betiko wrote:DoomYoshi wrote:I don't see what the contradiction is.
elaborate then. why did you say on day 2 or 3 there is always a massclaim but you're not really keen to get 2 more claims today? "especially since we got the godfather". tell me more about this. why would we risk more now?
we don't know if mafia has fakeclaims, so i wouldn't mind a few nameclaims at least.
A massclaim doesn't mean that on day 1 we claim a few roles, then on day 2 a few more and then finish off on day 3. It isn't a stepwise solution. A massclaim is an "all-or-nothing" approach. The point of a massclaim is that so many claims come at once, that the mafia can not fakeclaim anything, except VT.
The way the post-fakeclaim works is that a) make mathematically certain that the scum couldn't of claimed anything else and b) kill all VTs unitl you find scum.
Right now, the only player dead is a godfather. Which means if there are 1 or 2 scum left, and 10-11 VTs left (probably a bit less) we have the lowest chance for this strategy to work. If there are 4 VTs left and 3 scum, you have them nailed.
So, what is your alleged contradiction?