Moderator: Community Team
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
pmchugh wrote:If I wasn't lazy, I would sig that
VioIet wrote:What do you mean that I am a little off? Elaborate please.
And I already said. I voted you because I didn't like your story. Can't believe more people are giving you a pass for that. If I was the mod- you would have been gone.
VioIet wrote:WTH Commander!! You have been skimming through all my post?? I do not take kindly to that.
lalaland, cena-rules, pmc, sensfan,
Yet you FOS me for being inactive. WTH
When have I been inactive this game? At the time you made that post- we had both posted twice on Day 2. So don't know where you got that from. Go FOS yourself.
That seriously irked me.
Oh well moving on.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
VioIet wrote:Commander, I think it is a bit hypocritical for you to point out my so-called "inactiveness" when up to that point- you had the same number of posts as I did.
And did you take a look at the length of my posts? Normally I wait until I have several things to say. I don't impulsively post to answer a quick question or make a quick response as I am doing tonight.
I don't need to re-read what you wrote- I read it thoroughly. And I was all with you until you called me inactive. Again, may I repeat WTH!!!
I will probably re-read it eventually, as every few days- I re-read the past few pages in the thread.
I don't take this "inactiveness" claim lightly, as you are trying to throw suspicion on me for a bs reason.
strike wolf wrote:Ahh the pun involving my user name is killing me. To be completely truthful I get that "I don't really have anything to point to this but he just strikes me as possible scum" feeling with Ga7 all the time but that's getting side tracked from the topic at hand.
In all seriousness, I've rethought out my vote again. My original reason for unvoting Aage was that he had no visible connection with blake the only confirmed scum in the game. On reexamination while that does help support a case for him being an overzealous townie, there is a chance that he could be part of another non-town group and if that is the case it is best to flush them out early in the game rather than discover them late. For that reason Unvote vote aage.
That being said I still really do not like Jace in this game. I just do not trust him. I already presented the evidence of his connections with blake (blake stepping out to defend him and similar voting patterns) plus after calling him out today he gave a quick defense, voted on the Aage wagon quickly and disappeared again as things were moving more that way. So yeah over night, I think Jace is a valid subject to look into.
VioIet wrote:What do you mean that I am a little off? Elaborate please.
And I already said. I voted you because I didn't like your story. Can't believe more people are giving you a pass for that. If I was the mod- you would have been gone.
Victor Sullivan wrote:Thanks for the answers, herk, I'm glad to see my vote caught your attention![]()
theherkman wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:Thanks for the answers, herk, I'm glad to see my vote caught your attention![]()
Yeah, no prob. Buncha speed games, all those Oasis quads... Got like 70 games right now. I didn't really take the time to answer you until you voted me. Then I was like, "Well f*ck, I better explains my shizzz..." Lol!
theherkman wrote:VioIet wrote:What do you mean that I am a little off? Elaborate please.
And I already said. I voted you because I didn't like your story. Can't believe more people are giving you a pass for that. If I was the mod- you would have been gone.
Okay, Vi, the story was a little bit of humor. I posted one line about shooting the next person to make a sound. Flow was being a naughty bitch and mocked me. It made me a little upset and I took the opportunity to write a story. It was a joke. You want to kill me for that? Scummy... That might be a little off...
On reexamination while that does help support a case for him being an overzealous townie, there is a chance that he could be part of another non-town group and if that is the case it is best to flush them out early in the game rather than discover them late. For that reason Unvote vote aage.
aage wrote:theherkman wrote:VioIet wrote:What do you mean that I am a little off? Elaborate please.
And I already said. I voted you because I didn't like your story. Can't believe more people are giving you a pass for that. If I was the mod- you would have been gone.
Okay, Vi, the story was a little bit of humor. I posted one line about shooting the next person to make a sound. Flow was being a naughty bitch and mocked me. It made me a little upset and I took the opportunity to write a story. It was a joke. You want to kill me for that? Scummy... That might be a little off...
Er, "story" might mean multiple things.
Aage wrote:Still, I find it hilarious how you think I'm trying to get you killed because I'm so upset I couldn't kill you last night, rant rant fistshake.
theherkman wrote:Aage wrote:Still, I find it hilarious how you think I'm trying to get you killed because I'm so upset I couldn't kill you last night, rant rant fistshake.
This is the only reason I am being voted. Because I couldn't be NK'd.
aage wrote:theherkman wrote:VioIet wrote:What do you mean that I am a little off? Elaborate please.
And I already said. I voted you because I didn't like your story. Can't believe more people are giving you a pass for that. If I was the mod- you would have been gone.
Okay, Vi, the story was a little bit of humor. I posted one line about shooting the next person to make a sound. Flow was being a naughty bitch and mocked me. It made me a little upset and I took the opportunity to write a story. It was a joke. You want to kill me for that? Scummy... That might be a little off...
Er, "story" might mean multiple things.
Still, I find it hilarious how you think I'm trying to get you killed because I'm so upset I couldn't kill you last night, rant rant fistshake.On reexamination while that does help support a case for him being an overzealous townie, there is a chance that he could be part of another non-town group and if that is the case it is best to flush them out early in the game rather than discover them late. For that reason Unvote vote aage.
