Thieves mafia THIEVES WIN

[jnd94]

What concerns me is, you were unlynchable that day, but why didn't the scum gun for you that night?

Predictability? The kill could be easily traced to some bandwagoners.

[kalishnikov]

Hmm, I don't like this one bit. I really think nag and I shouldn't die today as if that's not endgame, it will be damn close.

We need to be careful with this lynch, I'm not sure what else to say other then that. Damn I wish we had a cop...

[firth4eva]

My main FOS is on jnd.

[kalishnikov]

Yea, jnd has definitly been acting weird and somewhat scummy.

[Skoffin]

This game is lagging again. Pretty much everyone has been verified except JND... we makes him most likely scum, however if he is still unlynchable we're screwed. Just how it it we lose if you claim? We still have two claimed protective roles, so you should be fine.
And I'm not so sure about Nag.. has he claimed? And about from the money taken by LSU, has he been robbed? I think one of these two is scum, but which one is beyond me.

[kalishnikov]

The only one who really looks scummy to me right now is jnd.

I believe LSU about his newfound ability (it's not his style to lie about something like that, I'd be very surprised if he is), which leads me to also believe nagerous is town.

Hmm, perhaps LSU is onto something with the firth idea. I'd like for us to try and lynch jnd again and have LSU take firth's money tonight to see how much he has, that would provide some leads.

The problem is though, if we try to lynch jnd again and it fails again, nag and I are both dead. I'm fairly sure nag's town and I know I am so this could be very bad for us if jnd doesn't die and we get back no money from the failed lynch.

Any ideas, anyone?

[kwanton]

VOTE COUNT!

Nag- 1 (Jnd)
Jnd- 1 (nag)

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Offhand has anyone actually been robbed that firth says he "protected" some money on? If not, I would say lynch him today as that would give the money to those that I've confirmed and I can "rob" Jnd tonight and give the money to one of the 2 that I've "verified" via the amounts they had when I pulled my Robin Hood act.

Vote Firth

[nagerous]

I pretty much agree with everything you say kalish. It just depends if we should bite the bullet and try and lynch jnd or go for the safe lynch in firth who is more likely to be pro-town. I'm in a bit of a quandry either way.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Here's the thing though, there is no guaranttee that we'll be able to have JND die today and if both of you die then we could be in serious trouble in regards to possibly getting close to lynch - 0. I would personally rather make sure we get a lynch on a possible scum rather than risking a lynch on someone that had the lynch not go through already once and have the two I'm positive about die from starvation

[firth4eva]

Day 8

It seems that the amount of robberies has gone up. Things are getting worse.

6 alive 4 to lynch.

deadline is in 3 days. That's about 11:00 A.M. Thursday, November 8th EST

Does this mean the scum has recruited?

[firth4eva]

C;mon you can't sit back forever. ya gotta do something about these thieves. First you think "hey I'll just use my pikachu and electrocute everyone and live happily ever after wif that kwan guy". Then you realized pikachus don't exist and kwan actually hates you. With your morale crushed, you decide to go into accounting.

You now have a night power. As a CPA, you can review the financial records of any player. Send me the name of a player and I will tell you how much money they have.

I hope you've been keeping track of how much money you started with and how the money has been moving around during the lynches Your win condition is still the same. Any questions just PM me. Have fun

*yeah I just came up with this to spice up the game. Don't tell the others my reasons *

This seems a lot like LSU's role but I don't understand LSU's role completely. You say you rob from the rich and give to the poor but also investigate to see how much money they have?

And what do you mean by protected some money on?

[kalishnikov]

I think LSU meant 'has anyone been robbed when firth said he was protecting you' but just kinda got a word mixed up.

Also, I agree with you LSU and nag about pretty much everything. It's just gonna suck if we're wrong and lynch firth and he is a doc-like role. Then we're really screwed.

But if both nag and I die today I think it's pretty much game over for the town anyway. One, maybe two more deaths after that should put it at endgame I think.

[nagerous]

Anyone thought skoffin might be lying and did that thing with ga7 in order to look pro-town and it was in fact a setup organised by ga7 to make skoffin look pro-town. Look at the facts, skoffin said he looked after ga7's money every night. Even when roles like cop and bodyguard claimed, surely he would have protected their money and not ga7's thats highly suspicious. Also, we've had no news from him since, whos money has he been protecting, I think he may be lying..

[firth4eva]

Skoffin is a girl

[nagerous]

I know that, that was a typo I think or I wasn't thinking properly.

[Skoffin]

Where did I say 'everynight' I protected him a few nights, as soon as Firth claimed I started protecting him. Then I got my crazt theory and decided to try it out on Ga7 again before I mentioned it.
Why does this feel so omgus to me? You were all for a jnd lynch, then as soon as I mention you you turn on me. Now how about answering those questions I asked before, hm?

[nagerous]

I have answered them, I've said several times I'm a townie with no powers. I have also no cash and if you weren't skimming you will see that LSU took my cash last night all 16k of it and gave it to you. Do you think I would have that little if I was scum. Townies start with 10k each and I got 2k from each lynch I was in. You can count its not hard... Also, why push against me for a lynch or would you rather both kalish and me die tonight so you can finish the game tomorrow???

[Skoffin]

You got "I'm not so sure about Nag" as pushing? And I said apart from LSU robbing you, I wanted to know if you had been robbed any other times. This game was practicaly dead, I wanted to get it going again by posting what little ideas I have.

[kalishnikov]

So form what I gather, either Skoffin or firth has to be scum if we're following the claimed-roles logic. It's entirely possible that either (or both) are lying about their roles and employing scum tricks to make us think they've got protective town roles, quite easily done right now because everyone knows we've got nothing.

I guess the question is then, who do we believe more, firth or Skoffin? firth claimed his ability first but Skoffin's theory did out ga7 (again, could have been a sacrifice but I'm not sure, they really didn't need to do that).

[Skoffin]

Sorry, I just kinda find it funny that yesterday it went from Nag and Jnd to the two claimed protective roles Ah well I've still killed more scum then the rest of ye, so even if you decide to kill me I'll still claim victory

[jnd94]

Just like I said before, nagerous is scummy in my mind. But because of trying to tell you guys my role subtley, non one listens.

[Skoffin]

Subtlety does not work on my frail mind.

[jnd94]

Exactly why now you think I'm scum.

[kalishnikov]

So then why should we lynch nag instead of either jnd, Skoffin or firth?

Thats directed at jnd, Skoffin and firth but anyone feel free to answer.