Moderator: Cartographers
Juan_Bottom wrote:Well, three actually....
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
RjBeals wrote:Looking good carins.
- castle looks fine to me.
- moon & witch & graveyard look great.
- I don't care for the texture underneath the colors. Looks to "shiny" or something. I would prfer a grainy dirt texture.
- Sky should be darker blue
- I don't think purple should be a color choice. Why not brown instead? or dark green?
- I think the spider web should look more like a web, now it's just an oval.
- Could the ocean not come to a point at the land? Maybe add some foam or wave crashes?
- I like this legend better. I would vote keep it, just maybe add a slight texture behind the solid brown. or maybe a tiny gradient.
- Maybe add a dark outline to the cauldron bubble instead of white. dunno though. Would have to see it.
- If you really want to wow me, add a zombie grabbing and peeking from behind a tombstone
- but I won't hold you to that one.
- What about this - have the map brighter in the center where the moon is, then fade out darker around the edges where the moonlight would be dimmer?
cairnswk wrote:RjBeals wrote:Looking good carins.
- castle looks fine to me.
- moon & witch & graveyard look great.
- I don't care for the texture underneath the colors. Looks to "shiny" or something. I would prfer a grainy dirt texture.
- Sky should be darker blue
- I don't think purple should be a color choice. Why not brown instead? or dark green?
- I think the spider web should look more like a web, now it's just an oval.
- Could the ocean not come to a point at the land? Maybe add some foam or wave crashes?
- I like this legend better. I would vote keep it, just maybe add a slight texture behind the solid brown. or maybe a tiny gradient.
- Maybe add a dark outline to the cauldron bubble instead of white. dunno though. Would have to see it.
- If you really want to wow me, add a zombie grabbing and peeking from behind a tombstone
- but I won't hold you to that one.
- What about this - have the map brighter in the center where the moon is, then fade out darker around the edges where the moonlight would be dimmer?
Rj...would you like to take this map and do it yourself?
RjBeals wrote:
- castle looks fine to me.
- moon & witch & graveyard look great.
Too bad.I don't care for the texture underneath the colors. Looks to "shiny" or something. I would prfer a grainy dirt texture.
I know. it's not finished yet.Sky should be darker blue
I don't think purple should be a color choice. Why not brown instead? or dark green?
Will work on that.I think the spider web should look more like a web, now it's just an oval.
Could the ocean not come to a point at the land? Maybe add some foam or wave crashes?
That i can work on.I like this legend better. I would vote keep it, just maybe add a slight texture behind the solid brown. or maybe a tiny gradient.
No leave it as it is, the grey outline shows the border clearly.Maybe add a dark outline to the cauldron bubble instead of white. dunno though. Would have to see it.
I don't wan to wow you, the zombie is for the zombie map that natewolfman wants to do...you can perahps work on that with him.If you really want to wow me, add a zombie grabbing and peeking from behind a tombstone - but I won't hold you to that one.
I can accept that one.What about this - have the map brighter in the center where the moon is, then fade out darker around the edges where the moonlight would be dimmer?
Androidz wrote:=D> Cairnswk i love it!!!Your the man!!!Your The MAN you know!! The man is you! Dont ever forget.
(unless your a girl then its.) Your the Girl!!!! Your the GIRL you know!! The Girl is you! Dont ever forget.
But i need to bitch about one thing tough, the legend i want you to change back to the stone sign you had before. The brown dont fitt at all.
Also the Dragon might be a little abscent of the map right now:O
And instead of use * cant you try like rjbeals did with diffrent armycircle? He used some sort of X. or something.
And your Carinswk signature fitts perfectly in the legend at the emeyspace. I think it will fitt better there..
cairnswk wrote:Androidz wrote:=D> Cairnswk i love it!!!Your the man!!!Your The MAN you know!! The man is you! Dont ever forget.
(unless your a girl then its.) Your the Girl!!!! Your the GIRL you know!! The Girl is you! Dont ever forget.
But i need to bitch about one thing tough, the legend i want you to change back to the stone sign you had before. The brown dont fitt at all.
Also the Dragon might be a little abscent of the map right now:O
And instead of use * cant you try like rjbeals did with diffrent armycircle? He used some sort of X. or something.
And your Carinswk signature fitts perfectly in the legend at the emeyspace. I think it will fitt better there..
Yes well lets forget about the girl eh!
Some of those things i will work on. The legend is staying as is but the brown texture will probably be altered.
The dragon will go.
The symbols can change.
Signature stays in the web.
Thanks.
cairnswk wrote:Rj...would you like to take this map and do it yourself?
RjBeals wrote:cairnswk wrote:Rj...would you like to take this map and do it yourself?
no.
but you want feedback don't you.
foregone wrote:Love the mist. Looks great.
I really like the colours as they are now visually. But it seems difficult to distinguish between some of them. Animal Farm and Death's Door isn't hugely clear, but its also not horrifically difficult. I'm struggling a bit to see where Death's Door and Witches' Way end/begin though.
Witches' Way is also a little difficult to read on the legend.
And I know you've addressed this but I thought I'd throw in my 2 cents anyway. The border on the cauldron is a little bright for my liking. It detracts a little bit from the beauty of the rest of the map in my opinion.
The map is definitely emitting the right feeling for me now though.
And I've been fast posted.
edbeard wrote:It looks cool but I can't really see the difference between death's door and witch's way
cairnswk wrote:Oh dear, you must be all bloody colour blind.![]()
edbeard wrote:cairnswk wrote:Oh dear, you must be all bloody colour blind.![]()
no it's just that you've picked colours that almost blend together. if you really think that undertaker's plot and skeleton closet won't be mistaken for being part of witch's way
that's just what happens when you do the colours with a gradient like that. relatedly, broomstick base is completely different colour than Fallow field and Voodoo Vault. So, this only adds to the problem of people figuring out what territories belong to which continent.
It looks fine if it's just a picture but begs the question what's going on with these colours? And, no offense, but maybe the problem is on your end because that's always been the major issue with this map.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users