You hypocrit, this is my exact argument for killing TheHerkman.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
theherkman wrote:Haggis seems REALLY scummy. Doesn't seem to be too active, yet not skimming/lurking. Comes out to post every so often, even voting. BTW - I was the one who put together the post links. Not you. You copied my post and updated it. I spent an hour making those links and that post. It's quite rude to claim you did it.
theherkman wrote:spiesr wrote:What evidence do you have against aage, apart from him voting for you today? This looks a lot like you just omgusing everyone who votes for you still.
And spiesr is now on my mafia list. Good job outing yourself. =D This game is looking better and better!
Haha, I can't help but laugh. You're gonna defend someone for wanting to kill a pro-town role. This is great! Lol!
theherkman wrote:Oh, also, just wanted to throw this out there. Was reading another CC mafia and just wanted to say something for the cop. If you can talk to Mr. S and he relays messages between you and an unknown party, it is probably the mafia. Just an FYI.
TheSaxlad wrote:strike wolf wrote:Mr. Squirrel wrote:Players:
1. chu
2. edocsil
3. vic
4. ga7
5. Theherkman
6. pmc
7. AoG
8. lala
9. freezie
10. violet
11. haggis_mcmutton
12. cena
13. TG
14. Flores
15. commander
16. the saxlad
17. sensfan
18. karel
19. stike wolf
20. iliad
21. nag
22. /
23. spiesr
24. jace
25. ace
26. naxus
27. thez
28. mandy
29. blakebowling
30.dazerazer
Ok just thought I'd note this...I'm looking at this list and there are a few inactives like
Mandy who seems to have just disappeared
lalaland who's posted some but been fairly quiet throughout the day only confirming and making a comment about if he wasn't sure if mandy was role claiming or joking
PMC who was fairly active for about a day RL time and than disappeared
Karel who confirmed made one joke vote and than resurfaced today and made a relevant comment about the current suspect.
Thez who other than confirming his role has not posted.
Cena with the same scenario as Thez
And possibly a couple others that I have missed.
the activity has been fairly good in this game but thought I'd post this as in a game this size it is easy to miss the inactives.
Surely Pointing Out all the inactives, trying to draw the vote away from them is a scumtell?
FOS Strikewolf.
TheSaxlad wrote:Guys, This is my first mafia game as well.
I can assure you I am not mafia, and whether it be my death or whether the doc chooses to protect me, if a cop searches me and can back up I will roleclaim next round.
You dont have to back me openly, just dont vote for me.
TheSaxlad wrote:ok no role claiming then.
Is daze hung yet?
TheSaxlad wrote:theherkman wrote:edocsil wrote:Anyone else still curious how the hell herk knew there could be a punisher? It is one of the most obscure roles in the game
You've been skimming a lot. I don't know, I mentioned that there might be. I've also provided links to where I've read it.
strike wolf wrote:Well going back through his early posts. His first post showed he at least had some basic knowledge of cops and doctors coming into the game. Shortly after he mentioned that this was his first mafia game online. So he does possibly have more history in mafia than he has let on just on a different stage. I also don't like how he has for a large part of the game just echoed town sentiment. I do like that he went out of his way to make an extensive about specific activity in the game. But other than that he hasn't taken much of his own initiative except for trying to raise suspicion against anyone who has voted for him or questioned his logic (aog and commander)
True, I do know how to play, but it's a different dynamic playing online. More thought I think. It seems to me that there is more random blundering and less thought to games played in-person. It has also been a great number of years since my last game. I used to play as a young teen on church road trips. It was all we did. We made up our own flavors/factions/roles/everything and played for hours on end, game after game. Anyway, I digress. I'm not voting AOG again out of spiteor commander for his nonsense...
I have no FOS at AOG, and a strong one at commander, but I am not convinced he is scum.
And i do try.Do you know how long those linkys took? Hehe a long ass time.
so spending all your time trying to persuade us your not scum, by leading us off on the completely wrong track?
Small FOS herkman.
TheSaxlad wrote:freezie wrote:theherkman wrote:You should be keeping an eye on blakebowling. I say that I am have information about a doc and know who two trusted townies are and he votes me... HELLO? Did anyone miss this?
All I seen was you overreacting ONCE AGAIN calling out a single vote on you. A single vote and you call someone for '' trying to call a lynch on you''.
Dude, you're not at l-1..you're a l-a gazibillion votes.
Found this on page 47.
Herk You need to spill now. HTF did you know what was going on...
TheSaxlad wrote:strike wolf wrote:nagerous wrote:Either way I'm surprised that more blood wasn't shed, in a 30 player game there could be up to 5 or so killing roles.
Well it looks to me like this was a case of one killing role killing another killing role (perhaps the punisher? blake did make a role claim of some kind on one of the pages) preventing the latter killing role's kill to go throughv or less likely Blake's role was busdriven back at himself. I also wouldn't put it past the mod to have a Poisoner in this game and my experience is that most good vigs and JOATS won't attempt to kill anyone until they have a good sense of who's mafia.
