South Park Mafia [Scum Win]

by **blakebowling** on Sun Jul 03, 2011 7:04 pm

Just a reminder that you have a few hours before I post the night scene. and I am still missing 3 Night Actions.

by **chapcrap** on Sun Jul 03, 2011 7:37 pm

blakebowling wrote:Just a reminder that you have a few hours before I post the night scene. and I am still missing 3 Night Actions.

I don't do night actions. Wish that I could. *mumble*

This soup is still making my ache. I hope that tomorrow will be a better day for me.

by **blakebowling** on Mon Jul 04, 2011 3:01 pm

Two young boys awoke in south park. Still indifferent about Eric's death, They walked down the road to meet the third. Across the street they saw a bloody Kenny McCormick.
"You killed Kenny!"
"You Bastards!"

chapcrap - Kenny McCormick (Human Shield) has been killed.

Begin Day 4

by **evilchaos** on Mon Jul 04, 2011 4:00 pm

YOU BASTARDS!

by **evilchaos** on Mon Jul 04, 2011 4:01 pm

blakebowling wrote:Two young boys awoke in south park. Still indifferent about Eric's death, They walked down the road to meet the third. Across the street they saw a bloody Kenny McCormick.
"You killed Kenny!"
"You Bastards!"

chapcrap - Kenny McCormick (Human Shield) has been killed.

Begin Day 4

Flavor confirms existence of two remaining boys, meaning Stan is in the game. 40k is confirmed town, based on no counter-claim.

by **chapcrap** on Mon Jul 04, 2011 4:17 pm

It seems that the soup has overtaken me. Goodbye my friends.

by **evilchaos** on Mon Jul 04, 2011 4:31 pm

Vote Com9

Two players were fed the soup and then died the next day. This is too much of a coincidence to ignore.

by **Talapus** on Tue Jul 05, 2011 8:29 pm

evilchaos wrote:Vote Com9

Two players were fed the soup and then died the next day. This is too much of a coincidence to ignore.

Ya, either damn smart scum for offing people after advertising they had soup or someone is lying.

by **evilchaos** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 5:13 am

evilchaos wrote:Vote Com9

Two players were fed the soup and then died the next day. This is too much of a coincidence to ignore.

@Everyone - we need opinions on this. 2 of 9 people alive have posted since day started...

@Mod - mass prod tomorrow or the next day, please, unless activity picks up.

by **kratos644** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 8:26 am

Personally I'm not 100% sure what to think about this yet. Com hasn't appeared overly scummy to me but it's possible that his soup is killing people so for now I'll give a FOS Com9.

There is also the issue of Tail. When is the last time that we heard anything at all from him? Now I'm weary to go after him based on this alone because I was really busy and inactive as a result but was a power role although we've also had most of our power roles exposed already so maybe it would be alright to pressure him.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 8:59 am

I was gonna post last night but got preoccupied with other stuff. Either way most of what I have to say is dependent on hearing from at least one person if not two who haven't posted yet.

by / on Wed Jul 06, 2011 6:06 pm

Hmm, well we won't get any new info through pressure, I'm going to look back to our last day to see if I can come up with something better, but it does seem like a good move at this point.

by **evilchaos** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 6:46 pm

kratos644 wrote:Personally I'm not 100% sure what to think about this yet. Com hasn't appeared overly scummy to me but it's possible that his soup is killing people so for now I'll give a FOS Com9.

There is also the issue of Tail. When is the last time that we heard anything at all from him? Now I'm weary to go after him based on this alone because I was really busy and inactive as a result but was a power role although we've also had most of our power roles exposed already so maybe it would be alright to pressure him.

Classic scum neutrality...

I still think Kratos is a good scum candidate.

by **kratos644** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 8:46 pm

It's neutral that I'm not convinced that Com9 hasn't been the one handing out the soup? That doesn't seem to fit as a role for chef to me. If that makes me appear scummy then so be it.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 9:10 pm

kratos644 wrote:It's neutral that I'm not convinced that Com9 hasn't been the one handing out the soup? That doesn't seem to fit as a role for chef to me. If that makes me appear scummy then so be it.

Exactly. Poisonous soup does not fit with Chef - yet you vote me. Smart.

