Moderator: Community Team
strike wolf wrote:Have to agree with Rodion. I don't mind long joke phases but lately wagons especially on day 1s seem to be taking a good bit of time to develop. To get a little more rounded view based on the questions. I'd also like to ask you all.
What tells are you looking for on this day 1 for choosing your lynch and why?
Leitz wrote:To answer betikos question of trust: nobody, if anything by asking that question I'm suspecting you are up to no good.
saxitoxin wrote:Your position is more complex than the federal tax code. As soon as I think I understand it, I find another index of cross-references, exceptions and amendments I have to apply.
Timminz wrote:Yo mama is so classless, she could be a Marxist utopia.
To answer betikos question of trust: nobody, if anything by asking that question I'm suspecting you are up to no good.
Leitz wrote:To answer betikos question of trust: nobody, if anything by asking that question I'm suspecting you are up to no good.
I thought I voted, but I just see I didn't so: Unvote, vote betiko
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
Leitz wrote:To answer betikos question of trust: nobody, if anything by asking that question I'm suspecting you are up to no good.
I thought I voted, but I just see I didn't so: Unvote, vote betiko
Rodion wrote:Leitz wrote:To answer betikos question of trust: nobody, if anything by asking that question I'm suspecting you are up to no good.
I thought I voted, but I just see I didn't so: Unvote, vote betiko
Mind elaborating how Betiko asking that question makes him scummy to you?
betiko wrote:let s put the question the other way; out of the 16 who do we trust a little? to tell the truth, i think that rodion by asking this question is one of the guys i would trust the most... aparently you guys have played this a few times together so you know each other better.. this means that I don t trust SG7
unvote vote SG7
Rodion wrote:It's too early in the game to trust someone as far as "towniness" goes. What we can do is make an effort to get the RVS over with as soon as possible, otherwise by the time a deadline is enforced we might not have a good candidate for the D1 lynch (and, statistically, town is better off by lynching someone).
Unvote.
betiko wrote:it s funny how trying to make the game advance always makes you the most suspicious. regarding rodion, it s more that i think his approach with that type of question had to be the one of a townie, i might be misslead, don t know yet but it was my gut feeling reading that post. i m the first one to have taken a positive position on someone as we had to start somewhere.. as I had no non joke lead on anyone being scum.
half of the guys are not saying anything and can t therefore be suspected...
Swifte wrote:I agree that inactivity itself can be grounds for suspicion. However, I have just reviewed all players and all players in the game have posted within the last 48 hours. Obviously some more active than others, but far from deadbeats at this point. Dates are as of my own timezone I imagine.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:Well honestly I'm not really buying into any of the current cases...I don't really think there's anything to Rodion's questioning of leitz, I don't really find the betiko case that strong and the rodion is basically non-existant. If anything I buy the betiko case more than the others but I still find it fairly weak even for day 1.
saxitoxin wrote:Your position is more complex than the federal tax code. As soon as I think I understand it, I find another index of cross-references, exceptions and amendments I have to apply.
Timminz wrote:Yo mama is so classless, she could be a Marxist utopia.
MeDeFe wrote:strike wolf wrote:Well honestly I'm not really buying into any of the current cases...I don't really think there's anything to Rodion's questioning of leitz, I don't really find the betiko case that strong and the rodion is basically non-existant. If anything I buy the betiko case more than the others but I still find it fairly weak even for day 1.
Of course it's weak, but so are most cases on day 1. Rodion's asking for a reasoning is... about as non-scummy as things get, though.
Betiko's questions, "would you be ok with lynching the person below you" and "who do you trust" are odd, though. If everyone answered honestly they could be used to figure out scumbuddies or mason/lover partners. But expecting honest answers is foolish in the first place, so what's he after?
dazza2008 wrote:MeDeFe wrote:strike wolf wrote:Well honestly I'm not really buying into any of the current cases...I don't really think there's anything to Rodion's questioning of leitz, I don't really find the betiko case that strong and the rodion is basically non-existant. If anything I buy the betiko case more than the others but I still find it fairly weak even for day 1.
Of course it's weak, but so are most cases on day 1. Rodion's asking for a reasoning is... about as non-scummy as things get, though.
Betiko's questions, "would you be ok with lynching the person below you" and "who do you trust" are odd, though. If everyone answered honestly they could be used to figure out scumbuddies or mason/lover partners. But expecting honest answers is foolish in the first place, so what's he after?
Was the first question not asked by Rodion?
Anyway I did not find either question particularly scummy. To me it just seemed like 2 guys trying to get some kind of conversation going which can only be a good thing.
saxitoxin wrote:Your position is more complex than the federal tax code. As soon as I think I understand it, I find another index of cross-references, exceptions and amendments I have to apply.
Timminz wrote:Yo mama is so classless, she could be a Marxist utopia.
MeDeFe wrote:dazza2008 wrote:MeDeFe wrote:strike wolf wrote:Well honestly I'm not really buying into any of the current cases...I don't really think there's anything to Rodion's questioning of leitz, I don't really find the betiko case that strong and the rodion is basically non-existant. If anything I buy the betiko case more than the others but I still find it fairly weak even for day 1.
Of course it's weak, but so are most cases on day 1. Rodion's asking for a reasoning is... about as non-scummy as things get, though.
Betiko's questions, "would you be ok with lynching the person below you" and "who do you trust" are odd, though. If everyone answered honestly they could be used to figure out scumbuddies or mason/lover partners. But expecting honest answers is foolish in the first place, so what's he after?
Was the first question not asked by Rodion?
Anyway I did not find either question particularly scummy. To me it just seemed like 2 guys trying to get some kind of conversation going which can only be a good thing.
You're right, Rodion asked the first one. I must've gotten that mixed up somehow.
ok...
Then we have betiko asking one weird question, and Rodion asking a weird question and later a non-scummy question. I'm still leaning towards putting pressure on betiko, though.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users