CYOC #5 [5/16] ENDGAME [DINO DOWN]

[Thorthoth]

My conclusion is that most everyone has some sort of 'ability' but they are mostly stupid or weird. Dakky, however, got rekt because he gave the mod a vanilla townie option and no mod without a sense of humour wouldn't take that option to troll. I lol'd. This oracle seems to support my theory, but a few deaths will confirm it outright.

How did you come to these conclusions. please elaborate?
The oracle seemed like it could have just been a mod joke... or maybe it needs to be triggered by the right kind of question or password.
Also, how would dakky have 'given ''a vanilla townie option''?

[dakky21]

Also, how would dakky have 'given ''a vanilla townie option''?

It was not an option, it was actually my suggestion.

I had a talk in the private chat with TFO a lot before the game started, even before the sign-ups. We talked about the roles I'd pick and he was like "LOL, that's not going to work"... that's why I included a VT in the PM to him as a 4th possible role knowing he will most likely ignore the first 3. As others said, I got trolled obviously. Shouldn't have mention the VT, guess he would have to pick one of the three proposed, but yeah, in a weird game I am only VT and my only power is my vote.

[TheForgivenOne]

Vote Count

Skoffin: mandalorian2298, BuJaber (2)
Kwanton: The Weird One, kwanton (2)
pikanchion: benga (1)
Dakky21: aage, strike wolf, Metsfanmax, thorthoth (4)
Samlen: Pikanchion (1)
Skittles!: skoffin, madmitch (2)
No Lynch: dirtydishsoap, Samlen (2)

Not Voting: dakky21, skittles!

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch. Deadline set for October 29th at 17:00CCT. Also want to note from my rules:

If no majority is reached at the end of the deadline if made, the player with the most votes will be lynched and the game will enter into the night phase. In the event of a tie, the lynchee will be determined by a 24-hour final ballot in which every player casts a final (no changes) vote for ANY player. If there is still a tie, a runoff ballot will be held between the two or more who tied. The deadline may be extended upon request.

Just making sure everyone is aware.

[benga]

dakky is lying
he finally got his jester role
I wouldn't go for vote on him

[Metsfanmax]

dakky is lying
he finally got his jester role
I wouldn't go for vote on him

1) No. Stop playing the goddamn jester card it's 2017.

2) If dakky is actually a jester, who cares? He can have his win while the rest of us play without distraction.

[Skoffin]

My conclusion is that most everyone has some sort of 'ability' but they are mostly stupid or weird. Dakky, however, got rekt because he gave the mod a vanilla townie option and no mod without a sense of humour wouldn't take that option to troll. I lol'd. This oracle seems to support my theory, but a few deaths will confirm it outright.

How did you come to these conclusions. please elaborate?
The oracle seemed like it could have just been a mod joke... or maybe it needs to be triggered by the right kind of question or password.
Also, how would dakky have 'given ''a vanilla townie option''?

1. My role is stupid and/or weird
2. The Oracle appears to be stupid and/or weird, though maybe you are right in that it is a mod joke but I doubt it.
- Following on from those two points, I'm also assuming the mod gave silly roles out based on the mod's personality

3. Dakky stated he did; it's not me coming up with an idea out of thin air.

[benga]

dakky is lying
he finally got his jester role
I wouldn't go for vote on him

1) No. Stop playing the goddamn jester card it's 2017.

2) If dakky is actually a jester, who cares? He can have his win while the rest of us play without distraction.

okay, let's have some fun!

unvote
vote dakky

[BuJaber]

That's 5 on dakky.. getting a little too close to a lynch for it to be a joke anymore.

[Pikanchion]

That's 5 on dakky.. getting a little too close to a lynch for it to be a joke anymore.

They claimed under a fairly low amount of pressure and claimed VT, worst case is we lose a (the?) VT in a game where most—if not all—other roles are fairly powerful and non-standard. If this is a mislynch it's likely the least bad mislynch possible, so I'm willing to take that chance.

Unvote: Samlen
Vote: dakky21

[aage]

That's 5 on dakky.. getting a little too close to a lynch for it to be a joke anymore.

You think it was a joke? Dude claimed VT out of nowhere. He's either got a play and I wanna see what it is, or he's actually got VT and apparently doesn't want to be in the game.

Only really dangerous scenario that comes to mind is the nuke role Strike had ages ago in a game... I'm willing to roll the dice that it's not that.

[DirtyDishSoap]

I thought a common theme between Dakky and Mitch would be that they role revealed early without any real warning? Maybe not full blown reveals, but soft claims.

I'll just keep being a dick head and stick with the no vote, I already sense a band wagon coming.