Also, I've not talked with the boys tonight (thus not using my action) and boys can confirm that, so should the soup appear somewhere again - that would mean I have nothing to do with this.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 9:17 pm

Commander9 wrote:
kratos644 wrote:It's neutral that I'm not convinced that Com9 hasn't been the one handing out the soup? That doesn't seem to fit as a role for chef to me. If that makes me appear scummy then so be it.

Exactly. Poisonous soup does not fit with Chef - yet you vote me. Smart.

Also, I've not talked with the boys tonight (thus not using my action) and boys can confirm that, so should the soup appear somewhere again - that would mean I have nothing to do with this.

While I agree that you are probably not the one distributing the soup or at least think claiming chef while the poison soup nazi was the main focus for needs lynching was a bit risky for a scum with that much power, I don't see how you choosing not to communicate with the boys last night proves you wouldn't have sent anyone soup.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 9:30 pm

strike wolf wrote:While I agree that you are probably not the one distributing the soup or at least think claiming chef while the poison soup nazi was the main focus for needs lynching was a bit risky for a scum with that much power, I don't see how you choosing not to communicate with the boys last night proves you wouldn't have sent anyone soup.

Well, a question to you then: do you think that there could be a poisoner with an extremely strong fake claim that would have an ability to tell anything to the boys? Furthermore, mod would even tell them that it was from Chef, basically confirming the role.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 10:11 pm

Ah ok I misunstood. I thought you were using a "well I didn't do this action so obviously I didn't do this action" defense but rather you were falling more back on "this is my ability. Not that."

by **Commander9** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 10:26 pm

strike wolf wrote:Ah ok I misunstood. I thought you were using a "well I didn't do this action so obviously I didn't do this action" defense but rather you were falling more back on "this is my ability. Not that."

Well... If I would just say I didn't use an ability without any confirmation, that would not be a good defence - no way to check it. This way we will indeed learn something:

A) we will either know that I am Chef as the boys can confirm I didn't contact them and it is actually me giving the soup (if there's no sick today)

OR

B) Someone will be sick, boys will confirm that I am Chef and I didn't contact them and it is not me who's giving the soup.

FoS Kratos for trying to twist my role and pin the soup on me.

by **strike wolf** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 10:38 pm

Than I stick by my original comment. Just because you chose not to use one action wouldn't mean you didn't choose to do another. It is flawed logic.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jul 06, 2011 11:04 pm

strike wolf wrote:Than I stick by my original comment. Just because you chose not to use one action wouldn't mean you didn't choose to do another. It is flawed logic.

Commander9 wrote:
Well, a question to you then: do you think that there could be a poisoner with an extremely strong fake claim that would have an ability to tell anything to the boys? Furthermore, mod would even tell them that it was from Chef, basically confirming the role.

by **evilchaos** on Thu Jul 07, 2011 4:36 am

kratos644 wrote:Personally I'm not 100% sure what to think about this yet. Com hasn't appeared overly scummy to me but it's possible that his soup is killing people so for now I'll give a FOS Com9.

There is also the issue of Tail. When is the last time that we heard anything at all from him? Now I'm weary to go after him based on this alone because I was really busy and inactive as a result but was a power role although we've also had most of our power roles exposed already so maybe it would be alright to pressure him.

Ok, let me have a go at rewriting what you said here:

kratos's BS wrote:Personally, I'm not sure if Com9 is scum. He isn't overly scummy, but it's possible that he's scum. FoS Com9.

We haven't heard anything from Tail in a while. We shouldn't go after him, but we should pressure him (means the same thing - lol).

You basically said, in both cases, that the players aren't very scummy, but we should pressure them. a.k.a. Let's be neutral. That way I can start a bandwagon while leaving myself completely free to claim I never pushed hard for their lynch. You gave no strong conclusions on players. This is a scum tell, in my opinion.

Who is the most likely scum in your opinion Kratos?

Also, Unvote. I guess Chef doesn't seem like a poisoner, but I hate relying on nameclaims for proof of who is town.

by **TA1LGUNN3R** on Thu Jul 07, 2011 6:08 am

I investigated kratos last night, got a roundabout innocent result.

-Tails

by **lalaland** on Thu Jul 07, 2011 8:09 am

Tail, can you elaborate on what you mean by "roundabout innocent"?

Also, was anybody poisoned last night? Because that seems as thought it's an important point right now.