Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[kwanton]

It seems like whenever anyone is close to lynch they say "significant loss for town" or something like that. That sentence really loses its meaning since everyone is saying it....

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Kalish save the threat of "if you know who I am" bit. That routine is old and retired. You put a vote on a player that named a pro gotham figure that no one countered. you claimed to want more information from someoen that already had claimed name and role. There is nothing else that mandy could've told us.

[Skoffin]

Yeah, little disappointing defence there. How many votes are currently on him anyway?

Jesus, I wanted to reply to that one specific post, in the like 5 minutes it took to right the next one you guys sure have jumped to an awful lot of conclusions...

That's what I figured so I decided to wait for you, I didn't see your name anywhere so I thought you might of went offline.

[Chad22342]

It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.

[kwanton]

It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.

It says it on the first post. Neutrino FYI.

[Koesen]

If I reveal my role and don't get lynched, I'll certainly be killed tonight, which would help the town less then if you hang me wrongfully.

It's late and I'm tired and I guess I'm not thinking clearly, but I can't think of anything that might make it better for you to be wrongly lynched than to be nightkilled.

[Skoffin]

It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.

You don't need to repeat yourself, the mod will see it when he goes through to tally votes.

[kalishnikov]

What kalishnikov do wrong? I say we keep him for later if we are ever stumped, he is there. We dont have a time limit, and both Mandy and Koesen seem like they shouldnt be lynchd, atleast, not until we get some better evidence and a little more time to think this over.

He voted me in response to a Cop claim. "Save him for later"? We are not making pickles, we are hanging Scum.
FOS jnd for defending kalshnikov

And clearly theres more then meets the eye here. Jnd didn't defend me, he spoke reason.

Its not like I'm going anywhere, there are several more scummy people then me at the moment (n8freeman, derderf of the top of my head). All he said is perhaps some more looking should be done before you kick me off the gallows...

If you don't find any better leads, I'll still be here....

[kwanton]

"More than meets the eye"

Transformers? Here?!

Meh. Are you saying that there may be some scum conspiracy against you? Explain.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Its not like I'm going anywhere, there are several more scummy people then me at the moment (n8freeman, derderf of the top of my head). All he said is perhaps some more looking should be done before you kick me off the gallows...

I don't know who N8 is in the game, but you are acting a lot scummier than he is in my opinion. Derf already claimed fool. We already have discovered that "fool" is a pro townie role so he is of no concern right now. You are the one that has acted the scummiest through being a scum or else "tryign to get more info on mandy" when he already had given his role name,his persona, and his investigations. yet he got a vote from you. That is 99.9999999999999999999999999999999999999% scummy.

[kalishnikov]

Kalish save the threat of "if you know who I am" bit. That routine is old and retired. You put a vote on a player that named a pro gotham figure that no one countered. you claimed to want more information from someoen that already had claimed name and role. There is nothing else that mandy could've told us.

Wow, way to respond to the points in a post that are convenient for you.

For like the 80th time, I did it because immediately after everything he said, he went silent and never responded to several valid arguments by Koesen and others. I thought maybe if I put a vote on him, he'd pop up, and look, he did.

Never once did I say we should lynch him. Never once did I say we shouldn't believe him. Votes are used for more then just getting a lynch...

[kalishnikov]

"More than meets the eye"

Transformers? Here?!

Meh. Are you saying that there may be some scum conspiracy against you? Explain.

Possibly, but probably not. It just seems mandalorian was awful quick to jump on Jnd for defending me, when he did no such thing.

[kalishnikov]

Its not like I'm going anywhere, there are several more scummy people then me at the moment (n8freeman, derderf of the top of my head). All he said is perhaps some more looking should be done before you kick me off the gallows...

I don't know who N8 is in the game, but you are acting a lot scummier than he is in my opinion. Derf already claimed fool. We already have discovered that "fool" is a pro townie role so he is of no concern right now. You are the one that has acted the scummiest through being a scum or else "tryign to get more info on mandy" when he already had given his role name,his persona, and his investigations. yet he got a vote from you. That is 99.9999999999999999999999999999999999999% scummy.

So I've acted scummier then the submariner who only turns up to vote? You can clealry see his name under "Users browsing this forum" regularly but ok.

And I'll repeat again, because I'm starting to think maybe you've got a selective reading disorder, I put a vote on him because he just let all the possibly valid points made about his motives roll off him without as much as an acknowledgment.