[TheForgivenOne]

Vote Count

Skoffin: mandalorian2298, BuJaber (2)
Kwanton: The Weird One, kwanton (2)
Dakky21: aage, strike wolf, Metsfanmax, thorthoth, benga, Pikanchion (6) L-3
Skittles!: skoffin, madmitch (2)
No Lynch: dirtydishsoap, Samlen (2)

Not Voting: dakky21, skittles!

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch. Deadline set for October 29th at 17:00CCT

[Samlen]

I'd say that surely a living vanilla townie is better than a dead one but i've proven that I'm garbage at reading dakky so i have no idea \o/.

[BuJaber]

Yes - his claim is unwarranted, but it is believable. If people are joke voting him we can have fun with it for a few days, but if people don't intend on switching their vote, are they really comfortable with lynching a VT this early on?
Even no vote is a better option.

I get that it's a 16 player game and the herd needs to be thinned and the more control we have in choosing who dies is the better, but this still seems overly aggressive.

[madmitch]

T his whole Dakky thing is strange, Why did he come out with his role so early and without any pressure ? Does he want to die so soon and why ? Is he a jester or a bomb ? I think I will stay where I am at until we receive more info

[Thorthoth]

Fine, I'll be boring and prudent too. Unvote dakky. It was mostly just a joke anyway...
Of course, being boring and prudent will probably get me lynched...
since playing bizarrely and recklessly doesn't seem to do the trick.

[dakky21]

I'll try to answer all your questions in one sentence or two:

I'm not a jester or a bomb, I'm a VT in a game where obviously 15 of 16 roles are power roles (weird or not, doesn't matter) and no, I don't want to die, but I feel useless so try to understand my logic of the early claim. If we/you are going to mislynch, then rather lynch me than some important town PR.

Of course it would be better to lynch scum, but it's D1, town loses nothing from me but can gain some info on who was on my lynch and who was not, votes and unvotes etc.

[Skoffin]

I know people will believe I am going against my own policy, but I am not. As I believe this game consists of most roles having something 'extra' in it, this is one of the few times where town's nightgame will be comparable in terms of power to that of scum. As such I support a no lynch D1 for this game as I do think any variety of things could happen and it will give us a better sense of what is going on.

Unvote vote no lynch

[dakky21]

I will also

vote no lynch

because I will most likely be lynched, so at least I voted. I don't care if I will survive this day, so let's go with no lynch.

[kwanton]

That's either a Jester or someone who doesn't want to play this game anymore. So both scenarios make sense.

In light of that vote kwan

[Skittles!]

I don't believe Dakky for a second. vote dakky. He's a good player guys, this is so damn calculated because he knew precisely how people would take role claiming a fucking VT for no reason on day 1 when joke stage just finished.

Fine, I'll be boring and prudent too. Unvote dakky. It was mostly just a joke anyway...
Of course, being boring and prudent will probably get me lynched...
since playing bizarrely and recklessly doesn't seem to do the trick.

You unvote Dakky even tho bizarrely and recklessly is EXACTLY his playstyle. He loves being reckless, albeit in a way that not many people get.

Also just look at how BuJaber and benga react after his claim. It's damage control and also a way to safely push people away from voting him.

dakky is lying
he finally got his jester role
I wouldn't go for vote on him

Bolded for emphasis. Basically "I wouldn't go for vote on him" = I'm expecting you to be scared enough of the idea of a jester that you won't vote either. So easy. Even if he is a jester, who the f*ck cares? He wins, he isn't going to help town anyway because he's always going to try and get himself lynched. That's what a usual jester does.

That's 5 on dakky.. getting a little too close to a lynch for it to be a joke anymore.

BuJaber RN. Basically - "okay guys.. dont lynch my buddy... he's going suicide mode"

You have a beautiful mind dakky. If you didn't like playing mafia so much I would suggest that you be CC's permanent mafia co-host. You'd add a lot of fun ideas to setups.

But I don't agree with your conclusion. Assuming you're telling the truth: mod granted you your wish. That doesn't mean nobody else has a VT role. Generally speaking VT is the most common role. Now this game may not be standard, in which case we could have the remaining 15 players having a special role, but I find that highly unlikely.

And I don't think I need to say it, but just in case: no need for people to claim VT right now to counter dakky's hypothesis. A claim like that would be pointless and dangerous.

Off-topic: Who do we ask for confirmation that Thor is banned/find out for how long? If it's a long-term thing he needs to be replaced in the 3 games he's in. Or at the very least chess mafia since I haven't started day 1 there yet.

