stahrgazer wrote:So, our tendency to intervene against dictators since the 1940s isn't because we're arrogant, it's because we're afraid for our allies, for the innocent, and for ourselves... that if we don't intervene soon enough, the "next Hitler" will succeed where the German one failed.
You can dis us, disagree with us, and dislike our methods all you wish, chang, but when you do it, please do it for the "right" reasons, not your made-up ones. It's not "arrogance" that has us intervening, it's concern and fear.
We're not telling the rest of the world they should allow all their citizens to have arms, and we don't need the rest of the world telling US that we shouldn't allow OUR citizens to have arms.
When you can show me the country that has ZERO murders and not just zero legal guns, I might start to see your viewpoint that guns are the problem.
And on to this point -
After WWII the US overthrew several democratically elected governments, and in many cases supported dictators.
http://killinghope.org/bblum6/overthrow.htmAfter being ousted by the Vietnamese, POL POT received American aid through the Salvation Army.
In Vietnam our soldiers protected goodyear's rubber tree farms. For every bullet hole in a rubber tree the US Army reimbursed Goodyear.
In Chile the CIA overthrew a peaceful government and allowed the murder of the entire first family, just because we could. The CIA's case report said that we had nothing to gain by murdering the Chilean government.
In the very shameful case of Guatemala - we overthrew a peaceful, liberal government to stop President Ćrbenz GuzmĆ”n from nationalizing the Banana fields. The United Fruit Company was afraid that President Guzman was going to nationalize
unused fields and so asked Truman and Eisenhower to murder everyone. The President of El Salvador supported the CIA's coup, because he was afraid that the people of El Salvador would take to the example of agrarian reform. The result was a 30 year civil war, leaving everyone dead.
In the 70's we forced Venezuela to open up it's oil fields to ease a fuel shortage in America. Saudi Arabia retaliated against Venezuela, crushing it's economy for a decade.
America has anti-slavery/forced labor laws for imported goods, yet the American government does not enforce them so that American's can enjoy cheap Chinsese sh*t.
Our government has done a lot of good in the world, but it's also done more than enough evil. De-stabilizing whole regions and killing peaceful government's for the sake of an American corporation's "rights" rights is as bad as it gets. Every example I've given is a living memory example, but as far back as this country has existed, we've been murdering everyone. In a million ways Americans deserve praise for all the good that they've done,* BUT! we are far and away from being immune to criticism and have no more a reason to be proud than any other country. Our government has been neither for nor against dictatorships and has been working with them in the Middle East and South America for a century. I'm not going to google facts to support my post here though, as this should all be common knowledge. Much of the goodwill that our country has produced has not been from our government, but from our people.
*Beate Sirota Gordon, who recently passed away, comes to mind