Athkatla Mafia - Talassians [mandy] WIN! (and Koesen)

[Neutrino]

So... much... randomness...


My thoughts thus far:

While killing NES is a reasonable standard Day 1 strategy, it probably shouldn't be done too quickly. If a simple, no-questions-asked bandwagon develops, then what little value there is in Day 1 will be lost.

Anyway, keep up the randomness!

[ga7]

Well, I do think Nes has been the scummiest so far with his bandwagon vote with the excuse of getting a roleclaim off a non-poster (very credible really) but it's obviously a backup plan. I mean, if I was scum partner with Nes, the first thing I'd want to do is get him lynched to clear me So I don't think much info would transpire from his lynch.
That said, I'll Vote Pancake on the off chance he's scum. Plus I never got to lynch him

[mr. incrediball]

Unvote vote Incrediball as I don't know who you are.

screw you

[mr. incrediball]

unvote
vote LSU Tiger Josh cause he voted for me and likes american football

[Anarkistsdream]

Guys, we need to come to some sort of concensus...

[XenHu]

unvote

With recent knowledge of how crap NES is after day 1, I have to vote NES for his over-all annoying-ness and not getting how to play mafia..

Meh. I say leave NES alone for now. He's never going to learn if we always kill him Day 1. Although, I do see your point.

-X

That recent knowledge of how he plays even after day 1 is stuck in my mind. We kept him alive because his mason partner told us he was his partner, which turned out true.

We let him learn, but still, he played like a newb and was annoying throughout the whole game. I wanted to lynch him so badly, but I couldn't.

So my vote stands.

What I want to know is, if a majority of players think he is a pain, why aren't the mods blacklisting him?

Again, I see your point, but I'm not liking the idea of lynching him, at least right now.

Nothing would be gained because lynching NES is a 'standard procedure'.

-X

[The1exile]

Vote Count
Fircoal: Syzygy, kwanton (2)
cena-rules: MTG, XGS (2)
PCM: NESconqueror, (1)
NES: PCM, firth, jake, nag, jnd, skittles (6)
Eddie: narc, cena, NES (3)
XGS: Neut, incrediball (2)
jnd94: Spurgistan (1)
Josh: incrediball (1)

[cena-rules]

Vote Count
Fircoal: Syzygy, kwanton (2)
cena-rules: MTG, XGS (2)
PCM: NESconqueror, (1)
NES: PCM, firth, jake, nag, jnd, skittles (6)
Eddie: narc, cena, NES (3)
XGS: Neut, incrediball (2)
jnd94: Spurgistan (1)
Josh: incrediball (1)

do we have a deadline??

[Anarkistsdream]

Guys.....

Why are people voting Fircoal when he is not in this game?

And, if he IS in this game, he has not posted once and his name is not on the first page list.

So, I ask... WTF???

Unvote: Eddie

Vote: Syzygy

[The1exile]

You have about 36 hours left. Deadline is 11 am GMT, though I won't be on to post the death scene until maybe 3 hours later.

[The1exile]

Guys.....

Why are people voting Fircoal when he is not in this game?

And, if he IS in this game, he has not posted once and his name is not on the first page list.

So, I ask... WTF???

Unvote: Eddie

Vote: Syzygy

Fircoal, along with mandalorian2298 and got tonkaed are participating in the meta-mafia. As gods, they have their own problems to worry about, however you can lynch them but like if you lynch me, a LOT of people suffer a lot of bad consequences.

[Anarkistsdream]

Clarified... Rodger Dodger... My vote stands.

[ga7]

After incrediball's last intervention, I changed my mind: lynching a noob is a necessity. I don't care which one though
Well, I don't know what the gods will do, and pity the people having as god one of these 3, but it seems to me that putting a vote there is a good way to lay low... FOS Syzygy & Kwan
Unvote

[Syzygy]

What sort of consequences are we talking about here?

Unvote: Fircoal. I don't want to invoke some kind of divine wrath on my ass.

[cena-rules]

What sort of consequences are we talking about here?

