Is the CC system of checks working?

[army of nobunaga]

Recently two guys definitely were one guy or definitely were in cahoots. The were acquitted and my thread deleted. I guess their IPS came up different... Although I have a program that can throw a spectrum of different Ips even as I type this.


The I run across two guys that seem to me were not cheating and am watching as one loses his upgraded account.

I would like to question the system and hold accountable the people and the hunters that accuse or not accuse.


This is the thread I am talking about. viewtopic.php?f=239&t=81979&view=unread#unread

I will not post the guys account that was definitely cheating against me, but one was a free 5 game new account, one was a paid 50 game account... all 5 games of the new account were against the other paid account (some 1 vs 1) ... and in the game i played, they didnt even attack each other until round 8 even when i busted out of the nuetral and saw the free account with a 20 army stack next to a 1 army guarded castle.

I for one do question the system... love the game.. love the people.. but I wonder about the system of fair play/ who checks it/ and who checks them.


thanx

[Serbia]

The system has definitely failed in this case here olkok falsely accused

HighlanderAttack is, at least in my mind, a respected member of the community, surely anyone who's been playing in tourneys the past year knows of him. If he says olkok is his cousin, I believe him. This bust smelled fishy from the get go, and sets a bad precedent. I will take turns at my office occasionally. You'll find that Big Jon, Ball, Lord_of_War also all take turns there, using the same IP address. Are we in danger of getting busted as multis too? And why wasn't HighlanderAttack busted? And seriously, why would you assume that an account belongs to the same person, when one is a premium, and the two have never played in the same game? Just doesn't make any sense at all.

I really hope CC does the right thing here and fully reinstates olkok, because this is a sham.

[lancehoch]

Recently two guys definitely were one guy or definitely were in cahoots. The were acquitted and my thread deleted. I guess their IPS came up different... Although I have a program that can throw a spectrum of different Ips even as I type this.

I told you that the accounts were not multis. You asked how you could get them looked at for a secret diplomacy issue and I told you to make a new post in that same thread and I would move it back into the open cases forum. The thread was not deleted, it was moved into the Closed Reports forum where all of the decided cases are moved.

[owenshooter]

Recently two guys definitely were one guy or definitely were in cahoots. The were acquitted and my thread deleted. I guess their IPS came up different... Although I have a program that can throw a spectrum of different Ips even as I type this.

I told you that the accounts were not multis. You asked how you could get them looked at for a secret diplomacy issue and I told you to make a new post in that same thread and I would move it back into the open cases forum. The thread was not deleted, it was moved into the Closed Reports forum where all of the decided cases are moved.

why do you even bother lance? some people are just never satisfied, and when they don't understand how things work they become frustrated and think they are being ignored... only so much can be done, and you have gone well above what is called for by responding to this thread...-0