The Tick Mafia - JUSTICE PREVAILS!

[swang918]

Could Charle have visited someone with a view to saving them, but had the bad luck to visit scum who took the opportunity to shoot him.
Sort of a no good deed goes unpunished thing?

Ok if this was the case then who did scum kill last night?

You are just getting sketchier and sketchier

Vote Loose Canon

and FoS Pixar for reasons in my last post

[fusibaseball]

I'm also not so sure that Charle's kill was random. He was suspecting Pixar and Loose Canon before he got on the no Lynch wagon. And you can chalk that up to randomness but what I can't get past is that yesterday when Pixar was about to have to claim, that was when Loose started up with all his nonsense. And if Loose and Pixar are indeed together on the scum team, they would want to kill Charle because he was the only one suspecting them together. And if that was the case, Charle was a great target because until Sonic pulled this quote, everyone was agreeing that the hit was random.

This exactly. +1

[Extreme Ways]

Vote Drake, hasn't even logged in in the past 5 days so I assume he'll be mod-killed at the end of Day 2 as a replacement hasn't been found.

I agree with everything you have said except the quoted part. It's not useful to lynch someone who will be mod-killed anyway, that's wasting a lynch.

[fusibaseball]

Just pull any of his posts out of context and analyze it individually for a second:

Does it count as a win for Charle if Town wins?

Like what is the meaning of this post? What is this?

Unvote Drake, vote Loose Cannon

I assume that because you haven't voted yet as you promised you would Day 1, you won't be interested in voting at all Day 2 and that makes you as useless as Drake but with confusing activity to boot

[fusibaseball]

I agree with everything you have said except the quoted part. It's not useful to lynch someone who will be mod-killed anyway, that's wasting a lynch.

Yes I agree and it just occurred to me that there's still a non-zero chance we find a replacement before the end of Day 2 so there is hope for Drake's role in the case it's Town, hence my vote switch

[degaston]

Announcement:

traffic133 has agreed to stay on.
Charle will be replacing drake_259. (He is not to mention anything about his previous role.)

Vote Count:

Loose Canon : 3 (fusibaseball, SoN!c, swang918)
PepeAtila : 1 (DirtyDishSoap)
Razorvich : 1 (Ragian)

No Vote : 13 (*Pixar*, Charle, Darin44, DukeHazzard, Extreme Ways, General Bax, Loose Canon, Maxleod, PepeAtila, Razorvich, strike wolf, TrafalgarLaw01, traffic133)

18 Alive, 10 votes needed to lynch

[TrafalgarLaw01]

Ok, so just for us to differenciate what we refer to maybe we can come with names like Doc Charle (The dead one) and Chare the new Charle.
What you guys think?

[Extreme Ways]

I would also add that Charle should not respond to people quoting him in the past. So that he cannot now say anything about his Doc-opinion about Sonic.

[Darin44]

Could Charle have visited someone with a view to saving them, but had the bad luck to visit scum who took the opportunity to shoot him.
Sort of a no good deed goes unpunished thing?

Ok if this was the case then who did scum kill last night?

You are just getting sketchier and sketchier

Vote Loose Canon

and FoS Pixar for reasons in my last post

I will hold my vote for now. but I thank loose not voting so we can see if count or not is scummy. Pixar is still on my list of FOS

[degaston]

We interrupt our regular broadcast to bring you this special report.

Greetings Citizens. A large crown has gathered in The City, eager to place blame for the death of our beloved mad scientist, Dr. Mung Mung. Their anger appeared to be converging around Loose Canon, who had drawn attention to himself yesterday by, among other things, being unable to vote. Materials had been gathered for the construction of a crude gallows to exact swift retribution should the will of the people demand it.

But suddenly, in a stunning turn of events, as Loose was being led to the gallows to jeers and the occasional throwing of an overripe tomato, seemingly from out of nowhere, a cloud of thick smoke enveloped him. Once the smoke had cleared, Loose was nowhere to be seen. It appears that the crowd's thirst for vengeance will not be satisfied today. At least not by lynching Loose Canon. They will have to search elsewhere to satisfy their blood-lust.

For The City News, I'm Brian Pinhead.

[degaston]

Vote Count:

PepeAtila : 1 (DirtyDishSoap)
Razorvich : 1 (Ragian)
Loose Canon : 0 ()

No Vote : 16 (*Pixar*, Charle, Darin44, DukeHazzard, Extreme Ways, fusibaseball, General Bax, Loose Canon, Maxleod, PepeAtila, Razorvich, SoN!c, strike wolf, swang918, TrafalgarLaw01, traffic133)

18 Alive, 10 votes needed to lynch

[Extreme Ways]

I'm assuming this is related to Loose's voteless role. Despite questionable play, this would confirm Loose as town to me.

[SoN!c]

I would also add that Charle should not respond to people quoting him in the past. So that he cannot now say anything about his Doc-opinion about Sonic.

Cop opinion, charle was doc..

Love it to have Charle back! He was reading it all very well, unlike some that just seem to fast scroll trough it all while others are seamingly not even in the game atm..(bax for sure, raz by the comments he gets..).

