Timminz wrote:As long as the grand pubah can track his precious stats, without having to give any thought to outliers, or exceptions, then all is right with the world.
You know the ironic part, though?
In those games that BpB and G1 were forced to forfeit, BpB and G1
won the games. So the automatic stats are screwed up anyways unless jp "gives thought to outliers or exceptions".
Chariot of Fire wrote:so it's hardly likely to be a glitch in the code.
Wrong. The
associated thread has been moved to the new "Bug Forum" meaning the mods designated it as a "glitch in the code". There have been multiple reports of this happening in that thread. Plus, it is easy to prove. Start up a triples game and send auto-join links to 4 players for the same team. The fourth player will automatically be assigned to the wrong team.
And Chariot, I'm not saying that this bug was caused by the clan mods. It's not their fault by any stretch of the imagination.
Fruitcake wrote:I am not saying it is a poor feature, or that I can think of anything better.
Eh, we've had no problems with merely not using the Auto Join feature when games are posted. It's worked for countless Clan Challenges, the first Clan League, and the second half of the second Clan League. Like I said before, if I ever get Auto Join links now I remove them before letting the clan decide who plays where.
jpcloet wrote:Wow, 1 game is such a big deal then eh.
Considering this entire league is coming down to "1 game" then yes, it is "such a big deal". I hope everyone realizes that I'm not arguing for the sake of G1. We've been out of the playoffs for quite a long time now. This only affects the BpB.
jpcloet wrote:Fine, prove to me with indisputable proof that RB entered into the game via the "site bug" and we'll have a rematch. Otherwise the evidence before us is that he joined the wrong team and was the 4th G1 member into the game.
Oh please. You know just as well as I do that there's no way to give you indisputable proof. But what is more likely? RB tried to join using the Auto Join that was given to him or he took the password and purposely joined the wrong team even though he saw his teammates on the other? Funny that you had no problem believing that the first happened at the time, but now that your prior excuses for a forfeit are ridiculed you change your stance.
Look, I don't think I can run the Clan League better than you. In fact, I
know that I can't. All I'm saying is that shit can happen that is not the sole fault of the players and the rules should be overlooked for such situations. Not everything is black and white.