Also FOS: TheSaxLad You want to vote herk because he and Aage were the only two to FOS Blake? first of all I believe that is false as far as being the only two. Second of all, the logic that it is because they must know more than everyone else makes no sense whatsoever.
No Im voting herk because, he seems A. too active
B. he seems as though he knows a lot, especially about blakebowling.
C. How?
Those are my main questions/statements, as soon as/ if I get satisfying answers then I will change my vote, maybe it might even bring the scum out.
TheSaxlad wrote:After reading the pages above:
unovte vote aage
reasons above in the last 3 pages.
TheSaxlad wrote:edocsil wrote:Alright, since when is Herk a confirmed townie? This is really beginning to bother me. He did some wacked shit yesterday and is starting it up again today, and when he is presented with a logical argument he flames. And then by magic everyone agrees with him and jumps on his OMGUS wagon
Christ, are you three in this together? I want to do some re reading before I post all my thoughts, but here are a few. FoS Fircoal and Ga7, you are both better players then that and I cannot come to terms as to why you agree with Herk's pathetic arguments. You know full well if you support Herk the others will likely follow your lead and attempt to lynch aage and this causes me great concerns, because while aage has been aggressive in his pursuit of Herk he has had a legitimate case against him. But you just dismiss it all as lyncher tactics and wagon him.
What is going on here?
Why are you protecting him?
Guys i think we found another mafia waiting to be lynched...
Commander9 wrote:
Masons are not always pro-town?
theherkman wrote:I think that if Jace is scum, then we should look at ga7, flores, and saxlad VERY CAREFULLY. If Aage is scum, we need to look at freezie, edocsil, and strike.
Also, violet, why are you voting me again?
ga7 wrote:I find Strike Wolf's argument the best one so far, although it's hard to really go for it because it concerns the dead scum's behaviour and not Jace's, who can only defend his pattern. Nevertheless it's a link, and might be a good lead.
strike wolf wrote:That being said I still really do not like Jace in this game. I just do not trust him. I already presented the evidence of his connections with blake (blake stepping out to defend him and similar voting patterns) plus after calling him out today he gave a quick defense, voted on the Aage wagon quickly and disappeared again as things were moving more that way. So yeah over night, I think Jace is a valid subject to look into.
freezie wrote:edocsil wrote:Alright, since when is Herk a confirmed townie? This is really beginning to bother me. He did some wacked shit yesterday and is starting it up again today, and when he is presented with a logical argument he flames. And then by magic everyone agrees with him and jumps on his OMGUS wagon
Christ, are you three in this together? I want to do some re reading before I post all my thoughts, but here are a few. FoS Fircoal and Ga7, you are both better players then that and I cannot come to terms as to why you agree with Herk's pathetic arguments. You know full well if you support Herk the others will likely follow your lead and attempt to lynch aage and this causes me great concerns, because while aage has been aggressive in his pursuit of Herk he has had a legitimate case against him. But you just dismiss it all as lyncher tactics and wagon him.
What is going on here?
Is this the case you're talking about?aage wrote:Yes, Jace is suspicious, but for now i will still urge you all to vote theherkman. This dude has been referring to having night kill actions ALL NIGHT, not to mention his pretty. odd behavior yesterday (as in, during D1). If he's the vig, we're better off without him. If he's some other killing role, he should die. Now.
vote theherkman btw.
That he posted some story mid-night about beeing able to kill?
Great case Mr E. Well worth an agressive defense over aage.
Heck, am almost wanting to lynch you just to see if Aage is your scumbody or not...
This won't clean Herk, but yea..
aage wrote:Why do you think I want to see a second member of that power group of yours? Possibly because I also need info? Because I'm not a cop? As I already said? It's the almost-ultimate test of seeing whether you're speaking the truth and I'm targeting the wrong guy. The ultimate test would be lynching you, but it seems like people are more interested in lynching Jace so that's probably not going to happen today. And since Victor's test also didn't work, this is now the only way for me to be sure.
theherkman wrote:You should be keeping an eye on blakebowling. I say that I am have information about a doc and know who two trusted townies are and he votes me... HELLO? Did anyone miss this?
strike wolf wrote:Apparently PR is post restriction. As far as the case is concerned I think I have a better idea now of what's going on. It has infornmation to do with herk's group though for now I won't pursue that side of it. The other part is I didn't find anything linking aage to blake other than aage did at one point FOS him. So at the very least I do not believe Aage is a part of the known mafia.
Anarkistsdream wrote:If you guys can't tell that Doom is being forced to post this drivel, you are fools...
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Stefunny85 wrote:Maybe there wasn't a NK because the whole mafia is inactive
VioIet wrote:I have no post that was a one-liner, it was a page full of quotes that I responded to. Or posted for reference/information.
Perhaps you are the one who needs to re-read my post again.
Fairly convenient for you to pop up and say "oh busy i will post later." So you were busy- I'm sure that was true. But to call someone who had contributed more than you up to that point an "inactive." WTH
Hypocritcal
Tunnely
FOS Commander
VioIet wrote:
I will avenge your death Dazey!!!
Users browsing this forum: No registered users