Post-Apocalyptic Mafia - Town Wins! [Archive]

[VioIet]

For the record- I just have to say- I was the best Tom Cruise!!!

My post on Day 1 and Day 2 were nearly verbatim, actual quotes he has given in interviews. I thought my Day 1 post would give away my character for sure.

If there was an award for truly playing up your PR, i would nominate myself to win it
Sax also did well with his. Skoffin and MeDeFe were great.

On a more serious note- I agree wholeheartedly about Illiad. Very well done.

Also squirrel played well- up until the point when he killed me It happened at a very inopportune time for me. I had just finally had some success- and now had three people in my cult. And BAM- he kills me
I was harmless- really. Just insane

Thank you for the game commander. I know how hard he worked on everything, and the painstaking amount of time it took to come up with the scenes. Very creative and intelligent scenes- wonderful roles. Congrats Commander on a good game.

[Streaker]

Also I'll give out and rate how who played this later on today.

[Commander9]

Also I'll give out and rate how who played this later on today.

I swear I'll finish doing them this week - education takes a lot of time and there's been a lot going in CC recently.

[Streaker]

Also I'll give out and rate how who played this later on today.

I swear I'll finish doing them this week - education takes a lot of time and there's been a lot going in CC recently.

No pressure, just a friendly reminder from an interested player

[safariguy5]

Also I'll give out and rate how who played this later on today.

I swear I'll finish doing them this week - education takes a lot of time and there's been a lot going in CC recently.

No pressure, just a friendly reminder from an interested player

Yeah I'd be interested to see what you think too Com9.

[Commander9]

Ratings (In my highly subjective opinion):

Justinassss - 0. I don't think thiss needs any additional explanations.

Vioieit - 6.5 . Did fairly well to enhance her PR and to survive as long as she did, but I'm not sure she chose the right recruits. Decent game.

Saxlad - 5.5 . Attracted much more attention than he should have and didn't use his votes well at all. Got better towards the end, though which bumped up the rating.

Campin - 3.0 . It wouldn't be unfair to say that he didn't try, but not a lot of it came off. Plenty of room for improvement.

Aage - 6.5 . I feel that while he was around, he played fairly well and contributed to town, but his disappearance hurt him quite a bit.

/ - 8.0 . I'd say one of the stand out performers in this game. Despite being killed by Iliad, up until that point he played really well - spreaded the confusion and side-tracked the town quite a few times.

Safari - 7.5 . I'd say he was somewhat unlucky as he was targeted a lot, but while his start was slow, I thought towards the mid game, he was playing really well. Used his mason abilities well and generally was influential.

Mr. S. - 8.5 . If not for a moment of madness with the cult, I'd have given him 9.5. A lot of his early theories were right on track and generally has contributed a lot to the town both with his role and his analysis.

Edoc - 7.0 . He started rather bad as he did a lot of waggoning and had some minor scumtells, but he really grew as the game went on and was playing really well at the end.

Skoff - 6.5 . Not bad, not too well off either.

Streaker - 6.5 . The rating may be somewhat unjust as used the same criteria as I did towards others, but considering this was his first game, he did extremely well (IMHO).

Herk - 6.5 . I'm disgusted with myself for saying this, but I thought he played really well ( ) and only was ousted of the game due to some bad luck on his side.

Iliad - 8.0 . I've really enjoyed watching Illy this game - his move was ballsy, but it payed off. Would have had a better rating if not for his inactivity.

Naxus - 7.5 . I feel that he did really well with both of his roles according to what resources he was provided with. A very solid showing.

TG - 7.0 . Aided the mafia well, but could have been even more influential.

Haggis - 8.0 . Played quite well as both of his roles and generally has contributed a lot to town's victory. Well done here.

MeDeFe - 7.0 . He thought that he was pretty much a town's vig and he was very responsible with it. Generally contributed fairly decently to the game.

Jeraado - 8.0 . This may be a shock to most of you, but I was very surprised that he got pressured so much. I thought he handled his role and defence really well and helped town quite a bit even though he was hated by 3 townies.

Thezz - 4.0 . Really not much to say...

Fuzzy - 5.5 . Didn't do too much, but he at least some credits for the effort.

Fir - 2.5 . No idea why he signed up for this at all.

MVP - I'd say probably Mr. Squirrel.


