Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[dominationnation]

Probably townies or anyone else without any skill wont eve participate in the games

Im fairly sure if you dont particpate in the action somehow aimless reserves the right to modkill.

no I mean that they arnt given the choice to compeate

[pancakemix]

Some of us have no skill at archery.

[got tonkaed]

Understood, selin referenced as much when he said that as the bard he wouldnt be participating it only makes sense that a fair number of players do not.

[autoload]

So it's arrow proof townie, then.

.

A possibility that if he is mafia, that claiming arrow proof will explain why the mafia isn't killing him.

Hopefully we actually are able to Lynch him Day 4 without too much trouble...

[autoload]

Hmm ok, let's say we don't lynch Selin today, in that case I want to throw in a few leads, backed up with some evidence from day 1:

(regarding the bandwagoning on Autoload)

The following people have followed Mandy's little trick and are accused of bandwagoning: LSU Tiger Josh, Guilty_Biscuit, pancakemix, willis, Fircoal.

We can assume that Auto is either a noble or peasant since Exile claimed Doc, and since I followed Exile we can probably say that both Exile and Auto are clear in that case, Which brings us to the next step, Some of the people on that least could be mafia bandwagoners (except for the dead ones of course).

Where has willis been?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I don't know although it's mother's day in the states so many people may have been away from the computer today. As far as the accusation goes it is again from one of the same 2 people that have been fingering me the whole game.

While it wouldn't surprise me if the winner of the archery contest was in fact robin hood, it is possible that someone else may win as I'm sure some roles were in fact given an archery skill other then just robin and say the sheriff. Otherwise it wouldn't be much of a contest. Besides if the contest was "rigged" there would be no reason for anyone to even attempt to compete in it

[Incandenza]

A couple of quick things before I go to sleep....

I must have misread that post of Selin's, too lazy to look for it, where he seemed to say that he would have done the same thing as mandy (i.e. convince us to lynch him by day 3) if he'd known that such was a viable plan. But Selin being bulletproof makes a kind of sense, so I'd be inclined to put lynching plans on the shelf.

Having no archery skills myself, I can only guess, but my guess is that a certain number of people received some sort of numerical value between 1 and 100 for their archery skill. Then Aim consults random.org... So odds are that robin will at least be in the top 2 or 3...

With a game this big, the submariners are rampant and are going to conceptually cause us trouble down the road. My vote for dwight stays, since he's been online today and posted elsewhere but not here.

[for dummies]

I agree that robin will probably be in the top 3. Then what do we do? Do we have the cop investigate the three of them? do we make all three roleclaim?

Also even if the cop does investigate them what if robin is the godfather? I mentioned that earlier and still think it is a distinct possiblitity based on the circumstances.

[Anarkistsdream]

Alright everyone... I have read back through the thread and I can honestly say that absolutely NOTHING new has been discussed. This is turning into another Day 1 with 80+ pages.

Submariners should be dealt with in whatever way Aimless would like them to be dealt with, but something needs to happen. A lot of people disappear on weekends- like I had to this time- but many many people have not posted since Wednesday or Thursday.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

Alright everyone... I have read back through the thread and I can honestly say that absolutely NOTHING new has been discussed. This is turning into another Day 1 with 80+ pages.

I think the fact that day 1 had 80+ pages has something to do with it.

[moz976]

Hmm ok, let's say we don't lynch Selin today, in that case I want to throw in a few leads, backed up with some evidence from day 1:

(regarding the bandwagoning on Autoload)

The following people have followed Mandy's little trick and are accused of bandwagoning: LSU Tiger Josh, Guilty_Biscuit, pancakemix, willis, Fircoal.

I think that this is a fairly good place to start looking for mafia. I could see voting for LSU since I have been suspicious of him the whole game.
and willis has gone submarine since day one so that too is suspicious.

For now I will unvote hecter

But all the submariners need to come up for air.

[autoload]

Here is one Sub Mariner I don't want to mess with...

[XenHu]

I don't know although it's mother's day in the states so many people may have been away from the computer today. As far as the accusation goes it is again from one of the same 2 people that have been fingering me the whole game.

While it wouldn't surprise me if the winner of the archery contest was in fact robin hood, it is possible that someone else may win as I'm sure some roles were in fact given an archery skill other then just robin and say the sheriff. Otherwise it wouldn't be much of a contest. Besides if the contest was "rigged" there would be no reason for anyone to even attempt to compete in it

Thanks for the re-hash.



My vote stays on you.

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Good as long as you realize that you are wasting that you are wasting your vote on voting for a townie that is working for the crown.

[XenHu]

Good as long as you realize that you are wasting that you are wasting your vote on voting for a townie that is working for the crown.

If you care so much, instead of playing martyr, why don't you make your own speculations?

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'm busy right now at work, but I'm sure not all 25 players still living have been posting.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

Nope. Who has been the most inactive today (mafia day)?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

But off the top of my head I would say Hecter is pretty suspicious based on the fact that he averages 52 posts a day and he hasn't been posting much in here.

[Anarkistsdream]

Spiesr, Dwight, Willis, and Hecter are the ones who post the least and who- when they do post- have nothing inventive or intelligent to say.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

Spiesr, Dwight, Willis, and Hecter are the ones who post the least and who- when they do post- have nothing inventive or intelligent to say.

Out of those four spieser is the highest in my suspisions. But revealing their role wouldn't tell me much - then again that is just a consequence of them not posting that much.

I'm voting spiesr - vote:spiesr

BTW: Mandy lets out an evil chuckle everytime this thread grows another 10 pages.

[autoload]

Well, everybody get on board someone. When we get them to Lynch-2 or something see what they say...

[wicked]

Well, everybody get on someone.

HERE I AM!!

[moz976]

I am going to go ahead and vote LSU

I have been accusing him on both days one for his band wagoning and then for his lack of a good defense. As I beleive Xen said playing the martyr is no defense.

[XenHu]

Well, everybody get on someone.

HERE I AM!!

-X

[Aegnor]

Hmm I'll Vote LSU for now. Although I'm not 100% sure of his scumminess, granted he was bandwagoning and failed to provide a sensible defense, but it's a bit strange to me that no one came to his aid. Unless of course, the rest of the scum are experienced enough to know not to affiliate themselves with someone like LSU.

Bottom line, we have no real evidence to verify LSU as scum, other than his behavior, but I would gladly point my fingers at Willis (bandwagoning and submarining) and Hecter (submarining) at the same breath. If anything changes I might shift my vote to the other suspects.