War of the Triple Cult (Day 6)

[sheepofdumb]

Well, I think that the cult leader needs to be lynched today as if we let him live any longer he will get another recruit. (Not certain that he would succeed, but it is too great a risk) The real investigator may consider looking at pmc tonight (maybe will too?)
Do we think sheep told the truth about will being unrecognizable? If so that could mean will is cult?

I didn't say unrecognizable, just unrecruitable.

[sheepofdumb]

Haha your desperation is ridiculous, you just want to take me down with you because I caught you out.

You heard him he's the red cult leader he even admitted it. If your powers were killing yesterday then why did no-one die?

Better watch it boy or I'll make sure you're dead.

When you recruit someone that night they can't use their power that same night. That's why no one died.

[sheepofdumb]

Sorry for triple posting but one last though. If Pmc was recruited last night that would make him a cult SK. Besides, lynching me would mean you lose your one solid connection to cult information. I'm offering to use the tools I have to hunt down the other two cults. I will know what roles cults will gain and I have an investigation and night kill. Think about it. You lose a hunted down cult leader and you lose an edge that you wouldn't have otherwise. Voting who you want night killed by FOSing. It's all up to the town.

[sheepofdumb]

Again apologies for quadruple posting. I re-read the night kill. If a townie is killed the killer will be revealed to the town. I'm built for cult hunting.

[spiesr]

Well, I think that the cult leader needs to be lynched today as if we let him live any longer he will get another recruit. (Not certain that he would succeed, but it is too great a risk) The real investigator may consider looking at pmc tonight (maybe will too?)
Do we think sheep told the truth about will being unrecognizable? If so that could mean will is cult?

I didn't say unrecognizable, just unrecruitable.

I meant to type unrecruitable but spell check changed it on me.

So sheep is supposedly offering his cult's services to the town if we leave him alive. I don't really trust him and are not sure that that would be a wise course of action...

[pmchugh]

Good job pmc, you caught me in my lie. I'm Red cult leader. My cult members gain powers. Yesterday it was killing and the day before that it was investigation. Night two I investigated Will and found him to be immune to recruitment. Therefore, PMC IS CULT. I guarantee it. So I'll cut the town a deal. If you let me live I will help hunt cult. At the end of the game I will give you the names of all my cult members and town can win. Take it or not it's up to you.

Wait, hang on I read this wrong first time. You are saying you know will is unrecrutiable and so are you so therefore I must have been recruited but this is wrong.

The investigation only checks if someone was a recruitment target not if they were actually recruited. Meaning that will or you could have been targetted by the green/blue cult and thats what triggered the result and I can asure that this is the case. This means you have absolutely no evidence against me.

Right now sheep has a 3 man strong cult that has the ability to recruit and kill.

Sheep unless you give us the name of your killer we can't keep you alive, and then you have to try and recruit an uncrecuitable target so you don't grow. This way you can investigate report back to us and stay alive otherwise you have to be lynched today.

[sheepofdumb]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

[pmchugh]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

[Stroop]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

If we don't kill sheep, he'll recruit someone else (perhaps with a special ability as well) to try and increase his cult's chances of winning without him.

[sheepofdumb]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

If we don't kill sheep, he'll recruit someone else (perhaps with a special ability as well) to try and increase his cult's chances of winning without him.

Discussion! Good! I like it. I can give you my word I won't but really, it wouldn't make a difference would it?

[Stroop]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

If we don't kill sheep, he'll recruit someone else (perhaps with a special ability as well) to try and increase his cult's chances of winning without him.

Discussion! Good! I like it. I can give you my word I won't but really, it wouldn't make a difference would it?

No... No, it wouldn't.

Plus, we have no guarantee that you actually provide a useful name. We can check it by lynching or someone can check it during the night; the first leaves you (cult leader) alive, the other still allows your killer to kill.

unvote vote sheep - to emphasize that everyone should.

[william18]

Good job pmc, you caught me in my lie. I'm Red cult leader. My cult members gain powers. Yesterday it was killing and the day before that it was investigation. Night two I investigated Will and found him to be immune to recruitment. Therefore, PMC IS CULT. I guarantee it. So I'll cut the town a deal. If you let me live I will help hunt cult. At the end of the game I will give you the names of all my cult members and town can win. Take it or not it's up to you.

Wait, hang on I read this wrong first time. You are saying you know will is unrecrutiable and so are you so therefore I must have been recruited but this is wrong.

The investigation only checks if someone was a recruitment target not if they were actually recruited. Meaning that will or you could have been targetted by the green/blue cult and thats what triggered the result and I can asure that this is the case. This means you have absolutely no evidence against me.

Right now sheep has a 3 man strong cult that has the ability to recruit and kill.

Sheep unless you give us the name of your killer we can't keep you alive, and then you have to try and recruit an uncrecuitable target so you don't grow. This way you can investigate report back to us and stay alive otherwise you have to be lynched today.

I think sheep means that when he tried to recruit me, it didn't succeeded. Which means stroop protects against red, or sheep was the person that tripped stroops senses.I wonder if stroop will enlighten us which cult he's effective against to help us. Either scenario, that means Sheep only has 2 cults. Any way if sheep tells us his killer, then we should keep him.

