CYOC Mafia [7/15] Game Over! [Archive]

[spiesr]

OR use it on /, Spiesr, or anyone else to stop all this "Well they could be mafia" arguments.

That wouldn't stop all those arguments, just cross off one player from the list. (Provided that the Yam works as advertised.)

[jak111]

OR use it on /, Spiesr, or anyone else to stop all this "Well they could be mafia" arguments.

That wouldn't stop all those arguments, just cross off one player from the list. (Provided that the Yam works as advertised.)

Well maybe if one was cleared people who mess off and at least take a chance for one day to see if the remaining ARE mafia >.<

[edocsil]

I have reread, I had serious beef with the way one player in particular handled things. Enough that I think I could build a legitimate case out of it.

Screw it, there are 2 good cases I can make. I am going to inv the one I think is scummier and see what it comes back with. I'll post the other case if the inv doesn't pan out.

[jak111]

Alright, I look forward to reading it in the morning Edoc, Pancake seems to have been on so hopefully you got it by the time you get back online. I'm off for the night and will help out with whatever you got.

[edocsil]

Tailgunner is town, posts later.

[jak111]

Good enough for me, Unvote

Hopefully he has some town info?

[edocsil]

Tailgunner is town, posts later.

meh I am still up.

Vote shaggy (otherwise known as Saggy in my notes, idk why)

Despite everything I'm very tempted to vote neb... the post restriction thing is problamatic now and later it is going to only get worse. It may be a by product of the limited number of posts but I've felt he's being intentionally neutral about a lot of issues.

This was OMGUS to boot. Neb has posted more, and of better quality then he has, so his argument is baseless.

Wagoned hard (on vodean on yomiel, but not the case vs me) This is self explanatory. Mindless votes are mindless

Lynching me is necessary for the Town to survive.

Noted. I'll definitely be voting you tomorrow if someone dies from you tonight.

In the meantime unvote and vote tails. Makes sense vodian plus I'm willing to apply pressure on anyone other than Yomiel to get this properly moving.

Yomiel please stop repeating yourself. We all get it. At this point I definitely think you have some kind of PR. A suicidal townie maybe.

If you all recall vodean supposedly tried to trick a player into wagoning. Who knows if he was telling the truth, but his logic sucked pretty hardcore, so a wagon on it is scummy.

my $.02

[jonty125]

7. jonty125-- lyncher/ee mechanic (3rd party? can't remember)

I'm town, but have an alternative WC, which is the lyncher mechanism. But there is somebody out there (a WHAM! member), who is of a random alignment and has the same alternative WC, (except he has to hammer me).

Oh and don't forget, if he doesn't hammer, I'm unlynchable.


The shaggy case doesn't seem too different from the one back on D1.

[edocsil]

7. jonty125-- lyncher/ee mechanic (3rd party? can't remember)

I'm town, but have an alternative WC, which is the lyncher mechanism. But there is somebody out there (a WHAM! member), who is of a random alignment and has the same alternative WC, (except he has to hammer me).

Oh and don't forget, if he doesn't hammer, I'm unlynchable.


The shaggy case doesn't seem too different from the one back on D1.

*gasp*

Your right. So he did it day 1, and then continued right on into day 2 ! Guess what's going to happen day 3 too?

[Iron Butterfly]

Shaggy has a night action.

[jonty125]

Shaggy has a night action.

Is this trying to clear him

[jak111]

Shaggy has a night action.

Is this trying to clear him

I think he's asking for a claim from Shaggy.

[Iron Butterfly]

Shaggy has a night action.

Is this trying to clear him

It is what it is.

If we can only be judged by our actions I saw him visit Yumiel night one.

[edocsil]

What would he do there however as scum? All I can think of is frame. Or roleblock. Surely a cop wouldn't waste their time with yomiel.

[Iron Butterfly]

What would he do there however as scum? All I can think of is frame. Or roleblock. Surely a cop wouldn't waste their time with yomiel.

That has been what I have been trying to figure out. On day two I was trying to wait it out to see if someone would slip up and then you were killed. I do not believe he was trying to kill Yumiel as he was not protected. Perhaps he IS one of the Wham or Chuk/Saf group and was checking out yumiel after all.

