Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[spinwizard]

i want selin to tell us his role/ powers exactly!

[Selin]

As has been said, but worth repeating: there's no way a halfway competent mafia would nightkill selin.

If I understand things, then the prevailing theory is that the mafia would conceptually have received an infusion of talent after the archery contest (selin and mandy), and were it not for mandy, we wouldn't even be aware of this possibility. The question is, are there more people that might possibly switch from town to mafia?

The obvious thing to me is that whoever wins the archery contest has to be lynched immediately, as that person is likely to be robin.

We should keep selin around for another day at least. I also think that if selin has powers, he might want to reveal them now. I'm not demanding this, just putting it out on the table. If he has some skills that we can use to ferret out bad guys, then there's no reason to lynch him yet.

I'm glad to see that IGS posted, and t'was a sensible post, so

UNVOTE
VOTE dwight

Same principle.

i still do not understand it
how you came to conclusion
that i will join in mafia
that's not my consideration

regarding my skills
nothing more than i told you
what else do you expect from me
mafia can't kill me, but you


.

[pancakemix]

So it's arrow proof townie, then.

[spinwizard]

selin what is your role?

[Selin]

Good question and good point. But now I wonder if when Selin becomes mafia, will he keep his power? I know it sounds like a dumb question but here's why I'm asking. The way he goes about saying it, it sounds like Selin's power can be of good use to the town. My original point and question was that if this power is so helpful, why would the mafia let us have it? It just doesn't sit with me. That's all.

-X

Well, if the speculation is correct that selin is a bullet-proof townie, then there isn't much the mafia can do aboot it. And I would presume that selin would keep his role, which would make a townie win much harder.

The idea of lynching selin on day 4 sounds good to me.

that's exactly what i have been
telling to you last two days
but you can lynch me anytime
if that is what the town says

.

[XenHu]

selin what is your role?

Did you not see his post?

-X

[Selin]

So it's arrow proof townie, then.

.

[Selin]

If I were mafia, I wouldn't kill selin. Reason being, there was (and still is) much speculation of him. By the mafia not killing selin, we worry about selin. Hence, nobody worrying about other mafia members.

.

[Selin]

i am guessing that the person that wins the archery contest is probebly robin hood but it is not garantied. I assume that u all got little archery skill numbers in your pm's so from this i think that it will be done by a random number/ percentage system to work out who wins.


do u all agree?

those with archery skills probably
will join contest on day three
but me with no such skill will be
entertaining you for free

.

[XenHu]

those with archery skills probably
will join contest on day three
but me with no such skill will be
entertaining you for free

.

That makes sense. I wouldn't expect a bard to have much skill at Archery.

Unvote:Selin

-X

[Aegnor]

Hmm ok, let's say we don't lynch Selin today, in that case I want to throw in a few leads, backed up with some evidence from day 1:

(regarding the bandwagoning on Autoload)

The following people have followed Mandy's little trick and are accused of bandwagoning: LSU Tiger Josh, Guilty_Biscuit, pancakemix, willis, Fircoal.

We can assume that Auto is either a noble or peasant since Exile claimed Doc, and since I followed Exile we can probably say that both Exile and Auto are clear in that case, Which brings us to the next step, Some of the people on that least could be mafia bandwagoners (except for the dead ones of course).

[Aegnor]

damn typo, least=list.

[I GOT SERVED]

I remember that LSU had a bit of controversy thrown his way during day one. I wasn't entirely convinced by his argument. I still don't think that there's enough against him for me to vote for him. But he still looks scummy.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

Hmm ok, let's say we don't lynch Selin today, in that case I want to throw in a few leads, backed up with some evidence from day 1:

(regarding the bandwagoning on Autoload)

The following people have followed Mandy's little trick and are accused of bandwagoning: LSU Tiger Josh, Guilty_Biscuit, pancakemix, willis, Fircoal.

We can assume that Auto is either a noble or peasant since Exile claimed Doc, and since I followed Exile we can probably say that both Exile and Auto are clear in that case, Which brings us to the next step, Some of the people on that least could be mafia bandwagoners (except for the dead ones of course).

I pointed out some 60+ pages back that I voted for Auto before Mandy. I have to admit that I'd like to know where everyone else on the list stands.

[spiesr]

So are we all agreed to lynch Selin Day 4? If that's a yes, who to lynch today?

How about you?

[pancakemix]

So are we all agreed to lynch Selin Day 4? If that's a yes, who to lynch today?

How about you?

I think I can help the town achieve it's ultimate objective of eliminating the merry men.

[spiesr]

Mayby Hector thinks will we lynch him if he doesn't post, and so he is jester?

[hecter]

No, that's not it. If I was a jester, I would post a lot of stupid stuff, like Mandy did.

[for dummies]

GOD Stop talking about the stupid jester. it is a dumb role. i am sure aimless wasn't idiotic enough to put it is this game. Every time someone does something suspicious you guys are like "oh oh jester jester" just be quite

[The1exile]

No, that's not it. If I was a jester, I would post a lot of stupid stuff, like Mandy did.

The only way I managed to get lynched as jester last time was to write in size 0 that I was mafia. And even then it only worked after the mafia godfather had already said he was mafia

[XenHu]

Vote: LSU

My attention now turns to you. What do you make of the recent information?

-X

[dominationnation]

you guys all seem to be assuming that the archary contest will just be something in writtng by the mod and that non of us will have anything to do with it. How do you know that we dont have to do something or another?

[got tonkaed]

Although it probably doesnt help to speculate about something too much like this....One would assume that even if there is an interactive element in the archery contest, players with better archery skills are probably going to be at an advantage either way. I find it unlikely that the worst archer in the game, no matter their involvement will out shoot robin hood.

[dominationnation]

Although it probably doesnt help to speculate about something too much like this....One would assume that even if there is an interactive element in the archery contest, players with better archery skills are probably going to be at an advantage either way. I find it unlikely that the worst archer in the game, no matter their involvement will out shoot robin hood.

Probably townies or anyone else without any skill wont eve participate in the games

[got tonkaed]

Probably townies or anyone else without any skill wont eve participate in the games

Im fairly sure if you dont particpate in the action somehow aimless reserves the right to modkill.