@jfm, any reason to think blacky would be notified if healed? You don't get notified if you get saved by a NK by a doc, I don't really see why a day doc would trigger a notification from the mod
TX AG 90 wrote:That being said, I'm still on the fence with these 2, but agree that one has to go and maybe both.
You think they could be on the same scum team?
TX AG 90 wrote:But how will we know if the healing comes? Just because Blacky says he is healed doesn't make it so...
if blacky lies about being healed we should easily know he is scum.
Case 1: He is healed but says he isn't: day doc can counter-claim and we got blacky and SW pegged as scum
Case 2: He isn't healed, but says he is: either we lynch blacky to not risk losing a doc, or we lynch SW directly. Either way we lynch the other one the following day if the 1st one hasn't turned out scum.
aage wrote:- He says there is a day doctor, there is absolutely no evidence of this, who will heal Blacky. If that is true, there's only two people who could possibly know that: the day doctor, or the poisoner('s teammates). Secondly, if there is a day doctor who can cure poison, they would have used their day doc power on Blacky the moment they saw his post about being poisoned. Therefore there is absolutely no reason to assume this can be true. FoS Mets here for not at all thinking this through and yelling to "give jfm time to play out his gambit". There is no gambit.
Blacky might have been poisoned by redirection or by a SK, therefore being poisoned doesn't necessarily mean he isn't scum. At this point, I think it would be poor play to let him die so early but the doc might not have made the call yet (I am not it though).
But I agree jfm saying he knows there is a day doc (and who it is) is immensely suspicious, especially since he claims to not have used his action last night, as I would assume there would still be hidden aspects to his role, so I doubt he's taking his information from there