All Star Team:
Mr. Squirrel - Jeraado - Haggis - Iliad - / - Safari (naxus just missed out)

[safariguy5]

Thanks for the kind appraisal there Com9, although I do think I might have stayed alive longer had that Dlanor A. Knox JOAT lynch not been so militantly pursued. But pretty accurate evaluations all around.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Just so you know, I was the one who advocated your NK Saf (:D), since I had aage figured as the doc already and I was pretty certain there wasn't another protective role. If only Iliad hadn't killed / then I'm 100% certain the mafia would've won.

So pretty much I'm even more awesome than Commie gives me credit for.

-Tails

[Fircoal]

Ratings (In my highly subjective opinion):
Fir - 2.5 . No idea why he signed up for this at all.

Because I didn't expect to be swamped by a huge Day 1. It ended up that was like 10-20 pages behind, and I had no idea what was going on at a time where I wasn't really doing well in all my mafia games. That's part of the reason why I'm trying to keep myself limited in games right now, because I don't want that to happen again. Sorry that I never said anything or what not but I just fell behind and I just couldn't get back. xwx

[Haggis_McMutton]

It ended up that was like 10-20 pages behind, and I had no idea what was going on at a time where I wasn't really doing well in all my mafia games. That's part of the reason why I'm trying to keep myself limited in games right now, because I don't want that to happen again.

I unfortunately know exactly what that feels like. God I'm annoyed that I didn't manage to catch up to PotC

Also, I'm surprised Iliad didn't get MVP.
It's interesting to think, is his relatively low activity in every game helping or hurting him?

[MeDeFe]

Meh, I was a bit suspicious about my role from the start. I mean, "Alexander the Great, Conqueror of the world" with minions at my disposal and armies waiting to march. Also a dual win condition, either when all threats to town are eliminated or when I've conquered the world, but with no instructions about how to go about that second part. I thought that a bit of insanity was highly likely, but I didn't rule out the possibility that I really might be the vig with a solitary win condition that might manifest later in the game from the beginning. With the motherfucking apocalypse having happened and zombies attacking us it didn't seem to be completely impossible.

After a person was targeted by a giggling killer on night 1 I figured that might have been me acting out my delusions of secret minions obeying my orders, when the gigglers appeared again without me doing anything I started wondering whether I even had any powers or just delusions. I would've loved to be forced to claim, though, that would've been awesome.

Oh, and I figured out who Sax was the day after I was killed. Posting restriction, weird accent with lots of 'z'... damn, it's got to be Arnie. He confirmed it when I asked by PM, otherwise I would've offered to replace an inactive at some point.

[Mr. Squirrel]

MVP - I'd say probably Mr. Squirrel.

I'M NUMBER ONE!!!! WOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!! NYA-NYA-NYAAAAAAAAH!!!!





Just kidding. On a serious note, I should have gotten like a 6 or something. I got recruited by cult and then the day right afterward I nearly lynched him. I was a terrible teammate.

[safariguy5]

MVP - I'd say probably Mr. Squirrel.

I'M NUMBER ONE!!!! WOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!! NYA-NYA-NYAAAAAAAAH!!!!





Just kidding. On a serious note, I should have gotten like a 6 or something. I got recruited by cult and then the day right afterward I nearly lynched him. I was a terrible teammate.

I'd say you were a great teammate to me.

[Streaker]

Ah, thank you commander for the ratings. I appreciate the time you put into this game, and I hope you can keep the same quality of gameplay up for your next games.

I'm glad with my rating, it seems very fair. Never expected better to start with here.
Squirell, in the end it was Iliad who killed me though. You COULD have backed me up a little more there

[VioIet]

Thanks for the good rating commander!!!

I still say I was the BEST Tom Cruise ever!!! My first two inane post were pretty much verbatim quotes that he has given before. All my posts were things that he has actually said. I know because i looked them up.

I should really get a PR reward

[Commander9]

Ah, thank you commander for the ratings. I appreciate the time you put into this game, and I hope you can keep the same quality of gameplay up for your next games.

I'm glad with my rating, it seems very fair. Never expected better to start with here.
Squirell, in the end it was Iliad who killed me though. You COULD have backed me up a little more there

Thank you I'll definitely try.

Thanks for the good rating commander!!!

I still say I was the BEST Tom Cruise ever!!! My first two inane post were pretty much verbatim quotes that he has given before. All my posts were things that he has actually said. I know because i looked them up.

I should really get a PR reward

I can always add a PR in the other game

[VioIet]

I can always add a PR in the other game

Oh, no thank you. That's quite alright.