Also why would "New Charle" act or comment on his previous old Foc role? I think it was stated clearly he would not.


Now back to Loose - could it be he is a Mafia-aligned Tree Stump? If so he may be allowed to continuously contacting the other Mafiosi privately (also during the day) and by doing so (one way comms) he laid out the "ground plan" for them to follow?

On mafia wiki it says "Depending on how good a strategist the Tree Stump is, this can be nightmarishly powerful for scum."

Then the other scum would surely try to protect him by making us believe (or making us doubt enough) he is townie.

PS: Im getting a Good Mist read on one - just like loose dissapearing in a tick mist cloud according to the news bulletin.. And a good mist is almost completely undetectable until it's too late..

[Extreme Ways]

I'm not experienced in forum mafia, but I was under the imrpession based on Raz's game that mafia had access to chat all the time. Correct me if I'm wrong.

[Loose Canon]

Strike posted that in elementary mafia Doc protects Cop night 1.

1. So maybe the reason there was only 1 killing was because mafia targetted Cop as well as Charle.
2. Granted it is possible that Charle was doctor to whoever the Cop is.

The reason I asked if a town win meant Charle won (answer I've been given is yes) is Cop should declare what he discovered - because cop would win if town wins even if cop is killed.
Because of reason 1 above the information if revealed will help town - but if kept to Cop because of reason 1 there has to be a strong danger that mafia will kill cop making the information useless to town because it would die with cop.

Cop I think you should declare what you discovered now - for the greater benefit of town.

[Extreme Ways]

Strike posted that in elementary mafia Doc protects Cop night 1.

1. So maybe the reason there was only 1 killing was because mafia targetted Cop as well as Charle.
2. Granted it is possible that Charle was doctor to whoever the Cop is.

The reason I asked if a town win meant Charle won (answer I've been given is yes) is Cop should declare what he discovered - because cop would win if town wins even if cop is killed.
Because of reason 1 above the information if revealed will help town - but if kept to Cop because of reason 1 there has to be a strong danger that mafia will kill cop making the information useless to town because it would die with cop.

Cop I think you should declare what you discovered now - for the greater benefit of town.

Doc doesnt know who cop is. and cop may not have valuable information yet. Outing yourself as cop means you're a target, and theres no doc to protect you either.

[SoN!c]

Strike posted that in elementary mafia Doc protects Cop night 1.

1. So maybe the reason there was only 1 killing was because mafia targetted Cop as well as Charle.
2. Granted it is possible that Charle was doctor to whoever the Cop is.

The reason I asked if a town win meant Charle won (answer I've been given is yes) is Cop should declare what he discovered - because cop would win if town wins even if cop is killed.
Because of reason 1 above the information if revealed will help town - but if kept to Cop because of reason 1 there has to be a strong danger that mafia will kill cop making the information useless to town because it would die with cop.

Cop I think you should declare what you discovered now - for the greater benefit of town.

Strike posted that in elementary mafia Doc protects Cop night 1.

1. So maybe the reason there was only 1 killing was because mafia targetted Cop as well as Charle.
2. Granted it is possible that Charle was doctor to whoever the Cop is.

The reason I asked if a town win meant Charle won (answer I've been given is yes) is Cop should declare what he discovered - because cop would win if town wins even if cop is killed.
Because of reason 1 above the information if revealed will help town - but if kept to Cop because of reason 1 there has to be a strong danger that mafia will kill cop making the information useless to town because it would die with cop.

Cop I think you should declare what you discovered now - for the greater benefit of town.

Look who's here ! Now i was thinking you vanished in a thick cloud of mist..like "vansihed" for real untill a next news bulletin (but still be able to have comms with the other maffia)

You just wanna find the cop it seems?. You have been probing to find out roles all game long and now this? Also Im considering the possibility the mafia had a multiple hit planned on 2 targets but only found out only one actually died.. Now the maffia is trying to figure out why target n°2 is still here? In that scenario there are 2 players that are very active on the matter (you being the one who wants to find the cop).

PS: Could you please vote like so many asked already so we can see what happens?
PS2: If not for the big red flags you ticked on so many inconsistenties before:
A) this post sounds like a whole new Loose.
B) Almost like somebody is typing it for you. You sound genuine, thought out and believable here (so unlike before) but still sounds you wanna find somebody (the cop)

[strike wolf]

Strike posted that in elementary mafia Doc protects Cop night 1.

1. So maybe the reason there was only 1 killing was because mafia targetted Cop as well as Charle.
2. Granted it is possible that Charle was doctor to whoever the Cop is.

The reason I asked if a town win meant Charle won (answer I've been given is yes) is Cop should declare what he discovered - because cop would win if town wins even if cop is killed.
Because of reason 1 above the information if revealed will help town - but if kept to Cop because of reason 1 there has to be a strong danger that mafia will kill cop making the information useless to town because it would die with cop.

Cop I think you should declare what you discovered now - for the greater benefit of town.

