MAFIA - X-Men Legends [Game over -- Town wins!]

[Machiavelli]

Hm, a serial killer in the Mafia could be an option...but it would have to be a random choice, or 'inversed' SK...as one most likely wouldn't take out a fellow mafia member (unless it is part of strategy to confuse?).


--Andy

Actually, I was the Mafia SK in that game and the choices were not random. I don't understand why the SK would take out the mafia first, so, if my theory is correct, we have a newbie serial killer.

I was a serial killer before, and I went after twonies - but of course, just like the rest of us, the serial killer right now can't tell twonie from mafia. at least not yet. So I would not necessarily say it's a newbie SK.

QFE

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

[Fircoal]

Hm, a serial killer in the Mafia could be an option...but it would have to be a random choice, or 'inversed' SK...as one most likely wouldn't take out a fellow mafia member (unless it is part of strategy to confuse?).


--Andy

Actually, I was the Mafia SK in that game and the choices were not random. I don't understand why the SK would take out the mafia first, so, if my theory is correct, we have a newbie serial killer.

I was a serial killer before, and I went after twonies - but of course, just like the rest of us, the serial killer right now can't tell twonie from mafia. at least not yet. So I would not necessarily say it's a newbie SK.

QFE

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

FOS: Mach

[Machiavelli]

Any reason?

[sully800]

I honestly suggest we start looking at all the people trying to post doubt on me. I honestly have no suspects at all. Nothing to really go on except the people who have no understanding of what I wrote and want to attack me.

The last main person trying to post doubt on you was just proven to be innocent because he was killed at night. Also when you and MB were arguing before I was just getting a vibe that I agreed with him more than you and that you seemed a bit scummy. Once MB was proven to be innocent it reaffirmed my earlier thoughts.

Is it enough for me to want to lynch you? No, definitely not at this point. It's just the biggest lead I have to go on at the moment, hence the FOS. I understand that a smart mafia can frame townies by killing someone who was CONVINCED that a fellow townie was mafia. So its a tough call to make and I would rather have a lot more discussion before placing a vote for anyone.

[wicked]

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

huh?

[Machiavelli]

Hm, a serial killer in the Mafia could be an option...but it would have to be a random choice, or 'inversed' SK...as one most likely wouldn't take out a fellow mafia member (unless it is part of strategy to confuse?).


--Andy

Actually, I was the Mafia SK in that game and the choices were not random. I don't understand why the SK would take out the mafia first, so, if my theory is correct, we have a newbie serial killer.

I was a serial killer before, and I went after twonies - but of course, just like the rest of us, the serial killer right now can't tell twonie from mafia. at least not yet. So I would not necessarily say it's a newbie SK.

QFE

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

FOS: Mach

So you think there is a SK?

Are you sure? Because I know that there's not.

Go ahead, try to explain why there is a SK. I will be able to convince everyone you are wrong, and maybe you will be exposed as mafia in the process.


But dont back down now, make my day.

[Machiavelli]

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

huh?

Wicked, think about auto's last game, but dont give away what I am getting at when you understand.

[wicked]

I am convinced of nada in this game, as far as roles go.

[Machiavelli]

by auto's last game, I meant the 12 player game when I was the cop...


At least tell me you understand what I am getting at, even if you disagree with me.

[Fircoal]

Hm, a serial killer in the Mafia could be an option...but it would have to be a random choice, or 'inversed' SK...as one most likely wouldn't take out a fellow mafia member (unless it is part of strategy to confuse?).


--Andy

Actually, I was the Mafia SK in that game and the choices were not random. I don't understand why the SK would take out the mafia first, so, if my theory is correct, we have a newbie serial killer.

I was a serial killer before, and I went after twonies - but of course, just like the rest of us, the serial killer right now can't tell twonie from mafia. at least not yet. So I would not necessarily say it's a newbie SK.

QFE

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

FOS: Mach

So you think there is a SK?

Are you sure? Because I know that there's not.

Go ahead, try to explain why there is a SK. I will be able to convince everyone you are wrong, and maybe you will be exposed as mafia in the process.


But dont back down now, make my day.

I think that if your saying that your sure there is no SK, your trying to cover up the fact you are the SK, though this is only a thought.

Also, just because people believe there is an SK, does not make them suspicious.

[wicked]

Auto's game that's still going on? Sorry, I'm extremely sleep-deprived at this point, so won't ask for more details until I've had a chance to rest.