There was a block on the attempted night kill so unless there are double roles I would rule that out. I don't see a Doc wasting protection on Yumiel either. You tracked. I watched.

[pancakemix]

I'll be seeking a replacement for shield.

[spiesr]

Good enough for me, Unvote

Hopefully he has some town info?

Are you saying you intend to force him (Tails) to claim?

What would he do there however as scum? All I can think of is frame. Or roleblock. Surely a cop wouldn't waste their time with yomiel.

He could be scum and how a role not traditionally assigned to scum. And therefor did any number of things. No way to know.

[jak111]

Good enough for me, Unvote

Hopefully he has some town info?

Are you saying you intend to force him (Tails) to claim?

What would he do there however as scum? All I can think of is frame. Or roleblock. Surely a cop wouldn't waste their time with yomiel.

He could be scum and how a role not traditionally assigned to scum. And therefor did any number of things. No way to know.

For your first quote I am not forcing him, but at this point we need any town essential information on the table so we know what we're even dealing with here.

For the second one, I am guessing a role block might have actually been possible (Didn't wanna risk one of their own dying?) We can WIFOM all we want with what happened, but I think Shaggy is the one that needs to come forward. Tails only if he has information we don't already know. Framer wouldn't be that far fetched neither. (Frame an already suspicious person?).

Oh gawd, the biggest piece of WIFOM would be that Tails is Mafia God Father. But that may be pushing it for today XD

But what's the best course of action does anyone think? If Shaggy doesn't claim (or if he does) we could go there depending on what happened. We could go with a random lynch of the suspicious. Or does anyone have a person and/or reason why they'd want to lynch/test on a specific person?

[pancakemix]

Suddenly, a voice bellowed out of the blue:

"Day 3. Post 3.

Okay, I've taken Edoc's smallish case on Shaggy into consideration, and read through all of Shaggy's posts (It's a quick read). It's a little enlightening. He really hasn't posted much of substance himself, even though he accuses Jonty of doing the same thing at one point. He's also had a couple posts stating that "he'll post more later." While this is not the strongest case in the world, I have a feeling he will hide behind being "busy" until he is actually pressured to claim...and I'm curious as to what he's doing at night...

VOTE ShaggyDan

There's my pressure.

I went through something like what you're talking about, a couple years ago with this chick named Amy.

Neb"

[Iron Butterfly]

Vote Shaggy

I agree. It would take less then 5 min to write and post the truth. Stalling tells me they need to get there story in order before posting.

I am also strting to think that perhaps Towns win condition is to secure the Third Party win condition. Complete speculation of course.

[jak111]

I am also strting to think that perhaps Towns win condition is to secure the Third Party win condition. Complete speculation of course.

Not out of the question yet. But I don't know.. it still feels so easy. There has to be a catch.

[safariguy5]

I suppose it can't hurt to get a claim from Shaggy. Maybe he's the other killswitch that jak is looking for. At least it would put us on even ground.

vote shaggy

[ShaggyDan]

Sorry about lack of activity guys, long story I won't bore you with. Suffice to say I'm not well atm.

As far as my night action I am The Delorean - Town Delayer. I targetted yomiel night one because I didn't want to delay any town power roles and figured that Yom was someone who was anti town.

In response to the criticisms of my pushing on Neb, I was just trying to get a lynch on the day rather than a no lynch... Which unfortunatly is what happened. It wasnt a good case but it was better than not voting imo.

[Iron Butterfly]

How do you delay?

[ShaggyDan]

I target someone and whatever they do at night happens the night after instead. I will reveal my night two action if people think it is necessary. If there are multiple killsin the next night it could be that the delaying was the cause (on account of lack of deaths last night).

As far as an alternative case for today, it wouldn't surprise me if there is a scum or two on the list of people who were voting jonty at the end of day 2. If there is an informed minority they would use the lack of decision of the majority to steer it the way they want. Imo the people on jonty lends itself to a strong indicator of this.

Sorry if that doesn't make sense to anyone else, I'm on a few cold and flu meds