Personally, I think your pretty dumb if you really see putting the first vote on someone (with the intent of info gathering) as being scummy, regardless of what he claims to be. It's the first vote... he's not gonna die....

This is becoming less a question of motives and more a popularity contest. Just lynch me if your gonna. Its like playing a game of Risk with loaded dice...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

WHen you've played enough games with Mandy, you'll realize that is what he does. He himself said that he may be paranoid and wasn't rushing to lynch Koesen until possibly tomorrow. Reality I don't care what you think as 1 vote doesn't really "force" anyones hand that doesn't want to be forced unless they are a NOOB. He didn't respond b/c of the vote placed on him as much as the reasoning behind it. If you want to point a finger at someone and maybe get more info give a fos to them or get more people on to vote with you. You say it's a popularity contest, I disagree. Mandy is more times then not killed off early b/c he is good at the game. It's to our advantage to use his skills while he is around. Had anyone else cast a vote at someone claiming a cop role that no one countered they would be jumped on. Instead you were the one that jumped on it and as such you find yourself at the end of the rope. Especially being that you did the "town will be sorry i died" claim that everyone does, but few actually are. If anything that is yet another scum sign stating that, but somehow refuse to give out a name or role when you're already getting lynched unless you pull a miracle out of your butt.

[Chad22342]

It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.

It says it on the first post. Neutrino FYI.

Well then why would it have replacement needed ASAP on the top.

[kalishnikov]

So I'm waiting.

You were all certainly quick enough to jump on the bandwagon, and I can see your all still here.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Hint genious(chad) yes it's needed asap. you made 1 post it wasn't responded to. you wait a few minutes and post it again. again it's not responded to. do you think it may be possible that THE MOD IS NOT HERE. stop spamming the board b4 i take you out my game for being a numbskull

[Skoffin]

It says you need a replacement. I'll play if it's ok. My role was replaced earlier when I was modkilled for inactivity but I'm back now and I don't know who took my role.

It says it on the first post. Neutrino FYI.

Well then why would it have replacement needed ASAP on the top.

He means it says who replaced you on the front page. Thus you cannot replace anyone in this game.

[kwanton]

Yea you would already know one role and that would give you an unfair advantage. Neutrino does not need to replaced(I don't think). Actually I don't know who needs to be replaced. PM the mod and stop posting here. KThanxBAi.

[kwanton]

So I'm waiting.

You were all certainly quick enough to jump on the bandwagon, and I can see your all still here.

I was not quick to "jump on the bandwagon" as you say. I actually held back my vote until you posted. My vote is pretty much because you had a weak defense at first and then proceeded to flesh it out with generic sayings. i.e. "I am important to town. Plz don't lynch."

[kalishnikov]

If you want to point a finger at someone and maybe get more info give a fos to them or get more people on to vote with you.

lol, wow. No matter what I say its a lose-lose with you. Perhaps that was what I've been trying to do, but since you've all jump on me so quickly, I didn't have a chance?

So since madalorian is such a good player, we should all just believe what he says blindly? Ok.... Good idea....

It was too late for a roleclaim before I even saw the thread... I was here at like 3 pm EST, and I came back at about 1 am EST and I'm lynch -2? What else do you want from me?

[kalishnikov]

So I'm waiting.

You were all certainly quick enough to jump on the bandwagon, and I can see your all still here.

I was not quick to "jump on the bandwagon" as you say. I actually held back my vote until you posted. My vote is pretty much because you had a weak defense at first and then proceeded to flesh it out with generic sayings. i.e. "I am important to town. Plz don't lynch."

Right, right.

So really, do you guys just read the parts of the posts that are convenient for you?

[kwanton]

Again. Not everyone was quick to bandwagon.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Being that you haven't been lynched, I would suggest if you do have the great pro gotham role that you reveal it and perhaps some will unvote. In regards to his comments it is wise to follow the ones that make sense. He was not the first to put a vote on you. That would be me in regards to voting someone that claimed protownie. He wasn't even the 2nd as that would be our resident fool. He happened to agree with the reasons and put his "investigation result" on hold til we know for sure.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

And yes not everyone was quick on the bandwagon. This bandwagon has taken over 12 hours to form and still hasn't resulted in your lynch. I know right now I'm firmly convinced of you guilt as are many other players, but you have your chance to save yourself now or forever hold your peace.