Deadwood Mafia Its all over! Thanks for playing

[Iliad]

Sheriff Bullock has not been having a very good week, each day he has to preside over a hanging and each night bodies pile up. This morning was no different. He found his business partner, Sol Star, dead on the floor of their hardware store. He had a tiny 2-shot .22 pistol in his hand and a hole in the side of his head. There was a note pinned to his jacket that simply read, “I miss her.” Also found dead was Doc Cochran. He had been blasted with a shotgun. To which Al Swearengen was heard to say, “Now who’s going to look after the whores' snatches!” The last body of the morning was found in Chinamen’s Alley. Mr. Wu, leader of the camp’s Chinese workers and town butcher, had been stabbed from behind. Bullock had seen both killing methods before.

Sierra Leon (Inventor/Lover) Sol Star is dead.
Nagerous (Doc) Doc Cochran is dead.
Mandalorian2298 (Gem saloon mafia janitor) is dead.

here's something really itneresting. If you guys remeber I told you that mandy went to AD. Gem saloon mafia tried to kill AD because he was immune to nightkills. Except then how did he die this night.

So either mandy was trying to clean up what would've been his dead body or using a hat

[Serbia]

Grrr, Dead! Good luck Townies!

[Clive]

vote f1th

Unless I can find a better home for my vote.

[Clive]

SL, u missed koesen

[Sierra_Leon]

Whoops, right you are. EBWOP:

Howdy all! I'm back to replace skittles.

11 people left alive:

1) Iliad
2) CrabNebula 2.0 (replaces) Russianfire
3) pancake (replaces) JND
6) Skoffin
7) Clive 2.0(replces) TWO
9) Sierra Leon 2.0 (replaces) Skittles! (replaces) Roger Dodger
12) LSU 2.0(replaces) Dustn64
13) F1fth
14) Lord Voldemort
17) Diddle
26) koesen 2.0 (replaces) lalaland 2.0 (replaces) willis


3 gem saloon mafia dead and 3 hearst mafia dead. Judging by the numbers in this game, I think having 8 scum on 26 people is a good guess. Gem saloon had a janitor, so I'm guessing hearst mafia still as a power role left in their ranks. That would leave gem saloon with a goon.

I took my time to read the game through again yesterday, so I have my suspicions. I'd like to hear from other people first though. So who's scum?

[Sierra_Leon]

vote f1th

Unless I can find a better home for my vote.

You've been voting f1fth for several days now, but I can't find where you explained why you think he's scum. Could you explain it to me again please, or quote a post where you explained earlier?

[Clive]

vote f1th

Unless I can find a better home for my vote.

You've been voting f1fth for several days now, but I can't find where you explained why you think he's scum. Could you explain it to me again please, or quote a post where you explained earlier?

I think he's scum because of his play on day 1. Dind't it at all. At it's not because he got me lynched, it's because I think he's scum.

Btw, I'm pretty sure SL is town, cos he's replaced RD, who I thought was town.

[Clive]

skoffin what are all your results?

[Anarkistsdream]

SONOFABITCH!!!!!

[F1fth]

I don't what else to say Clive except that my actions from day 1 are not a very good reason to think I'm scum.

Now assuming Koesen's analysis of the day scenes a while back was correct, it would mean Mafia A killed ExplainThis, Mafia B killed AD, and the Vig killed Serbia, correct?
'
It's a damn shame we lost our cop without getting any information from him.

[CrabNebula]

Too bad my theory couldn't be tested as AD died...

[CrabNebula]

Oh and requesting Iliad and Skoffin for results.

[Clive]

I don't what else to say Clive except that my actions from day 1 are not a very good reason to think I'm scum.

Now assuming Koesen's analysis of the day scenes a while back was correct, it would mean Mafia A killed ExplainThis, Mafia B killed AD, and the Vig killed Serbia, correct?
'
It's a damn shame we lost our cop without getting any information from him.

Well, we should look back from "breadcrumbing".

What did Iliad claim btw?

[CrabNebula]

Tracker iirc.

[Clive]

Yeh, found Iliad's claim of tracker. Looks like skoffin is completely cleared. Think Iliad is telling the truth too.

Don't think vig would have killed Serbia, everyone thought he was town, and he was playing well.

I checked back and the only thing Serbis seemed to hint at was a guilty on Mandy.

[Clive]

So, way I see it, SL, Iliad, skoffin, LSU are clear, and Diddle is possibly clear.

That leaves, (me) Koesen.2 Fifth Pancake CN.2 LV

And we have 2 scum left, right?

Pancake is completely submarining. I think we should put some pressure on him...

[CrabNebula]

I could have cleared myself if AD didn't die yesterday night. ANyway, I'll reread last few pages. I don't remember what is happening.

[Clive]

I could have cleared myself if AD didn't die yesterday night. ANyway, I'll reread last few pages. I don't remember what is happening.

How so?

And why won't it work now?

[Sierra_Leon]

We can get just a little bit more than that. The fact that Serbia didn't leave any clues tells me that he didn't get any guilty results on his investigations. This means that anyone he investigated was innocent (unless he was roleblocked). He was likely to investigate someone he thought was scummy.

In Serbia's case, the only person left who he was really suspicious of at some point was Clive. This is no solid proof that Clive is innocent, but it's enough for me to focus on other people for now.

At the end of day 4 he FOSsed Iliad. This only means he didn't investigate Iliad (yet), not that he got a guilty on him. I actually think it would suggest he investigated Iliad night 4 and got a town result, so I'm leaning toward Iliad really being what he says he is. Again: no solid proof, just hunches.

Day 5 Serbia FOSsed Koesen for attempting to get the cop to claim. Again, this probably means that he hadn't investigated Koesen yet, and since he's dead now I'm afraid this lead on Koesen is completely useless. It might have been the reason he got killed though.

[CrabNebula]

I could have cleared myself if AD didn't die yesterday night. ANyway, I'll reread last few pages. I don't remember what is happening.

How so?

And why won't it work now?

That would probably require me to claim and I don't think its quite necessary now since it gives no new information.

[lord voldemort]

well so far those summary's seem pretty alright. not much to add cept i wont be here for about 36 hours

[Skoffin]

Followed Koesen hoping he'd be one of the ones killed, well... it'd be good for results y'know Koesie , nothing happened.

I have to go out nao, so I may have moar to say when I get back.

[Clive]

LSU, did u kill?

Looks like koesen is clear too.

[pancakemix]

So, way I see it, SL, Iliad, skoffin, LSU are clear, and Diddle is possibly clear.

That leaves, (me) Koesen.2 Fifth Pancake CN.2 LV

And we have 2 scum left, right?

Pancake is completely submarining. I think we should put some pressure on him...

It's only submarining if I don't post without good reason but still keep up on the thread. I'm trying my best to be active, but I've other things I want to do in RL that take precedence, and I can foresee this being occupied lengthening itself in the coming week.

[Iliad]

Oh and requesting Iliad and Skoffin for results.

I was suspicous of ET so I followed him. He didn't go anywhere