 
 
C.
Moderator: Cartographers

 rebelman
				rebelman
			



 
			natty_dread wrote:I was wrong

 gimil
				gimil
			













 
		gimil wrote:are you guys crazy? I think te image quality of bad spelers versions is much crisp, cleaner and legiable. Graphically superior.


 yeti_c
				yeti_c
			













 
		yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:are you guys crazy? I think te image quality of bad spelers versions is much crisp, cleaner and legiable. Graphically superior.
Legibility is the only thing that the new version has superior...
Evilotto's is brilliant with a) strategy, b) LnF, c) Namings, d) Images
C.

natty_dread wrote:I was wrong

 gimil
				gimil
			













 
		gimil wrote:yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:are you guys crazy? I think te image quality of bad spelers versions is much crisp, cleaner and legiable. Graphically superior.
Legibility is the only thing that the new version has superior...
Evilotto's is brilliant with a) strategy, b) LnF, c) Namings, d) Images
C.
I mspeaking of graphical competance nothing else


 yeti_c
				yeti_c
			













 
		
 Coleman
				Coleman
			












 
		yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:are you guys crazy? I think te image quality of bad spelers versions is much crisp, cleaner and legiable. Graphically superior.
Legibility is the only thing that the new version has superior...
Evilotto's is brilliant with a) strategy, b) LnF, c) Namings, d) Images
C.
I mspeaking of graphical competance nothing else
Well I SOOOOOOOOO disagree...
In fact you're the one who's crazy... Otto's is much nicer.
C.
 )
 )
 rebelman
				rebelman
			



 
			rebelman wrote:yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:yeti_c wrote:gimil wrote:are you guys crazy? I think te image quality of bad spelers versions is much crisp, cleaner and legiable. Graphically superior.
Legibility is the only thing that the new version has superior...
Evilotto's is brilliant with a) strategy, b) LnF, c) Namings, d) Images
C.
I mspeaking of graphical competance nothing else
Well I SOOOOOOOOO disagree...
In fact you're the one who's crazy... Otto's is much nicer.
C.
Yeti, there is an obvious explanation for gimil's views he and bad speler are clearly multis, (check any of gimil's posts or early map drafts for proof of this)
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong

 gimil
				gimil
			













 
		Coleman wrote:the new map is the only viable one. However it could borrow somethings people liked about the old one.
What I'd suggest. Take those extra pixels and make it 840 by 800. Don't change the play area size. Make it look like it is on a table. Add some money for ascetics, you don't need to play on them like the old one. Maybe make the goofy blue legend look more like a rule card sitting on the table.

 Coleman
				Coleman
			












 
		i like what this coleman suggestedColeman wrote:the new map is the only viable one. However it could borrow somethings people liked about the old one.
What I'd suggest. Take those extra pixels and make it 840 by 800. Don't change the play area size. Make it look like it is on a table. Add some money for ascetics, you don't need to play on them like the old one. Maybe make the goofy blue legend look more like a rule card sitting on the table.
 bryguy
				bryguy
			





 
		Coleman wrote:the new map is the only viable one. However it could borrow somethings people liked about the old one.
What I'd suggest. Take those extra pixels and make it 840 by 800. Don't change the play area size. Make it look like it is on a table. Add some money for ascetics, you don't need to play on them like the old one. Maybe make the goofy blue legend look more like a rule card sitting on the table.

 Night Strike
				Night Strike
			



















 
		

 Bad Speler
				Bad Speler
			









 
			Thanks very much, I wasn't exactly sure if it ended up well.Coleman wrote:That's already leaps and bounds better.

 Bad Speler
				Bad Speler
			









 
			
 rebelman
				rebelman
			



 
			Bad Speler wrote:Took many of the suggestions...havent gotten around to some of them yet. Tried a new wooden background. Having trouble making the legend look like paper, but I'm still working at it.

 cena-rules
				cena-rules
			














 
		cena-rules wrote:1) on the ships if there is a blue on ship 1 it will be hard to see etc
2) are you having army circles can you put them on please

 Bad Speler
				Bad Speler
			









 
			Return to Melting Pot: Map Ideas
Users browsing this forum: No registered users