Moderator: Cartographers
whitestazn88 wrote:[Edited to remove bias based on "knowing" the mapmaker of a certain entry.]
I'll just add another "way to go guys! they look great!" here instead of my analysis of a certain cartographers map in development in comparison to one of the maps presented in this competition
RjBeals wrote:whitestazn88 wrote:[Edited to remove bias based on "knowing" the mapmaker of a certain entry.]
I'll just add another "way to go guys! they look great!" here instead of my analysis of a certain cartographers map in development in comparison to one of the maps presented in this competition
Nice (deleted) post though White - Or should I say... Detective.
You think you know huh... I wish I could say.. O how I wish.
(edit) Oh, I voted for number-1. Is it brygry or wca - i forget, but it's got my vote.
samuelc812 wrote:I voted for Number 4
My guesses
1. wcaclimbing
2. Mibi
3. oaktown
4. RjBeals
I don't think mibi made map #2. With his impressive graphics for other maps, such as Trojan War, I would expect graphics more trojan war-ish from him, drawn with the style he has used before. I don't think he would use a tutorial for inspiration on how to create realistic terrain, because he has already showed that he has excellent realism skills from Trojan War. I wouldn't expect him to switch his style from what he had with trojan war to something so different. So I think it was someone else. I may be wrong, though. that wouldn't surprise me either.
That does not really make sense. Basically you are saying that anyone who uses a tutorial is not "doing" real work. SO anyone who uses mibi's tutorial is not really doing work either? Only the original artist of a concept can claim that it is his/her work.wcaclimbing wrote:my only guess is RJ for #4.
And that mibi did NOT do number two. I would expect him to draw his own terrain, like he did for Trojan War, not use a tutorial.
WidowMakers wrote:wcaclimbing wrote:my only guess is RJ for #4.
And that mibi did NOT do number two. I would expect him to draw his own terrain, like he did for Trojan War, not use a tutorial.
That does not really make sense. Basically you are saying that anyone who uses a tutorial is not "doing" real work. SO anyone who uses mibi's tutorial is not really doing work either? Only the original artist of a concept can claim that it is his/her work.
Basically I am saying a tutorial is not bad. It was not copied (it appears) just followed to get the same effect. How many tutorials or techniques have you developed yourself wca?
e_i_pi wrote:I am thoroughly surprised with the lack of votes. Sure, the map does not have that eye-popping juju, but it's absolutely beautiful in it's simplicity and workmanship. I really have no idea how it can be improved upon - there are maps in play that don't hold a candle to this one.
whitestazn88 wrote:RjBeals wrote:(edit) Oh, I voted for number-1. Is it brygry or wca - i forget, but it's got my vote.
bryguy hasn't finished a map yet... famine is in... final forge? vacation? i forget, but i'm looking forward to that one bry...
natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
djak. wrote:What's with 3 and 4's ALL CAPS?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users