Lord of the Rings mafia [Town wins]

[Minister Masket]

MM's has apparently stated that his strategy is to lurk until something happens, supposedly this would lessen the chances that whatever happens happens to him. This is a scum tactic so...
UNVOTE VOTE MM

I didn't say I would lurk, I said I wouldn't vote. Quite a difference there.
And a scum tactic is to "lessen the chances that whatever happens happens"?

What?

[spiesr]

And a scum tactic is to "lessen the chances that whatever happens happens"?
What?

To lessen the chances that whatever happens happens to themselves.
I meant that it seems like you are waiting for someone to screw up and get themselves lynched. And you are trying to avoid activity so that that doesn't happen to you.

[Minister Masket]

And a scum tactic is to "lessen the chances that whatever happens happens"?
What?

To lessen the chances that whatever happens happens to themselves.
I meant that it seems like you are waiting for someone to screw up and get themselves lynched. And you are trying to avoid activity so that that doesn't happen to you.

You are a puzzle sir.
How can I be "avoiding activity" if I'm replying to you?

[Thezzaruz]

Vote Falcomongo

Never heard of ya!

Mongo? I think that's a little politically incorrect

Might even call it harsh, mean or unimaginative.

Bandwagonning is wrong...

EXCEPT WHEN IT IS PMC'S MUM WE ARE BANDWAGGONING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


WHOS WITH ME???!

What you say, me going after pmc... Noo, I would never do that...



Will throw in a Vote Minister Masket just because I haven't done that in a long time.

[nagerous]

In all honesty, I didn't mean anything politically incorrect in the post, I just didn't check to spell his name properly.

[william18]

Vote Falcomongo

Never heard of ya!

Mongo? I think that's a little politically incorrect

Might even call it harsh, mean or unimaginative.

Bandwagonning is wrong...

EXCEPT WHEN IT IS PMC'S MUM WE ARE BANDWAGGONING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


WHOS WITH ME???!

What you say, me going after pmc... Noo, I would never do that...



Will throw in a Vote Minister Masket just because I haven't done that in a long time.

Don't forget the bold.

[Thezzaruz]

Will throw in a Vote Minister Masket just because I haven't done that in a long time.

An EBWOP to make it count...

[Minister Masket]

Yeah that's right! Ignore my reply where I point out your flawed "straw-grasping" logic!

[william18]

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

You seem awfully sure of how many mafia there are? You know who else is pretty sure how many mafia there are? The mafia!

Vote pmchugh

Checkmate.

Awfully sure? Yeah because words like "possibly" suggest I am 100% sure there is yeah makes sense.

I am now half way to a lynch for no apparent reason

Well your first post was a speculation about the game, usually scum do this, also as soon as I posted my vote on you, you immediately turned around with an OMGUS vote and voted for me. Now you are trying to say that we have no reason to get you closer towards a lynch.

So there are reasons, maybe not the best, but the best that we have so far I think.

Speculation helps town get a basis on what they should expect. Only a fool wouldn't take someone elses speculations with a grain of salt.

[pmchugh]

Well your first post was a speculation about the game, usually scum do this, also as soon as I posted my vote on you, you immediately turned around with an OMGUS vote and voted for me. Now you are trying to say that we have no reason to get you closer towards a lynch.

So there are reasons, maybe not the best, but the best that we have so far I think.

Erm the OMGUS vote was a joke hence the bit were I shouted "SCUM!" at you, hardly what I do when I am being serious.

As for the speculation since when do scum normally speculate? They are less likely to do so as they already know the main part of the setup and it also limits fake claims, i.e. I may not have been suspected if I had claimed Elrond but since I didn't mention him then I can't claim him, ask thez if you don't believe me. In batman he guessed the setup and then claimed a role he didn't put in there unspurprisingly we lynched him and he was scum.

[Thezzaruz]

Yeah that's right! Ignore my reply where I point out your flawed "straw-grasping" logic!

Who ignored what??? No reason to get desperate already MM...

[Minister Masket]

Yeah that's right! Ignore my reply where I point out your flawed "straw-grasping" logic!

Who ignored what??? No reason to get desperate already MM...

spiesr ignored my post on the previous page.

Also, nice try playing the "desperation" card on me. Too obvious though.

[william18]

Well your first post was a speculation about the game, usually scum do this, also as soon as I posted my vote on you, you immediately turned around with an OMGUS vote and voted for me. Now you are trying to say that we have no reason to get you closer towards a lynch.

So there are reasons, maybe not the best, but the best that we have so far I think.

Erm the OMGUS vote was a joke hence the bit were I shouted "SCUM!" at you, hardly what I do when I am being serious.

