by got tonkaed on Wed Apr 18, 2007 8:55 am
tres, i laid out the argument for max being scum back in the last thread. Essentially, he claimed that he had a dual power role, that allowed him to in some weeks investigate, and in other weeks protect sort of in a shapeshifter fashion, which coincedentally is the form that the scum have taken. In one of his investigator weeks, he claimed to have targeted mandolorian. I am a tracker. I tracked him that week and he did not investigate anyone, and he was not roleblocked that week. He has lied about his role and i would believe is scum.
However, i feel puff is also scum and if i have my druthers id actually rather we lynch him, because if there is a possbility that max was simply lying about his role, there is a much more conclusive link to puff being scum. I investigated him the weekend when he targted mandolorian, who turned up dead. Had puff been a doc and targeted mando clearly he would be alive, but he is not. Puff i am therefore confident is the one who killed mandolorian and is a threat to the colony. Therefore tres, i would prefer you vote puff as he is more dangerous than max atm. Max i only caught lying about an investigation, puff i caught targeting someone on the week they died.