[Official] NBC Mafia Town Win MVP=trinicardinal

[dazza2008]

It feels to me like we are clearing people just for a strong character. Do we not think that fakeclaims would be strong in this game?

They may have strong fake claims, but when given a very strong fake claim, should we just say, no, that's too strong, you're lying or should be we try to find someone else? I mean, it's not like we can just lynch everyone even if they claim.

And if we're talking about things being fake claims, strike's claim of zero could easily be a fake claim as well.

This was my point really. With nothing to go on it seems we have no where to go. We could pressure Jonty then he will claim then what?

[chapcrap]

It feels to me like we are clearing people just for a strong character. Do we not think that fakeclaims would be strong in this game?

They may have strong fake claims, but when given a very strong fake claim, should we just say, no, that's too strong, you're lying or should be we try to find someone else? I mean, it's not like we can just lynch everyone even if they claim.

And if we're talking about things being fake claims, strike's claim of zero could easily be a fake claim as well.

This was my point really. With nothing to go on it seems we have no where to go. We could pressure Jonty then he will claim then what?

Depends what he claims and if it's believable. If it is also believable, then I guess we could try MeDeFe or go back and decide that we no longer believe strike or Leitz and lynch them.

[MoB Deadly]

The mafia cant have all the strongest names in the game though. I think we need to lynch a couple of the weaker name claims and work on the main characters when we have more info

[MeDeFe]

unvote

Sally is a strong claim, and the one-way lover mechanic is something that can come back and bite the scum if it's a fake claim. Say Jack dies and Leitz lives, then he's next on the chopping block.

I don't think we should go back and "just lynch dazza because he's VT". The case against him was bad to start with, we're probably better off seeing if we can dig up shit on someone else instead.

[Leitz]

unvote

Sally is a strong claim, and the one-way lover mechanic is something that can come back and bite the scum if it's a fake claim. Say Jack dies and Leitz lives, then he's next on the chopping block.

I don't think we should go back and "just lynch dazza because he's VT". The case against him was bad to start with, we're probably better off seeing if we can dig up shit on someone else instead.

The deadline is in about 2 days, a bit late for a new case according to me. Especially seeing the activity here (although a new increase since my claim) is still not the same as on D2. If you don't want to pursue the dazza case that leaves the jonty case as only option. If I'd agree to change my vote to him now, that would put him at L-2. I'm not sure if another claim is going to help us make it any easier..

[chapcrap]

unvote

Sally is a strong claim, and the one-way lover mechanic is something that can come back and bite the scum if it's a fake claim. Say Jack dies and Leitz lives, then he's next on the chopping block.

I don't think we should go back and "just lynch dazza because he's VT". The case against him was bad to start with, we're probably better off seeing if we can dig up shit on someone else instead.

The deadline is in about 2 days, a bit late for a new case according to me. Especially seeing the activity here (although a new increase since my claim) is still not the same as on D2. If you don't want to pursue the dazza case that leaves the jonty case as only option. If I'd agree to change my vote to him now, that would put him at L-2. I'm not sure if another claim is going to help us make it any easier..

I feel like the town is behind and needs to do something about it. A claim from jonty would be beneficial IMO.

[MeDeFe]

We really can't afford a no lynch with 4 townies and no scum dead so far. Under the circumstances, jonty is looking like the scummiest candidate for a lynch to me.

vote jonty

[Leitz]

That puts jonty at L-2 if I'm not mistaken..

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

leitz (1)- dazza
dazza(3)- PCM, leitz, jonty
jonty(5)- strike, betiko, chap, trini, MeDeFe

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline Midnight on January 23rd PST. If a lynch is not made by that time, no lynch will be declared. About 59 hours from now.

[jonty125]

I am Gate Keeper, Vanilla Townie.

[betiko]

Ok we have 1 day left...
I would clear out strike (zero) and leitz (sally) at least for today (even if personally i would clear them out almost completely). too strong characters in the movie that haven't been counter claimed, even if safari could ve perfectly introduced strong halloween town characters from the movie as mafia fakeclaims, but I think it's unlikely.

that leaves us with the 2 VT claims:
-dazza (behemoth)
-jonty (gate keeper)

with 1 day left, I think the choice comes down to these 2. And with 2 VT there it is highly likely we are going to catch a scum; the options are narrowing and we are not that many left compared to them.

I will stick to jonty; his overall gameplay could perfectly be the one of a scum, always under the radar and giving just the right amount of presence here or there not to be too much noticed.

I kind of think dazza was a genuinely bored VT on day 2 and that he just wanted a little action. the whole plan for brownie points would be too twisted and elaborated with too many unknown reactions and possibilities.

[strike wolf]

I stick by my vote. I believe Jonty to be the right choice.

[MoB Deadly]

unvote vote jonty

We have to pick between jonty and Dazz in hopes 1 of them is a fake claim. Jonty is slightly scummier in my book.

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

leitz (1)- dazza
dazza(3)- PCM, leitz, jonty
jonty(6)- strike, betiko, chap, trini, MeDeFe, MoB

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline Midnight on January 23rd PST. If a lynch is not made by that time, no lynch will be declared. About 38 hours from now.

[dazza2008]

I still suspect Leitz if I am honest but to get the game moving should I hammer Jonty?

If its a choice of him or me I have to go for him as I know I am VT.

[Epitaph1]

Being a fan of the movie, I still had to look up jonty's role because of it's obscurity. I'm inclined to think it's a fakeclaim as well.

[dazza2008]

OK unvote vote Jonty

[Leitz]

OK unvote vote Jonty

Jonty is lynched. Will he be scum? Let's find out!

[betiko]

wow this has been a fast lynch, thought it would last till the last minute. come on i wanna see a scum fall for once!!!!!!!! i still was unable to find who the gate keeper is in the movie googleing lol, don't remember this character..

[MeDeFe]

There must be one hell of a scene coming up.

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

leitz (1)- dazza
dazza(3)- PCM, leitz, jonty
jonty(7)- strike, betiko, chap, trini, MeDeFe, MoB, dazza

jonty has been lynched. Sorry for the delay, was celebrating Chinese New Year.

[safariguy5]

Scene

As the day dawned, there was still a certain amount of confusion about the Clown's purpose from the day before. Accusations flew, and several people were suspected.

"He offered to kill the clown but he was sure he wouldn't be forced to!"

"Don't kill me, I'm most definitely town!"

With the day ending, everyone decided to come to a decision. They took one of the accused and strung him up, claiming that "we've never seen you around before".

jonty125, Gate Keeper, Vanilla Townie has been lynched!

It is now Night 3, 48 hours to send in night actions.

[eagleblade]

Whats a Vanilla Townie

[betiko]

Whats a Vanilla Townie

only players still alive +mods can post in here please. also a little "hi" and adding a question mark wouldn't hurt.

seeing a new name as last poster i thought something crazy happened as the 48h are passed.. and we should get the scene... saaff curiosity is killing me!

[strike wolf]

A vanilla townie is a town member with no special abilities or restrictions placed upon their roles. They can vote but that is it.