Super Mario Mafia - TOWN WIN!

[kwanton]

Putting the third vote on your scum partner when there's 5 to lynch and when as you said town can't afford mistakes? When furthermore the case was still very unclear?

Yes. Especially with 5 to lynch. Since there are 9 left and no scum have been killed yet, that's exactly what I would do. If we lynch exile, the next day there will be seven if I don't get lucky with my bus driving. Then there would be 5 people who voted for scum and 2 people who didn't. I would go after the people who didn't vote scum.

[willis]

Of course. Does this mean you still believe Exile is the GF?

Yes, do we need to be concerned. Because if you are who you say you are, you should know this.

How would I know? GF tuns up town upon investigation. So there is still a chance that exile is the GF, but we need to lynch scum today. (Scum being serbia)

[Talapus]

Of course. Does this mean you still believe Exile is the GF?

Yes, do we need to be concerned. Because if you are who you say you are, you should know this.

How would I know? GF tuns up town upon investigation. So there is still a chance that exile is the GF, but we need to lynch scum today. (Scum being serbia)

Whoa, whoa, whoa. You've been battered and beaten the last two nights and missing. How in the world are we to believe you are sane?!? Just because you say "lynch Serbia", it doesn't mean I'm willing too. Look around you dude, we're in trouble unless we lynch some gaurenteed scum tonight.

[ga7]

Yes. Especially with 5 to lynch. Since there are 9 left and no scum have been killed yet, that's exactly what I would do. If we lynch exile, the next day there will be seven if I don't get lucky with my bus driving. Then there would be 5 people who voted for scum and 2 people who didn't. I would go after the people who didn't vote scum.

Well I don't know, the only time I saw this kind of things happen was in Cat mafia when Mandy voted Kalish, but he was an usurper. I don't really see how it's a good trade-off for scum to make the endgame longer on purpose, with Mario still being alive etc...

[ga7]

Whoa, whoa, whoa. You've been battered and beaten the last two nights and missing. How in the world are we to believe you are sane?!? Just because you say "lynch Serbia", it doesn't mean I'm willing too. Look around you dude, we're in trouble unless we lynch some gaurenteed scum tonight.

Why on earth would Mario be insane? What lynch is more guaranteed than a lynch backed-up with an investigation of our only cop?

[willis]

Of course. Does this mean you still believe Exile is the GF?

Yes, do we need to be concerned. Because if you are who you say you are, you should know this.

How would I know? GF tuns up town upon investigation. So there is still a chance that exile is the GF, but we need to lynch scum today. (Scum being serbia)

Whoa, whoa, whoa. You've been battered and beaten the last two nights and missing. How in the world are we to believe you are sane?!? Just because you say "lynch Serbia", it doesn't mean I'm willing too. Look around you dude, we're in trouble unless we lynch some gaurenteed scum tonight.

Well how would I prove to you that I am sane?

[Serbia]

IF he's the cop.

I'm Albatoss. I'm the mayor. I can prevent a lynch if I want to. Except my own. Kinda useless, but I'm NOT scum. Willis is probably a cop, but I'm questioning his sanity.

And yeah, weird role, weird character, but I'm not the mod.

[Talapus]

Why on earth would Mario be insane? What lynch is more guaranteed than a lynch backed-up with an investigation of our only cop?

Insane because he's been beaten up both nights. Also, why would he be in hiding. He's our hero, what is there to hide from?

[Serbia]

Of course. Does this mean you still believe Exile is the GF?

Yes, do we need to be concerned. Because if you are who you say you are, you should know this.

How would I know? GF tuns up town upon investigation. So there is still a chance that exile is the GF, but we need to lynch scum today. (Scum being serbia)

Whoa, whoa, whoa. You've been battered and beaten the last two nights and missing. How in the world are we to believe you are sane?!? Just because you say "lynch Serbia", it doesn't mean I'm willing too. Look around you dude, we're in trouble unless we lynch some gaurenteed scum tonight.

Well how would I prove to you that I am sane?

I don't think you can. But what Tal is saying makes sense. Can you take those beatings, and not expect some sort of effect? They're written in for a reason, you know.

[ga7]

Why on earth would Mario be insane? What lynch is more guaranteed than a lynch backed-up with an investigation of our only cop?

Insane because he's been beaten up both nights. Also, why would he be in hiding. He's our hero, what is there to hide from?

I just checked, that beaten up thing happened only in night 2. You're making things up there.

[kwanton]

Well I don't know, the only time I saw this kind of things happen was in Cat mafia when Mandy voted Kalish, but he was an usurper. I don't really see how it's a good trade-off for scum to make the endgame longer on purpose, with Mario still being alive etc...

Just think about it. If you were scum and it looked like you're scum buddy was getting lynched, wouldn't you vote him to avoid suspicion yourself? That's what I would do.

For the record, I believe willis's claim 100% since he was in the mason group. Unless both him and ga7 have coordinated this which is highly unlikely IMO. I also believe 100% that exile is the GF now. Like willis said, I'd rather lynch a GF than a scum peon.

