Moderator: Community Team
madmitch wrote:pretty sure I voted Thorth
madmitch wrote:He might be playing that new guy card, so keep on pushing him Dakky, better him than me
Kamikaze Jawa wrote:Greetings! As Lord Voldemort stated, I am replacing your absentee. If you'll allow me to say, I am brand new so I apologise in advance for any stupid noobiness but shall try my best.
I have read through the entire thread but at this point I don't feel able to confidently pick up any scum tells so for now I shall vote no lynch.
Pikanchion wrote:I was very careful not to ask about any aspect of the role except how many characters they encompass initially, however it appeared as though some had taken that to be an attempt to lure out Gollum, which is why I became more specific as to what I meant afterwards, mentioning Dwarves in particular. With potentially as many as 13 players as dwarves I don't see how this could really be spying out roles... Replying in the negative does not mean you are a dwarf, nor does it mean you are not a dwarf, and affirming this hypothesis only makes you one of likely 6-11 others, with no clue as to whether your role in particular has any abilities or not; FĆli & KĆli as a single role would likely have some sort of ability, while Bofur & Bombur as a single role would still probably just be a vanilla townie.
My guess is that nobody does have multiple characters as their role, and with that being the case I have information I wish to share before the first night phase, however if I am wrong about that then my revelation is bound to be harmful to town.
ZaBeast wrote:And what about your role? Pika wanted to know if anybody was playing more than one character. He said he had information he would share if no one was.
Kamikaze Jawa wrote:Greetings! As Lord Voldemort stated, I am replacing your absentee. If you'll allow me to say, I am brand new so I apologise in advance for any stupid noobiness but shall try my best.
I have read through the entire thread but at this point I don't feel able to confidently pick up any scum tells so for now I shall vote no lynch.
Pikanchion wrote:You clearly refuse to participate in Day 1 of the game because you're set on No Lynching, even if you are set on a No Lynch you could at least comment on something other than the setup of the game. How does this help town? How is town meant to have anything to go on going into Day 2 if nobody talks about anything other than setup during Day 1? Refusing to properly participate in Day 1 sets you up as a neutral party, you've disagreed with nobody over anything substantial, and likewise nobody has anything to disagree with you over. If scum this is a valid tactic, if town this is simply selfish.
No Lynching unless a candidate for scum appears is a self-fulfilling prophecy, if nobody has any pressure put on them then nobody will ever look scummy. If a game is day-starting it's clearly balanced under the expectation of a Day 1 lynch, otherwise there's no reason not to make it a night-start game.
MudPuppy wrote:ZaBeast wrote:And what about your role? Pika wanted to know if anybody was playing more than one character. He said he had information he would share if no one was.
You helping to promote Pika's role-fishing tease, Beast? The setup question is fine (though probably not very helpful) but then going straight into asking him about his role... with a decent potential for a brand new player to offer more than was asked?!? Hmmm.
Samlen wrote:That's just it, saying whether or not you're playing more than one dwarf IS helping scum out. By saying so you are confirming you are a dwarf, and if there's a vanilla townie standard in this game it would be dwarves. So by answering yes you're practically saying i'm vanilla and not worth attacking to the scum, leaving it easier for them to pick off power roles
Samlen wrote:That's just it, saying whether or not you're playing more than one dwarf IS helping scum out. By saying so you are confirming you are a dwarf, and if there's a vanilla townie standard in this game it would be dwarves. So by answering yes you're practically saying i'm vanilla and not worth attacking to the scum, leaving it easier for them to pick off power roles
Ragian wrote:Well done, Skoff
Kamikaze Jawa wrote:I have read through the entire thread but at this point I don't feel able to confidently pick up any scum tells so for now I shall vote no lynch.
ZaBeast wrote:Samlen wrote:That's just it, saying whether or not you're playing more than one dwarf IS helping scum out. By saying so you are confirming you are a dwarf, and if there's a vanilla townie standard in this game it would be dwarves. So by answering yes you're practically saying i'm vanilla and not worth attacking to the scum, leaving it easier for them to pick off power roles
I would agree with you if we were talking about regular dwarves (though I would expect Thorin to have some powers), but double dwarves could be a special kind of dwarf. And we either have one semi-confirmed townie (could be scum lying also) or important info from Pika. I don't see what's wrong in that.
madmitch wrote:won't be posting to much in next few days, had someone close to me pass away
Dukasaur wrote:saxitoxin wrote:taking medical advice from this creature; a morbidly obese man who is 100% convinced he willed himself into becoming a woman.
Your obsession with mrswdk is really sad.
ConfederateSS wrote:Just because people are idiots... Doesn't make them wrong.
Dukasaur wrote:saxitoxin wrote:taking medical advice from this creature; a morbidly obese man who is 100% convinced he willed himself into becoming a woman.
Your obsession with mrswdk is really sad.
ConfederateSS wrote:Just because people are idiots... Doesn't make them wrong.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users