autoload's 19 Player Mafia Game #1 --- Day 1 ---

[supercram]

it seems to me that Mach is a very unpopular mafia player.......

now, this could lead to many suspects, but we NEED to narrow it down

ok, But first we should write out a list on suspects.

Ok, if we go with MB's theory as a starting point, that leaves:

RK
Nyvek
SuperCram
Senfive
Trestain
Incandenza
MB
Wicked
Onbekende
for dummies
kokunai
Houssam
Rodger Dodger
XenHu
P Gizzle
Fircoal

Someone pointed out Mafia would pick a target that was the greatest danger to themselves.(Mach solving a previous game) I tend to agree with that. Newbies wouldn't know Mach's skill level.
So, if we then shrink the list to experienced-only players, that leaves:

RK
SuperCram
Senfive
Trestain
Incandenza
MB
Wicked
Houssam
XenHu
P Gizzle

Can anyone help confirm or add to this?

lol

FOS Nyvek for attempting top keep himself above suspicion, claiming "noobness"

[P Gizzle]

I'm pretty sure wicked is mafia.

had the same suspicion with NY......but we'll see.....i'd rather take out an experienced player, than a newb

[Nyvek]

FOS Nyvek for attempting top keep himself above suspicion, claiming "noobness"

Well cram, not to oversimplify my..."noobness" but, with 11 posts currently to date, just how many Mafia games do you think I could have played?

However, a good point, voting shouldn't really be determined on "out of game" factors, as per the rules. But, we need a starting point. Please tell us where the scum are so we can begin lynching them.

[wicked]

that seems about right....if we take out some of the experienced mafia, if any, we'll be in a better position to win

whoa! that sounds like mafia to me! taking out experienced players (when you don't know if they're mafia) will only hurt you in this game.

[supercram]

Please tell us where the scum are so we can begin lynching them.

we'll never know that today, so your approach is as good as any.

i'm with MB and kyle for now, let's get some pressure built up.

vote wicked

[wicked]

just because I'm experienced?

[reverend_kyle]

I'm pretty sure wicked is mafia.

Why?

I've been playing mafia with wicked since it first came here, and I've sort of got a feel for the vibe she normally throws out so to speak, but she's been acting way different, on a diff vibe


Anyone else noticed?

[supercram]

just because I'm experienced?

no. because i want to see what comes out of the woodwork now that you have 2 votes on you.

[supercram]

I've been playing mafia with wicked since it first came here, and I've sort of got a feel for the vibe she normally throws out so to speak, but she's been acting way different, on a diff vibe
Anyone else noticed?

that's what houssam said in Finn Rock, and he was dead wrong.
and you were THERE

FOS reverend_kyle

[wicked]

I'm pretty sure wicked is mafia.

had the same suspicion with NY......but we'll see.....i'd rather take out an experienced player, than a newb

That makes zero sense if you're a townie PG. Someone throws out a random name and you jump on it for one of the stupidest reasons I've heard to date?

[P Gizzle]

that seems about right....if we take out some of the experienced mafia, if any, we'll be in a better position to win

whoa! that sounds like mafia to me! taking out experienced players (when you don't know if they're mafia) will only hurt you in this game.

then let's go with NY, for all i care....i just wanna win, i don't care how the town wins, just THAT we win

[wicked]

sounds like RK's trying to get me back for me saying he almost messed up the last game. if this was feedback, I'd delete it for revenge!

[supercram]

have we even heard from everybody yet? i say we lynch somebody quiet.

[P Gizzle]

I'm pretty sure wicked is mafia.

had the same suspicion with NY......but we'll see.....i'd rather take out an experienced player, than a newb

That makes zero sense if you're a townie PG. Someone throws out a random name and you jump on it for one of the stupidest reasons I've heard to date?

no, certain people i suspect due to the way the "talk"......you, for whatever reason came up. last time, i guessed both mafia, so we'll see about my skills now

[Nyvek]

have we even heard from everybody yet? i say we lynch somebody quiet.

<Bangs 2 pots together making an awful racket.>

[wicked]

I think we're still waiting on a few to post!

[P Gizzle]

quite a few.....


which is bad, cuz now there are all these people that COULD BE mafia, and we won't know until we lynch someone.....

[Nyvek]

MB's theory of players that confirmed pre-night:
RK
Nyvek
SuperCram
Senfive
Trestain
Incandenza
MB
Wicked
Onbekende
for dummies
kokunai
Houssam
Rodger Dodger
XenHu
P Gizzle
Fircoal

P Gizzle's experienced player cross-reference:
RK
SuperCram
Senfive
Trestain
Incandenza
MB
Wicked
Houssam
XenHu
P Gizzle

Folks that haven't posted yet:
Senfive
Wisse
onbekende
kokunai
Xenhu

Folks on all 3 lists:
Senfive
Xenhu

[wicked]

Senfive hasn't posted yet has he? Or Xenhu? Sen was embarrassed last game by Mach.

[wicked]

let's wait to hear from these guys before pressing any votes.

[supercram]

what page is MB's theory on, anyone know?

[wicked]

it was at the very beginning.

[supercram]

cheers wicked.

[Nyvek]

Supercram said: what page is MB's theory on, anyone know?

First thing's first

The 3 players I already trust in this game are Wisse, vgmmaster and Machiavelli, who are not mafia. Mach is easy to see now that he's dead.

Here's where I know this to be true.

3 more players need to Confirm by PM. I am going to go ahead and Officially put the game in Night One.

Those 3 players were the ones without X's next to their names, and they still dont have X's there. And they are Mach, vgmmaster and Wisse. Auto said he was gonna go ahead put the game in Night One. He would only do that if he received all confirming PMs from the Mafia, which mean those 3 are not.

So at this moment I trust whatever Wisse and vgmmaster say.

Ps. Sorry about the sloppy quoting, I haven't figured out how to quote from more than 1 location yet.

[Nyvek]

BTW Cram, that's the 2nd important point you've missed. The 1st was Cowboys not even being here.
That leads me to believe you are skimming the posts. A mafia would also skim the posts, not needing any insight on the situation because he already had the answers.