This is either the scummiest or stupidest thing you've said yet. Cop is arguably the most valuable town role even more so than doc and should not claim unless they have very good reason to do so. Cop is more valuable than any individual role they might clear from an innocent investigation.

[TrafalgarLaw01]

I am actually surprised to see Loose can still comment as well. I thought the vanish would mean he wouldnt comment anymore. But seems just as his voted against were deleted. Certainly Loose is a powerfull character but what is his alignment?
Still find it so weird that he trys to reveal roles. and worst of all the Cop after losing the Doc.

First I though he was the dog in the Tick as he is Voiceless (Townie), Then With the mist thing I tough about the bombman as apparently use smoke granedes (Villain).
I would him to vote as well or explain why he said town will find him useful from D2 on

If someone is more versed in the Tick could come up with more accurate description as I have never seen the show.

[DirtyDishSoap]

Vote Count:

PepeAtila : 1 (DirtyDishSoap)
Razorvich : 1 (Ragian)
Loose Canon : 0 ()

No Vote : 16 (*Pixar*, Charle, Darin44, DukeHazzard, Extreme Ways, fusibaseball, General Bax, Loose Canon, Maxleod, PepeAtila, Razorvich, SoN!c, strike wolf, swang918, TrafalgarLaw01, traffic133)

18 Alive, 10 votes needed to lynch

So wait a Tick.

His vote count disappears entirely? Uhhh. I'm not entirely sure what to make of this.

And please for the love of God, do not reveal if you're a cop. What kind of insane babble am I reading here?

[degaston]

Clarification: Loose can still talk, but he can't be lynched today.

Carry on

[SoN!c]

In any case : lynching Loose Canon is out of the question for today. So best scenario for this day is to search elsewhere. Loose wants Cop to reveal himself so that is the final nodge if you still had loose on a 50-50 scale by now.. I say Aye to us voting to lynch Loose on D3.

Loose got so many red flags i would find it very hard to believe he is town and then this?. C'mon; He could have jumped on the Human Bullit ticket out but did not. He said he was not going to reveal his role even if he got a lynch vote.. Why would you do that? Because revealing his role is him admitting being mafia and that is getting the lynch anyway?.; and numerous inconsistencies..

But if we wanna (have to) search elsewhere and we believe Loose is mafia then let's trail back the mist banks that occured like "magic" ? Like Loose defending Pixar when Pix got smoking hot who came to defend Loose? I got some clues in my notebook but nothing that gets the mafia radar spining off the charts like it got on Loose.

For now A+B says C is Pix, with D being a mastermind

PS: we need to hurry up now we can't lynch Loose today, because scum is gonna kill all loose ends tonight for sure, and D will get a good mist going knowing it's almost completely undetectable for most until it's too late..

[*Pixar*]

Thinking I got bailed out by Loose was a total coincidence. I was actually about to claim until I got fast posted by that vote count which made me retract my claim, because something was going on with Loose's vote. But yes I would like to see Loose vote for someone today just to see what happens. And how does Loose not being able to be lynched today "confirm" him as town? Maybe he's got one action to use all game and he used it now since he was getting pressured?

[SoN!c]

Thinking I got bailed out by Loose was a total coincidence. I was actually about to claim until I got fast posted by that vote count which made me retract my claim, because something was going on with Loose's vote. But yes I would like to see Loose vote for someone today just to see what happens. And how does Loose not being able to be lynched today "confirm" him as town? Maybe he's got one action to use all game and he used it now since he was getting pressured?

Yeah, gotcha. Also i know the case against you is pretty slim..

Basically your case is build on Loose coming to your "rescue" (but that could have had other reasons too). Anyway we need to search elsewhere..so where do we start?

"And how does Loose not being able to be lynched today "confirm" him as town?"
= +1

PS1:

"Eat my smoke, copper!"

= one of the mad midnight bomber favorite quote's..

PS2: "Bombs": The midnight bomber has an unknown number of bombs in his possession. The means with which he created or otherwise acquired them is unknown but one of them is the "Smoke Bomb": he used a smoke bomb to escape from Arthur in the Comet Club washroom.

So a smoke bomb AND going for the copper (slang for cop)??

[DukeHazzard]

Thinking I got bailed out by Loose was a total coincidence. I was actually about to claim until I got fast posted by that vote count which made me retract my claim, because something was going on with Loose's vote. But yes I would like to see Loose vote for someone today just to see what happens. And how does Loose not being able to be lynched today "confirm" him as town? Maybe he's got one action to use all game and he used it now since he was getting pressured?

Convenient to say that now. I don't think you had any intention to claim as you had previously stated that in day 1. Still fos in my books. Also, pretty perfect timing for Loose to bail you out. Too perfect to be coincidence.

I was reading through this all from the start of the day as I haven't been around for a couple of days. I was inclined to vote on Loose as I also feel he is scummy. But I didn't get here in time and it wouldn't have mattered anyways. Still don't get why you're searching for a specific character to claim (cop?) Also, Why do you continue to ignore people asking you to vote? It's a high probability that I will be voting you D3.