As for the speculation since when do scum normally speculate? They are less likely to do so as they already know the main part of the setup and it also limits fake claims, i.e. I may not have been suspected if I had claimed Elrond but since I didn't mention him then I can't claim him, ask thez if you don't believe me. In batman he guessed the setup and then claimed a role he didn't put in there unspurprisingly we lynched him and he was scum.

I didn't know what you mean by the bolded part.

[william18]

Well your first post was a speculation about the game, usually scum do this, also as soon as I posted my vote on you, you immediately turned around with an OMGUS vote and voted for me. Now you are trying to say that we have no reason to get you closer towards a lynch.

So there are reasons, maybe not the best, but the best that we have so far I think.

Erm the OMGUS vote was a joke hence the bit were I shouted "SCUM!" at you, hardly what I do when I am being serious.

As for the speculation since when do scum normally speculate? They are less likely to do so as they already know the main part of the setup and it also limits fake claims, i.e. I may not have been suspected if I had claimed Elrond but since I didn't mention him then I can't claim him, ask thez if you don't believe me. In batman he guessed the setup and then claimed a role he didn't put in there unspurprisingly we lynched him and he was scum.

I didn't know what you mean in the bolded part.

EBWOP

[pmchugh]

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

[william18]

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

there was no Alfred

[Falkomagno]

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

so, undoubtedly your role is in the list that you gave us later....

[pmchugh]

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

there was no Alfred

LMAO, what were the chacnes that the joker would claim him of all poeple

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

so, undoubtedly your role is in the list that you gave us later....

As a matter of fact yes it is, but it's a pretty broad claim

[william18]

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

there was no Alfred

LMAO, what were the chacnes that the joker would claim him of all poeple

In batman mafia thez was scum. At one point he said I think the setup goes like this:

Batman, Joker, Alfred, Two-face etc. etc.

Later on he fake-claimed a role he hadn't mentioned in his guess of the setup, Brian or something and we knew it was fake otherwise he would have mentioned it in his summation of the roles.

so, undoubtedly your role is in the list that you gave us later....

As a matter of fact yes it is, but it's a pretty broad claim

hmm lets disect.

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

lol the only broad claims are orcs and nazgul.

[pmchugh]

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

lol the only broad claims are orcs and nazgul.

Eh? I named 22 characters in a 15 player game. I find it unlikely anyone has a role not mentioned above. Maybe 1 or 2 but that's max.

[william18]

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

lol the only broad claims are orcs and nazgul.

Eh? I named 22 characters in a 15 player game. I find it unlikely anyone has a role not mentioned above. Maybe 1 or 2 but that's max.

Lots of roles. Grima wormtonge, Treebeard, Tom Bombadil, Grishnakh, Eiwer(sp) the eagle, Hama, Denethor, Elrond, Butterbur, Farmer maggot, Gaffer Gamgee.

[william18]

Although some of them are a bit out there.

[pmchugh]

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

lol the only broad claims are orcs and nazgul.

Eh? I named 22 characters in a 15 player game. I find it unlikely anyone has a role not mentioned above. Maybe 1 or 2 but that's max.

Lots of roles. Grima wormtonge, Treebeard, Tom Bombadil, Grishnakh, Eiwer(sp) the eagle, Hama, Denethor, Elrond, Butterbur, Farmer maggot, Gaffer Gamgee.

If Eiwer and Farmer maggot are both in this game I will never play mafia again. Maybe Grimer/ Treebeard/ Elrond but I don't see any of the others being included.

[Mr. Squirrel]

vote nag cause he's clearly saruman.

Likely roles, not that it really matters:
The 9 fellowship members.
Sauron
Saruman
Nazgul?
Another scum possibly. Lurtz or Orc or similar.

+2/3 others. Probably a 3rd party player, Gollum?
And probably 1 or 2 from Theoden/Eomer/Arwen/Farimir/Eowen/Elf dude that dies at Helms deep/Group of people e.g. Rohirrim. - Most fake claims will come from here probably.

lol the only broad claims are orcs and nazgul.

Eh? I named 22 characters in a 15 player game. I find it unlikely anyone has a role not mentioned above. Maybe 1 or 2 but that's max.

Lots of roles. Grima wormtonge, Treebeard, Tom Bombadil, Grishnakh, Eiwer(sp) the eagle, Hama, Denethor, Elrond, Butterbur, Farmer maggot, Gaffer Gamgee.

If Eiwer and Farmer maggot are both in this game I will never play mafia again. Maybe Grimer/ Treebeard/ Elrond but I don't see any of the others being included.

It would be hilarious if Tom Bombadil was in this. He was by far my favorite character in the books. Such a jolly, happy fellow. However, if the backround story is anything to go by, I think this scenario is following the movies instead of the books. Otherwise he would have mentioned Bombadil since frodo and sam visited him before reaching Rivendell.

[spiesr]

Yes, you seemed to have named a lot of really minor characters who will not be appearing in this game. Trying to leave all the fake claims open?