[wicked]

I'm vaguely remembering that Mach. I'm sure I'll get it once I've had a chance to rest. No need to explain for now.

[Machiavelli]

Just like a woman to say she's to tired

[wicked]

LOL

[Senfive]

He was arguing with Senfive a lot, almost fighting with him and I believe pointed a FOS but never voted for Senfive.

I think MB and Senfive have clashing personalities.

--Andy

Oh, I don't think MB investigated Senfive, since he was being accusatory toward Senfive. I do believe that MB investigated a townie because he would have tried to tip us off otherwise. So perhaps he was being accusatory toward Senfive and struck a bit of truth? Maybe Senfive felt threatened because MB was right and so Senfive bumped him off?

It's a reach I know, and can't be proven, but whenever a townie is killed I think its helpful to look at who they were suspicious of, or who they clashed with. For MB it seemed to be wicked, senfive and xenhu. I think the wicked vote was mostly a joke to start the day, so I will point another FOS at Senfive

As for your confidence in who MB investigated, I still am not seeing the reasoning Andy.

This is more evidence then we had killing xenhu. I'm going to go ahead and vote senfive as it seems he is the biggest lead, also he was in autoloads game with master bush and watched him pick off 5 mafia, and argued with him every time. It just makes sense.

RK way to go with what others are saying instead of looking and reading for yourself. Like I said. Look at sully and RK after you find out I am townie. I Rest my case. I am tired of the Townies being led around like a dog on a leash.

[Machiavelli]

Hm, a serial killer in the Mafia could be an option...but it would have to be a random choice, or 'inversed' SK...as one most likely wouldn't take out a fellow mafia member (unless it is part of strategy to confuse?).


--Andy

Actually, I was the Mafia SK in that game and the choices were not random. I don't understand why the SK would take out the mafia first, so, if my theory is correct, we have a newbie serial killer.

I was a serial killer before, and I went after twonies - but of course, just like the rest of us, the serial killer right now can't tell twonie from mafia. at least not yet. So I would not necessarily say it's a newbie SK.

QFE

FOS ANYONE WHO THINKS THERE IS AN SK

FOS: Mach

So you think there is a SK?

Are you sure? Because I know that there's not.

Go ahead, try to explain why there is a SK. I will be able to convince everyone you are wrong, and maybe you will be exposed as mafia in the process.


But dont back down now, make my day.

I think that if your saying that your sure there is no SK, your trying to cover up the fact you are the SK, though this is only a thought.

Also, just because people believe there is an SK, does not make them suspicious.

Are you sure there is a SK?


CAREFULLY reread the pm you got that told you your role, and then answer again.

[wicked]

OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! heh heh heh
got it. and yes, I agree.

[Machiavelli]

[Machiavelli]

If fircoal still doesnt change his mind, do you think it is condeming, or do you think he is just being stupid/oblivious?

I will vote him if he still thinks there is a SK, but I understand that the evidence may not be enough for everyone to put a vote behind.

[sully800]

And with that, wicked and Machiavelli make it onto my "I really think they are innocent" list. I wasn't in Autoload's game, nor did I read it, but I think I see exactly what you are getting at based on my win condition.

I'm going to go read up and figure it out, but if you're saying what I think you're saying then good detective work!

[Machiavelli]

This is why I'm hot. This is why, this is why I'm hot.

[sully800]

If fircoal still doesnt change his mind, do you think it is condeming, or do you think he is just being stupid/oblivious?

I will vote him if he still thinks there is a SK, but I understand that the evidence may not be enough for everyone to put a vote behind.

No, I don't think it is condemning evidence at all because it was just a matter of seeing exactly what you are seeing.

However I think it is good evidence for clearing the people who saw what you see first. Man that statement was confusing!

[wicked]

hmm, tough call. I think players in that game would know, but beyond that probably not. I think we better keep that particular info to ourselves for now (i.e. not broadcast it) until we can use it to back a mafia into a corner. Who else was in that game that would know? We could question them to make sure they got it.

[Machiavelli]

I dont think it fully clears wicked, because she is smart enough to know what I am getting at, and could easily just be mafia agreeing with me.


I'm definetely a townie though

[wicked]

This is why I'm hot. This is why, this is why I'm hot.

well granted you WERE hot in that game! and so far you're doing well in this one.