The only other post about Dakky that BuJaber made, whereby they don't really give an opinion. Why doesn't the fact that dakky ROLECLAIMED for no reason at all, and that of a VT, and some story that is probably not even true, bother you? Sif you don't just send stupid characters in and troll TFO (not even sorry) to make a weird ass role for you. Instead Dakky suggests to be a VT in a game that is likely to be unbalanced and crazy. How is that in any way believable?

[Skittles!]

I don't believe Dakky for a second. vote dakky. He's a good player guys, this is so damn calculated because he knew precisely how people would take role claiming a fucking VT for no reason on day 1 when joke stage just finished.

Fine, I'll be boring and prudent too. Unvote dakky. It was mostly just a joke anyway...
Of course, being boring and prudent will probably get me lynched...
since playing bizarrely and recklessly doesn't seem to do the trick.

You unvote Dakky even tho bizarrely and recklessly is EXACTLY his playstyle. He loves being reckless, albeit in a way that not many people get.

Also just look at how BuJaber and benga react after his claim. It's damage control and also a way to safely push people away from voting him.

dakky is lying
he finally got his jester role
I wouldn't go for vote on him

Bolded for emphasis. Basically "I wouldn't go for vote on him" = I'm expecting you to be scared enough of the idea of a jester that you won't vote either. So easy. Even if he is a jester, who the f*ck cares? He wins, he isn't going to help town anyway because he's always going to try and get himself lynched. That's what a usual jester does.

That's 5 on dakky.. getting a little too close to a lynch for it to be a joke anymore.

BuJaber RN. Basically - "okay guys.. dont lynch my buddy... he's going suicide mode"

You have a beautiful mind dakky. If you didn't like playing mafia so much I would suggest that you be CC's permanent mafia co-host. You'd add a lot of fun ideas to setups.

But I don't agree with your conclusion. Assuming you're telling the truth: mod granted you your wish. That doesn't mean nobody else has a VT role. Generally speaking VT is the most common role. Now this game may not be standard, in which case we could have the remaining 15 players having a special role, but I find that highly unlikely.

And I don't think I need to say it, but just in case: no need for people to claim VT right now to counter dakky's hypothesis. A claim like that would be pointless and dangerous.

Off-topic: Who do we ask for confirmation that Thor is banned/find out for how long? If it's a long-term thing he needs to be replaced in the 3 games he's in. Or at the very least chess mafia since I haven't started day 1 there yet.

The only other post about Dakky that BuJaber made, whereby they don't really give an opinion. Why doesn't the fact that dakky ROLECLAIMED for no reason at all, and that of a VT, and some story that is probably not even true, bother you? Sif you don't just send stupid characters in and troll TFO (not even sorry) to make a weird ass role for you. Instead Dakky suggests to be a VT in a game that is likely to be unbalanced and crazy. How is that in any way believable?

To add onto this because I lost my train of thought when i was typing this post -

Before people even try and come for me about not having many posts in the first day, I never post much in the first day nor even the second. I play like this in every game since coming back to CC mafia. Always takes a few game days to warm up to the game and the flow.

[BuJaber]

A little unfair to mention that there isn't much contribution from me. How am I different from anyone? I wanted to know if people are serious about voting dakky. Some players were still in the joke phase.

Nice way of sealing my fate skittles. Well played.
If dakky flips scum you have laid the groundworks for my lynch. If he flips town you also can argue for my lynch because how would I have known. You are so aggressive

Dakky is smart yes but this doesn't fit with his meta. He simply wouldn't do this if he were scum. So respectfully, you're making too much of his claim. It's a funny story that's all.

[DirtyDishSoap]

It's almost as if I'm seeing a Deja Vu from Hobbit, minus the bomb scenario.

[Skittles!]

A little unfair to mention that there isn't much contribution from me. How am I different from anyone? I wanted to know if people are serious about voting dakky. Some players were still in the joke phase.

Nice way of sealing my fate skittles. Well played.
If dakky flips scum you have laid the groundworks for my lynch. If he flips town you also can argue for my lynch because how would I have known. You are so aggressive

Dakky is smart yes but this doesn't fit with his meta. He simply wouldn't do this if he were scum. So respectfully, you're making too much of his claim. It's a funny story that's all.

Different cause you were the first person to comment after Dakky claimed yet you still didn't actually say anything about how bizarre it was for dakky to do that.

What kind of defence is this btw, basically giving up just cause one person accused you of being in cahoots with 2 or maybe 3 people (I'm still unsure by Thor). Just because it was aggressive doesn't mean you should just roll over. All you can say is something pretty neutral about dakky, which just further cements my suspicion of you.

Dakky has a defined meta and this goes against that. Every time he tries to throw odd balls and play recklessly on Day 1 is when he isn't town. Honestly, he recruited me in Mass Effect Mafia because on Day 1, I picked him out to be nontown that day.