[ga7]

What were fircola's findings in the previous nights?

Night 1 - exile town
Night 2 - PCM I was blocked
Night 3 - Serbia scum

Ok in Night 2 he was beaten up. Because he was roleblocked

[ga7]

Just think about it. If you were scum and it looked like you're scum buddy was getting lynched, wouldn't you vote him to avoid suspicion yourself? That's what I would do.

For the record, I believe willis's claim 100% since he was in the mason group. Unless both him and ga7 have coordinated this which is highly unlikely IMO. I also believe 100% that exile is the GF now. Like willis said, I'd rather lynch a GF than a scum peon.

So, after everything you said about town not being able to afford a mistake, you prefer us, town, to blindly trust your counter-claim rather than ensure our future with lynching an investigated scum. Yeah, I get your thinking.

[kwanton]

So, after everything you said about town not being able to afford a mistake, you prefer us, town, to blindly trust your counter-claim rather than ensure our future with lynching an investigated scum. Yeah, I get your thinking.

How many times have you reiterated that I've said that? So many that I've lost count.....For someone who bases a lot of his arguments on what I said, you don't seem to trust me much

Like I said, I am sure that exile is the GF. I would say lynch serbia if I wasn't just as convinced of exile's scumminess.

[Talapus]

What were fircola's findings in the previous nights?

Night 1 - exile town
Night 2 - PCM I was blocked
Night 3 - Serbia scum

Ok in Night 2 he was beaten up. Because he was roleblocked

Ok I see that sort of. I totally buy willis' claim becas=use kwatons right, it's hard to coordinate a cooberating story like that if he was lying. But willis was convinced exile was scum and he thinks Serbia is as well. So, in this case I say we eliminate the GF becuase he's the one who's offing us in the night. I day we go after Serbia tomorrow since with the GF dead he can't kill us tonight anyway. That means tomorrow will be over in all of 5 minutes...

[ga7]

Well sorry for being redundant But I just think you're right there and find so many inconsistencies with your further posts that it strikes out. You didn't really answer my question, if you're convinced both are scum why vote for the one that all us townies are unsure of?

[Talapus]

So, vote - - - exile.

[The1exile]

Anyone else think that we might have found the scum in kwan, serbia and tappy?

[ga7]

Ok I see that sort of. I totally buy willis' claim becas=use kwatons right, it's hard to coordinate a cooberating story like that if he was lying. But willis was convinced exile was scum and he thinks Serbia is as well. So, in this case I say we eliminate the GF becuase he's the one who's offing us in the night. I day we go after Serbia tomorrow since with the GF dead he can't kill us tonight anyway. That means tomorrow will be over in all of 5 minutes...

That I don't understand. The goon alone can't NK? I thought they always could if the GF dies. Can someone that I find not scummy confirm this?

[willis]

What were fircola's findings in the previous nights?

Night 1 - exile town
Night 2 - PCM I was blocked
Night 3 - Serbia scum

Ok in Night 2 he was beaten up. Because he was roleblocked

Ok I see that sort of. I totally buy willis' claim becas=use kwatons right, it's hard to coordinate a cooberating story like that if he was lying. But willis was convinced exile was scum and he thinks Serbia is as well. So, in this case I say we eliminate the GF becuase he's the one who's offing us in the night. I day we go after Serbia tomorrow since with the GF dead he can't kill us tonight anyway. That means tomorrow will be over in all of 5 minutes...

I'm pretty sure mafia can kill without a GF

[kwanton]

Well sorry for being redundant But I just think you're right there and find so many inconsistencies with your further posts that it strikes out. You didn't really answer my question, if you're convinced both are scum why vote for the one that all us townies are unsure of?

I did answer that question. I said I was 100% sure that exile is the GF and I would rather lynch the GF than a mafia goon. And I'm not even the first to believe he is the GF. Whether you think he is or not isn't my problem, but I know he is. That is why I voted for him and why I think we should lynch him instead.

[ga7]

Anyone else think that we might have found the scum in kwan, serbia and tappy?

Right now I find more credible that side than you being the GF. Of course I could be wrong, but again the argument of not lynching a proven scum because you might be the GF is non-sense. We can't pick which claim is the more convenient just like that, there is no proof.
For that reason I'll fight till we lynch Serbia

[Talapus]

I'm pretty sure mafia can kill without a GF

Then why try to convince us that exile was the GF if you already knew Serbia was scum? That just makes you the target for the for the NK tonight. Are you sure of your sanity?

[Serbia]

ga7 just hates me. I'm not scum people.

[kwanton]

Right now I find more credible that side than you being the GF. Of course I could be wrong, but again the argument of not lynching a proven scum because you mightbe the GF is non-sense. We can't pick which claim is the more convenient just like that, there is no proof.
For that reason I'll fight till we lynch Serbia

Not might. Is. He is the GF. All the evidence points to it IMO. That's why I voted for him. I'm sure he is.