Most of the posts that call this bad judgement call for what it is reflect my personal view.
D.M. had a knack for rubbing Mods/Admins up the wrong way, while this is certainly irritating it was not to the greater detriment of the community. The only real casualty was the offended ego of the Mod/Admin behind the decision to permaban D.M.
The sort of things I'd expect someone to get permabanned from the forums are:
- Persistent biggotry.
- Persistent posting of pornography.
- Persistent spamming and derailing of topics.
- Persistent unauthorised advertisement of a competitors site on CC
- Persistent stalking of other players with intent to make their gaming experience unpleasant.
Persistently arguing the toss with the Mods/Admins(while it may be personally irritating for the Mods/Admins in question) does not in my opinion merit a permanent ban. If he's not making a valid point then by all means punish him with a vacation, but don't use the permanent ban just because you tire of having your decisions challenged and want to silence him for keeps. A permanent ban should be reserved for those truly virulent nasty pests that do nothing but disrupt the enjoyment of others and try to create as much chaos as possible.
There are plenty of players who personally irritate me a great deal, I've stuck them on my foe list, that does not mean I wish them to be permanently barred from the forum, nor should it be a reason to permaban someone. It takes no small amount of moral fortitude to admit to making a mistake, I hope the Mods/Admins in question consider those words carefully.