Unvote: Fircoal. I don't want to invoke some kind of divine wrath on my ass.

lol

[Sierra_Leon]

Alright, I've thought it over a little more. It's true that we won't learn much from lynching an inactive or a noob, but how will we learn anything more from lynching a more experienced player? There's no telling the real votes from the random votes on day one anyway. So lynching an inactive or a noob might be the best solution if there are no scumtells to be found.

However, after doing some digging I ran across this again:

Uh, random vote cena

How can a 4th vote on someone be random? FOS Mtg

This is in my eyes the best (if not only) scumtell so far, so IMO we're better off lynching MTG than we are lynching NES or Eddie.

vote muy_thaiguy

[firth4eva]

oh man. Nes up to his n00by antics again

unvite as i think he isnt scum but i ahd voted nark anyway

[cena-rules]

Alright, I've thought it over a little more. It's true that we won't learn much from lynching an inactive or a noob, but how will we learn anything more from lynching a more experienced player? There's no telling the real votes from the random votes on day one anyway. So lynching an inactive or a noob might be the best solution if there are no scumtells to be found.

However, after doing some digging I ran across this again:

Uh, random vote cena

How can a 4th vote on someone be random? FOS Mtg

This is in my eyes the best (if not only) scumtell so far, so IMO we're better off lynching MTG than we are lynching NES or Eddie.

vote muy_thaiguy

you make a good point

unvote vote mtg

[firth4eva]

yeah fos mtg

[The1exile]

Vote Count
Fircoal: kwanton (1)
Syz: narc (1)
cena-rules: MTG, XGS (2)
PCM: NESconqueror, (1)
NES: PCM, jake, nag, jnd, skittles (6)
Eddie: NES (1)
XGS: Neut, incrediball (2)
jnd94: Spurgistan (1)
Josh: incrediball (1)
MTG: Sierra, cena (2)

[Anarkistsdream]

Vote Count
Fircoal: kwanton (1)
cena-rules: MTG, XGS (2)
PCM: NESconqueror, (1)
NES: PCM, jake, nag, jnd, skittles (6)
Eddie: NES (1)
XGS: Neut, incrediball (2)
jnd94: Spurgistan (1)
Josh: incrediball (1)
MTG: Sierra, cena (2)

You missed my vote for Syzygy.

[The1exile]

whoops, fixed.

[Sierra_Leon]

Alright, I've thought it over a little more. It's true that we won't learn much from lynching an inactive or a noob, but how will we learn anything more from lynching a more experienced player? There's no telling the real votes from the random votes on day one anyway. So lynching an inactive or a noob might be the best solution if there are no scumtells to be found.

However, after doing some digging I ran across this again:

Uh, random vote cena

How can a 4th vote on someone be random? FOS Mtg

This is in my eyes the best (if not only) scumtell so far, so IMO we're better off lynching MTG than we are lynching NES or Eddie.

vote muy_thaiguy

you make a good point

unvote vote mtg

Thank you for agreeing with me, but FOS cena anyway for being very quick to hop on yet another bandwagon (NES and Eddie being the other bandwagons). Keeping my vote on mtg though.

[Anarkistsdream]

I blame that more on Cena being young than anything... *grin*

However, it is worthy of an FOS

[cena-rules]

Alright, I've thought it over a little more. It's true that we won't learn much from lynching an inactive or a noob, but how will we learn anything more from lynching a more experienced player? There's no telling the real votes from the random votes on day one anyway. So lynching an inactive or a noob might be the best solution if there are no scumtells to be found.

However, after doing some digging I ran across this again:

Uh, random vote cena

How can a 4th vote on someone be random? FOS Mtg

This is in my eyes the best (if not only) scumtell so far, so IMO we're better off lynching MTG than we are lynching NES or Eddie.

vote muy_thaiguy

you make a good point

unvote vote mtg

Thank you for agreeing with me, but FOS cena anyway for being very quick to hop on yet another bandwagon (NES and Eddie being the other bandwagons). Keeping my vote on mtg though.

I was considering voting him but it would be seen as an OMGUS vote. You gave me a reason so I voted