I think I can understand AAFitz theory and there is one big thing that brings your theory and atheism together and one big thing that bring your theory and religion together; you believe that we aren't special or choosen, and you believe that something intentionally created the materia. (thats how I understood you, correct me if I'm wrong) A lot of religions say we are special or choosen, and atheists say that we aren't choosen! Atheist explanation of the creating of the world is that materia was created through energy tightly compressing into one little area until it the big bang finally occured. The energy who inturn created materia is explained to be created out of nothing, (this is one of the vaguest of the atheistic theories but that is the best teory to a very hard question, "How can anything at all exist if no one made it" "It made itself through a natural process we so far know very little about" )
And religious people says god made us! I'm an Atheist and I go for what my logik tells me, when I'm confronted with a problem I don't use faith to try to solve it. And it's not because I'm a heartless person I just think that it's the way to solve intellectual problems that is how most atheists want to solve a problem. And I'm aware of that some people use their faith in the said situation, And often thoose people are religious, not really hard to understand that people who like to use logik will never buy religion, and people who use faith will never buy atheism. It's two different types of people, and to try to convince someone who for an exampel is not exepting faith to solve intellectual problems is never going to work, he want other argument then a cristian can give him, and vice versa!
That all said, I'm in complete agreement with AAFitz that we should question everything at least once, even the obvious. 
