Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[XenHu]

After the events of last night I think my biggest suspicion is still on Selin. Immune to night kills is a new one for me in mafia games. And it would be very easy for a mafia member to claim since he would not likely be targeted at night.
I am curious what AK has to say about the accusations against him. He and wicked we fighting hard for selin and wicked turned up a s mafia.

Also this is a pretty big game and we only seem to have a few active posters. We need to hear more from a lot of people. You should have some leads/ideas with all the information that has been put out there.

Immune to nightkills can be bulletproof townie, I believe.

If he's a bullet-proof townie, he certainly isn't acting like one.

FOS: Selin

Why would you go and shout out what some of us may have figured out already. I’ll be damn surprised to see Exile alive next morning.



-X

[Anarkistsdream]

If we have another doctor, please protect Exile tonight...

Beyond that... Selin, you really did sorta screw that up... I wonder if you are here to help the town out at all... Maybe your job is to innocuously screw the town over.

[XenHu]

If we have another doctor, please protect Exile tonight...

Beyond that... Selin, you really did sorta screw that up... I wonder if you are here to help the town out at all... Maybe your job is to innocuously screw the town over.

Jester?

-X

[The1exile]

If he's a bullet-proof townie, he certainly isn't acting like one.

FOS: Selin

Why would you go and shout out what some of us may have figured out already. I’ll be damn surprised to see Exile alive next morning.



-X

I know. I think he might have the ability, though perhaps not the role.

In any case, I was clarifying for Moz's benefit, not attempting to clear Selin from being a moron.

[The1exile]

If we have another doctor, please protect Exile tonight...

Beyond that... Selin, you really did sorta screw that up... I wonder if you are here to help the town out at all... Maybe your job is to innocuously screw the town over.

Jester?

-X

Don't think so, the jester tries to get lynched, and Selin was very much against being lynched.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

jester is a foolish role anyway

[The1exile]

jester is a foolish role anyway

It gets harder as you get more experienced.

[I GOT SERVED]

jester is a foolish role anyway

Agreed.


And Aegnor has been cleared in my book. I'm still suspicious of Selin though. But the scummiest would be spieser, just for pointing an FOS with no reason. Plus, I haven't really heard much from him.

[The1exile]

And Aegnor has been cleared in my book. I'm still suspicious of Selin though. But the scummiest would be spieser, just for pointing an FOS with no reason. Plus, I haven't really heard much from him.

When I've had that role, I've been mafia.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

I'm still suspicious of Selin though. But the scummiest would be spieser, just for pointing an FOS with no reason.

Agreed, where did this come from Spieser??

FOS dominationnation you creepy little scum...

[spinwizard]

not much to say here

fos-AK

[autoload]

If we have another doctor, please protect Exile tonight...

Beyond that... Selin, you really did sorta screw that up... I wonder if you are here to help the town out at all... Maybe your job is to innocuously screw the town over.

Jester?

-X

That better be a joke...

[autoload]

I'm still suspicious of Selin though. But the scummiest would be spieser, just for pointing an FOS with no reason.

Agreed, where did this come from Spieser??

FOS dominationnation you creepy little scum...

I was going to say something when I saw that, but got sidetracked.

[Aegnor]

Exlie is also clear in my book. He made a good point there, no mafia would be stupid enough to go use their night action and risk getting caught after I've claimed the nature of my role.

I don't really want to know what his role might be at the moment, I think the revealing of my role damaged the town enough :/

I do hope the doc would be kind enough to protect me tonight so I could keep tracking people at night.

[Selin]

Vote Aegnor

Because I still think he's scum.

And yes, I did target autoload. If I was mafia, don't you think I would have refrained from targeting anyone to prove my innocence?

Congratulations master bard,
Open your mouth and put your foot in,
For you paint a target on the doc,
Surely the scum's next victim.

And now for those that do not speak in verse...

I'm the doc, and I protected auto, because he's who I would have killed (on the first day when I'm mafia, I always kill a reasonably experienced player but very rarely the most experienced player since he's the most logical target for the doc, as well.)

I believe Mandy had a damn good set of suspicions, and the turning up with wicked as scum should confirm his accusations.

it was aegnor himself who claimed
what he did yesterday night
and in above post it was you
who said "yes" to aegnor, right?

so it is nonsense to say me
that i revealed your role here
everybody could think of that
you don't need to be a seer

actually you didn't answer
why did you post "vote aegnor"
do you try to get rid of him?
is that why you voted for?

.

[Selin]

If we have another doctor, please protect Exile tonight...

Beyond that... Selin, you really did sorta screw that up... I wonder if you are here to help the town out at all... Maybe your job is to innocuously screw the town over.

if there is another doctor
better don't protect exile
because that will mean I'm right
revealing lying exile

.

[The1exile]

I'll answer Selin a) when I get back on the internet and b) when he stops spouting crap.

[Selin]

Vote Aegnor

Because I still think he's scum.

And yes, I did target autoload. If I was mafia, don't you think I would have refrained from targeting anyone to prove my innocence?

Congratulations master bard,
Open your mouth and put your foot in,
For you paint a target on the doc,
Surely the scum's next victim.

And now for those that do not speak in verse...

