"Film Noir" Mafia Game (Day 4) TOWN WINS!

[pancakemix]

Actually, one mafia, one serial killer. But still, WOOOOO

[everywhere116]

Well, damn. Losing the doc on night one is not cool.

Good job by the vig, though. Now we've just got to figure out who Got Tonkaed was working with.

That willl be a problem. If I counted correctly, he only posted twice.

[Colaalone]

random.org tells me that i should vote pancakemix


and yes fircoal is like this is just about every mafia game ive ever read or played with him in for day one....

Unvote and Vote Vincent M

His whole charade with trying to bust people so quickly on day 1 when there is so little evidence is either the sign of a scum player or a very confused/swayable townie.

Those are his only two posts, not much to work with...
But I would say that 90% clears pancakemix as townie.

[The1exile]

random.org tells me that i should vote pancakemix


and yes fircoal is like this is just about every mafia game ive ever read or played with him in for day one....

Unvote and Vote Vincent M

His whole charade with trying to bust people so quickly on day 1 when there is so little evidence is either the sign of a scum player or a very confused/swayable townie.

Those are his only two posts, not much to work with...
But I would say that 90% clears pancakemix as townie.

Why so sure? He also voted Vince M, who was scum. Not his scum, but certainly I wouldn't then say that it clears pancakemix instantly.

[pancakemix]

His vote for me was random, and his vote for vincent was just to get himself safe for a day.

[The1exile]

I know. I'm not saying it means you are mafia, as I don't think you are judging by your behaviour, but basing judgements on a mafia's random votes isn't the best policy IMO.

[pancakemix]

Well, you're right about that.

[Colaalone]

I know. I'm not saying it means you are mafia, as I don't think you are judging by your behaviour, but basing judgements on a mafia's random votes isn't the best policy IMO.

What I meant was, mafia wouldn't random vote people from their own group. right? No of course not.

Why so sure? He also voted Vince M, who was scum. Not his scum, but certainly I wouldn't then say that it clears pancakemix instantly.

Umm... for all he knew, Vincent M was a townie.

[The1exile]

I know. I'm not saying it means you are mafia, as I don't think you are judging by your behaviour, but basing judgements on a mafia's random votes isn't the best policy IMO.

What I meant was, mafia wouldn't random vote people from their own group. right? No of course not.

There's no harm in doing so on the first sday, and I've voted my mafia partners before if they were looking retarded or scummy. IMO the best way tpo play a mafia role is to act like a townie, ignoring your mafia knowledge - it ensures you don't skim more than you normally would, you don't act against your normal behaviour, and you don't trip over yourself if you try to lie.

Why so sure? He also voted Vince M, who was scum. Not his scum, but certainly I wouldn't then say that it clears pancakemix instantly.

Umm... for all he knew, Vincent M was a townie.

True, but look at Vincent's posts. Does he really look like a townie - if he did, would we have lynched him?

[Aimless]

Well, this isn't really much to go on, but Got Tonkaed was the 3rd vote against Vincent - perfect positioning for starting a bandwagon. I think we should look at the others who helped start the bandwagon.

The1exile was the second vote against Vincent, and his initial vote was a joke vote that he never unvoted. (Well, granted, Vincent did one of his psycho attacks against The1exile immediately thereafter to give him a reason to keep the vote, but still.)

I GOT SERVED was the 4th vote, although his vote was in response to Vincent's erratic behavior, and the times between his vote and Got Tonkaed's don't really suggest bandwagoning, either. Plus, he made a joke vote against himself on page 5, although that probably doesn't mean anything either.

Well, I don't think it's enough to vote on, but FOS The1exile and FOS I GOT SERVED.

[The1exile]

The1exile was the second vote against Vincent, and his initial vote was a joke vote that he never unvoted. (Well, granted, Vincent did one of his psycho attacks against The1exile immediately thereafter to give him a reason to keep the vote, but still.)

I actually looked bck, and for some strange reason, I can;t find Fircoals vote... just a lot of him bien g stupid.

Fircoal, did you delete that post, or did the mod make it up, or did I just miss it?

[Aimless]

The1exile was the second vote against Vincent, and his initial vote was a joke vote that he never unvoted. (Well, granted, Vincent did one of his psycho attacks against The1exile immediately thereafter to give him a reason to keep the vote, but still.)

I actually looked bck, and for some strange reason, I can;t find Fircoals vote... just a lot of him bien g stupid.

Fircoal, did you delete that post, or did the mod make it up, or did I just miss it?

I found it. It's on page 6.

But, that also means I got the order wrong when I was counting initially. Which means you were first, Got Tonkaed was second, Fircoal was third, and I GOT SERVED was fourth.

So, FOS Fircoal, by the same logic as above.

[Colaalone]

Vote: Vincent M

For the same reason as those other guys. Erratic posting = not good.

I GOT SERVED vote on Vincent feels like bandwagoning to me. The 4th vote put him over half way to a lynch and without coming out with fresh opinions, he uses "oh yeah what those guys said!"

Also... I counted 6 votes on vincent
the1exile
get tonkaed
Fircoal
I GOT SERVED
Red Bull
and Me

Thats only 6... did i miss the 7th voter somewhere?

[The1exile]

Hm, good point... probably unriggables fault for saying that there was only one mre needed after the 5th vote...

Or maybe we have a double voter? (Heard of the role, never seen it in action)

[Aimless]

You know, it's possible he counted me as the seventh, since I quoted someone voting Vincent.

[The1exile]

You know, it's possible he counted me as the seventh, since I quoted someone voting Vincent.

That, combined with the fact the tpic title says night still, and the front page says day 1... I thinkl this mafia game is a bit screwed up.

*Cue autoload yelling at unriggable*

[Colaalone]

Hm, good point... probably unriggables fault for saying that there was only one mre needed after the 5th vote...

Or maybe we have a double voter? (Heard of the role, never seen it in action)

Yeah or a politician. Or a mod slipup.
I don't think it really affected things either way.
Vincent's outlook looked grim with all his crazy erratic behavior.

[Aimless]

Yeah. I think by that point a lynch was assured, so there's not much point in dithering about the count, if there was a slipup.

[Fircoal]

I voted him, because his attitude would not make the game fun, and just make it less fun, and because he was scummy.

[everywhere116]

I liked your mod lightning.

[Fircoal]

I liked your mod lightning.

I do too, but I'm changing avatars for a while, I'll probably go back to it, sometime. I also just changed my location.

[unriggable]

Hm, good point... probably unriggables fault for saying that there was only one mre needed after the 5th vote...

Or maybe we have a double voter? (Heard of the role, never seen it in action)

Yeah or a politician. Or a mod slipup.
I don't think it really affected things either way.
Vincent's outlook looked grim with all his crazy erratic behavior.

Oh did I screw up?

[pancakemix]

Vincent only had 6 votes...

[red bull]

Hm, good point... probably unriggables fault for saying that there was only one mre needed after the 5th vote...

Or maybe we have a double voter? (Heard of the role, never seen it in action)

Yeah or a politician. Or a mod slipup.
I don't think it really affected things either way.
Vincent's outlook looked grim with all his crazy erratic behavior.

Oh did I screw up?

no i dont think so..............

[Aimless]

Yeah, but it doesn't matter that much. Vincent would have been lynched anyway.