[pmchugh]

This is fine by me. If my killer is revealed though it will counteract a pro-town NK. He'll probably be the first to die.

I want the other townies consent before I reveal who my NK is.

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

If we don't kill sheep, he'll recruit someone else (perhaps with a special ability as well) to try and increase his cult's chances of winning without him.

Discussion! Good! I like it. I can give you my word I won't but really, it wouldn't make a difference would it?

No... No, it wouldn't.

Plus, we have no guarantee that you actually provide a useful name. We can check it by lynching or someone can check it during the night; the first leaves you (cult leader) alive, the other still allows your killer to kill.

unvote vote sheep - to emphasize that everyone should.

unvote I disagree, we can make sure he recruits a specific person by forcing him to recruit an unrectuitable person and checking that person for recruitment.

It makes sense to get as much info as possible and if that means keeping a cult leader alive then so be it, so long as he doesn't recruit.

Sheep what do you get if you recruit tonight?

[william18]

Everyone should agree to this, otherwise if we kill sheep we will have an unknown killer on the loose.

If we don't kill sheep, he'll recruit someone else (perhaps with a special ability as well) to try and increase his cult's chances of winning without him.

Discussion! Good! I like it. I can give you my word I won't but really, it wouldn't make a difference would it?

No... No, it wouldn't.

Plus, we have no guarantee that you actually provide a useful name. We can check it by lynching or someone can check it during the night; the first leaves you (cult leader) alive, the other still allows your killer to kill.

unvote vote sheep - to emphasize that everyone should.

unvote I disagree, we can make sure he recruits a specific person by forcing him to recruit an unrectuitable person and checking that person for recruitment.

It makes sense to get as much info as possible and if that means keeping a cult leader alive then so be it, so long as he doesn't recruit.

Sheep what do you get if you recruit tonight?

Yeah, tell us what you get next.

[Stroop]

I think sheep means that when he tried to recruit me, it didn't succeeded. Which means stroop protects against red, or sheep was the person that tripped stroops senses.I wonder if stroop will enlighten us which cult he's effective against to help us. Either scenario, that means Sheep only has 2 cults. Any way if sheep tells us his killer, then we should keep him.

Sheep did not try to recruit you, he says he recruited two people and we've had two nights.

[sheepofdumb]

I wish I could but Nate hasn't told me, only saying they will get better... I don't see anywhere in the rules that say I can't quote PM's I get from him so in 24 hours given I am still alive and nate hasn't told me otherwise I will start posting PM's.

[spiesr]

I still think sheep should not be left alive. And no will, sheep did not try to recruit you last night and fail, because then he would not have an investigator and a recruiter, just 1 of the two because he would have only recruited 1 person if I understand his explanations correctly

[william18]

I still think sheep should not be left alive. And no will, sheep did not try to recruit you last night and fail, because then he would not have an investigator and a recruiter, just 1 of the two because he would have only recruited 1 person if I understand his explanations correctly

Oh yeah. Forgot about that. Damn then that means I revealed a bit of my role for no reason .

[Stroop]

unvote I disagree, we can make sure he recruits a specific person by forcing him to recruit an unrectuitable person and checking that person for recruitment.

It makes sense to get as much info as possible and if that means keeping a cult leader alive then so be it, so long as he doesn't recruit.

We can't make sure he tries to recruit one person. Yes, we can check if he actually does, but sheep will just recruit someone else to increase his cult's chances of winning. Sheep is revealed as a cult leader, all he can do now is try to get his cult as big as possible before we lynch him, and you're considering that we let him do that?

[spiesr]

Really, where?

Or do you mean your role of being a cult member and therefor unrecruitable to other cults?

[captainwalrus]

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

How do you "garentee" that pmc is cult? Your claim of being an investigatior is bogus. What is stopping us from lynching you? You claimed cult leader.
unvote I will not yet vote you, instead I will give you adiqit time to defend yourself. Nate, Vote Count please.

[pmchugh]

Wait so people are unwilling to be told who a cult killer is?

Right now we have complete control over sheep if he doesn't tell us who his killer is, we lynch him simple as.

[sheepofdumb]

I guess it's the price I pay for being active.

Claim time.

I'm an investigator that searches for cult stuff. I checked out pmc last night, kage night 1, and Stroop night 2. Kage and Stroop didn't turn out anything but I found some cult stuff on Pmc. I can guarantee a cult lynch with him.

How do you "garentee" that pmc is cult? Your claim of being an investigatior is bogus. What is stopping us from lynching you? You claimed cult leader.
unvote I will not yet vote you, instead I will give you adiqit time to defend yourself. Nate, Vote Count please.

ROFL

[captainwalrus]

ROFL

You laugh at the mob that is at your doorstep? Notice that I have been nice enough not to lynch you yet.

[sheepofdumb]

ROFL

You laugh at the mob that is at your doorstep? Notice that I have been nice enough not to lynch you yet.

No I laugh at a skimma!