safariguy5 wrote:jeraado wrote:Its a bit of a worry that we're going to lynch someone who hasn't even logged on for a while. I'm guessing this is (at least one of) the people to be replaced.
I can't really see what we're going to learn by lynching campin? I'm hoping we'll get a replacement for him instead, so there's another active player. That being said, I don't want a no-lynch so hopefully commander finds someone soon.
Also, I though we'd already learnt that thesaxlad was the double-voter?
Yes, but unless we have a better lead, lynching dead weight is better than a no lynch.
My understanding was that the whole idea behind making sure that we don't end up with a no-lynch is that at least we learn something from a lynch. Either the target makes a claim, says something incriminating, or we get information from vote order/voters comments.
If campin is mafia then we've basically struck it very lucky. I suppose if he is gf/third party killer then that would explain the lack of action from the giggling group, but we haven't even speculated on that. I could understand if we were talking about someone who was inactive as that may be suspect in itself, but campin hasnt even been on so we're flying blind.
My fear is that we may find that campin is town, we've learnt nothing, and we've basically just made the mafia's job easier. Let me be clear, I'm not advocating a no-lynch, or even that we shouldn't lynch campin. I'm just saying that we need to continue discussing other suspects as well.
I remain suspicious of dlanor. He is pretty much steering the conversation the way he wants it to go, and whilst it is meaty stuff, it is also exactly what I would expect a replacement player to do if they were scum and picked up when the heat was on. Shutting down a line of conversation is fine if it is a distraction while we have solid leads, but if we dont then it is not something which benefits town. Also, don't forget how close we were to lynching fuzzy, or how defensive dlanor was when he first joined. I agree that a replacement shouldn't jump straight into a claim, but likewise what we have learnt from the original player shouldn't just be forgotten.
For today we're going to wind up lynching campin. I'd like to wait as long as possible on the remote chance that he shows up, but I will hammer if needed. However tomorrow hopefully we can kickstart some proper investigation