I'm the doc, and I protected auto, because he's who I would have killed (on the first day when I'm mafia, I always kill a reasonably experienced player but very rarely the most experienced player since he's the most logical target for the doc, as well.)

I believe Mandy had a damn good set of suspicions, and the turning up with wicked as scum should confirm his accusations.

it was aegnor himself who claimed
what he did yesterday night
and in above post it was you
who said "yes" to aegnor, right?

so it is nonsense to say me
that i revealed your role here
everybody could think of that
you don't need to be a seer

actually you didn't answer
why did you post "vote aegnor"
do you try to get rid of him?
is that why you voted for?

.

Aimless,
sorry not to write this post as a poem, but i realized that i mistakenly overwrote my second post on day 2, replacing the former poem with the post above. In order not to mislead all players who haven't read my former post, I have to explain it. So, below you will find the summary of my second post on day 2:

I quoted Exile's post that votes Aegnor for being scum and wrote a poem stating: Aegnor did claim his role on day 1 and said he is a tracker. And on day 2 he said that he tracked you (exile) and found out that you visited autoload. And then you said that he is right, so you verified him. However knowing Aegnor says the truth, you voted Aegnor, which made you scummy in my eyes.

I also voted The1exile for that in my former post . Here is it again:

Vote: The1exile

This explanation was needed to understand all my posts on day 2 and the reactions on them.
Aimless, I will continue now trying my best to write in poems, as before. ok? Please pm me, if anything has changed.

.

[Anarkistsdream]

That changes my mind...

Unvote
Vote: the1exile

[autoload]

So let me see if I get this straight:

1. Aegnor claimed to have tracked The1exile and found him to target autoload.
2. The1exile verified that he indeed targeted me for a night action, thus admitting that Aegnor was right in his claim, but then votes him anyways.

Now it is possible that the merry men have a mafia tracker which would clear The1exile and make Aegnor guilty. Or maybe Aegnor is pro town tracker like he says and The1exile is the Doc like he says. Or maybe The1exile was scum trying to kill me, and the real doctor saved me (unlikely)? Or Mafia cop or any number of mafia roles that can target but not kill...

It doesn't make sense that The1exile would vote for Aegnor after Aegnor was right about his night actions, but he did say he will come back and answer why. In the mean time I think we should all work towards who to agree on for today's Lynch.



I still believe AK_iceman would be a good choice for his defending of Aegnor with the known scum wicked. At the same time I understand that wicked may have just been trying to gain the trust of a potential townie. I like to use that tactic when playing as mafia.

The choice between The1exile and Aegnor is a coin flip and I would rather not guess on one of those two today.

That leaves Selin as another choice. Enough said about that.

As far as spiesr's little FoS... It could be he's a newbie Cop and don't know how to let us know that he got a lucky guilty reading on dominationnation.

Not enough evidence on dominationnation to warrant a Lynch at this time. Speaking of which, it would be nice to hear from dominationnation.

If I'm missing anybody, let me know why you suspect them and I will give my thoughts on them.

[moz976]

I think it really is a toss up between AK and Selin as to who I would vote for. As I said before I want to give AK a chance to defend himself of the accusations against him.

I would also like to add the people that we haven't heard anything from:
Colaalone -(A replacement and I don't envy all the reading you have to do)
LSU - (had a good bit of suspicion on him yesterday for his band wagoning could be laying low)
dwightschrute- (haven't heard much of importance from him all game)
willis - (Same here)
Hecter - (spoke but didn't give any opinions on anything)

We might need to put some pressure on some of these people to get some talk out of them.

[willis]

Sorry for not posting...I've had exams

Anyways... what do you want me to say?

[Anarkistsdream]

Sorry for not posting...I've had exams

Anyways... what do you want me to say?

We want to know what you think about everything that has gone on... IN YOUR OWN WORDS....

As it is, I agree that Exile said he'd comeback...

So

Unvote

[AK_iceman]

Yesterday, I defended Aegnor and went after Mandy just to end that God forsaken day! The way Mandy kept stirring up confusion and switching targets made me think he was more scummy than Aegnor at the moment, so I pushed for his lynch. Yes, it's really too bad that wicked did the same thing because now it looks like we were helping each other, which was NOT the case.

I still think Aegnor is suspicious, along with the1exile and XenHu. I'll see if I can show proof of my suspicions later today if I have time.

[XenHu]

I think it really is a toss up between AK and Selin as to who I would vote for. As I said before I want to give AK a chance to defend himself of the accusations against him.

I would also like to add the people that we haven't heard anything from:
Colaalone -(A replacement and I don't envy all the reading you have to do)
LSU - (had a good bit of suspicion on him yesterday for his band wagoning could be laying low)
dwightschrute- (haven't heard much of importance from him all game)
willis - (Same here)
Hecter - (spoke but didn't give any opinions on anything)

We might need to put some pressure on some of these people to get some talk out of them.

I agree on LSU. If anyone remembers, I had questioned him on why he hopped on a band-wagon, even voted him to see if I could get better info. All he had said was ‘go ahead, lynch me, it’s not going to help the town’(loosing paraphrasing). I’ll see if I can dig up the exact quotes.

-X