Reasons to vote for mitch (sorry for the redundant parts if you didn't skim through my posts)
madmitch wrote:Wow what a lucky night for us especially Thort, Dakky asking about actions does sound scummy but I think he might be on to something. Do we start all over with new suspects or should we be like Rags and stick to our D1 favorites and push them harder? I was suspicious of Thort until he was proven town and then Ifollowed Skoffin lead on Hot Shot but basically the vote was split and time ran out so there was not much pressure put on the suspects we had,right now I am thinking either MM or HS ,they seemed to be the popular ones at the moment
His first post of D2: raises concern over dakky's role fishing, only to double down on it. Also basically says he's going for a bandwagon. He does FOS dakky later on for his role fishing though.
madmitch wrote:Well I am screwed either way, get on the BW for Dakky or I will get voted out, Skoffin wants me to hammer him so I die for sure ,but I am not ready to leave this game yet,Dakky will pick me for sure if I get on the BW ,I like my town role and would like to live for another day, If there is another wagon that you guys want me to join I will join it
madmitch wrote:@ Rags, you are right,but I am actually scared, at least when someone votes for me I have a chanch to survive, here I don't think I will, OKAY I WILL as long it ir not the hammer, CAN I HAVE A VOTE COUNT PLEASE
Acting like he knows dakky is a bomb rather than a vengeful townie (though dakky's last post make it sounds like he may indeed kill the hammer.)
Incidentally, his soft-claim of a power roles doesn't seem in line with his role-fishing post, since if he had a power role, I would expect he would have said what he did during the night if he was agreeing with dakky.
Blatant copy-paste below, skip spoilers if you want
madmitch wrote:Wow what a lucky night for us especially Thort, Dakky asking about actions does sound scummy but I think he might be on to something. Do we start all over with new suspects or should we be like Rags and stick to our D1 favorites and push them harder? I was suspicious of Thort until he was proven town and then Ifollowed Skoffin lead on Hot Shot but basically the vote was split and time ran out so there was not much pressure put on the suspects we had,right now I am thinking either MM or HS ,they seemed to be the popular ones at the moment
madmitch wrote:@ BuJaber, you are right I am very cautious in this game, I am trying to change my play style and it is hard to break bad habits,
I am still wary of THORTH maybe he is 3rd party ? just something off there, FOS against Dakky and Rags for asking about who did what? but why was Dakky voted for and not Rags ? they are both guilty, I can relate to what Flores (that little ray of sunshine...Not
) said because I take a while to read and post,I am a little older than most or all of you,I remember having a phone on the wall with a crank ,our number was 1 long crank and 3 short ones,no shit guys ,anyway I am torn between H.S. and MM from D1 ,not quite sure who to vote for yet and I will wait for a while
How can you be say you were suspicious of Thor (notice the past tense), but then go on another post a few hours later saying you still are, especially when the only thing he did in between was FOS you. Kinda looks like an OMGUS to me. Also thor has been confirmed town, I don't see why you would think he's third party. Unless your role pm doesn't talk about Thorin's company, that is, or you have good reasons to think he's in a cult now. (
1st post 2nd post)
madmitch wrote:@ Thort skim much?? already voted for Dakky, and wanting to be MVP is just plain scummy, there is something not right about you ? maybe Dakky is right and you started of as an innocent child but turned into something else like 3rd party, hell I don't know ? I just don't like your attitude in this game.
Has been agreeing with dakky a lot. mitch actually started saying he was still wary of thor before dakky in what looked like an OMGUS moment (re:spoilers) though, but he doubled down later.
OMGUS moment in D1 when he asked dakky to keep pressuring thor instead of him just after dakky said he believed thor was town.
People have also raised issues of him being overly defensive
Reasons to vote for dakky:
- Very scummy beginning of the day, and he said he wasn't even trying to get lynched (lying about it being LV's first game, voting for thor, asking for a role claim, ...)
- Possibly tries to scare people off from voting for him, first saying he would kill thor, then whoever hammers him (btw, what's up with that list of suspects if he just wants to kill the hammer? Why even come up with it?)
- Inconsistent on what his role say
dakky21 wrote:because the more people is on me, the more damage it will cause (I'm not saying about lynch, you can lynch me without consequences I believe).
While before he said someone (read
one person) would die with him if he gets lynched
- Skimming what seems like a lot of posts, since there have been a lot of talks on who we'd want the target to be.
- I probably forgot other reasons
TBH, it's a thight choice between dakky and mitch. I am totally fine with hammering if no one does it soonish before the deadline, but for now I will stick with mitch.
People who I consider good choices for a potential shot from dakky
- HS & MM: minimal activity, and they both had BWs going against them on D1, so it could give us info
- mitch: not as eager after he soft-claimed, as he soft-claimed a power role, but still looks very scummy to me
- recent FOS to MudPuppy:
MudPuppy wrote:BuJaber wrote:For the hesitant/cautious lot.. if y'all want to wait for IP's replacement we will wait. But if a deadline is announced I expect a lynch. We have enough good suspects that we can manage this. Any delays then would look very scummy.
I,
as a member of the hesitant/cautious lot, am on board with this approach. I prefer to wait for a replacement to join but also don't want to see another no-lynch day.
MudPuppy wrote:
I suggest you don't shoot Thor. Pretty fine with whoever you think best after that. Not sure I understand who your groups are or why you group them in that fashion... but whatever floats your boat. If you think random is best, then go for it. Whatever you choose, we'd get some good information.
I don't see how you can advocate caution, then say on your next post you're on board with dakky killing at random.
Finally, and this discussion got burried down over the debate over whether we should lynch dakky, but skoff posted a while ago that he'd like everyone to post who his top 3 scum picks were and I think it's a good idea.
So far, I've seen such lists from DDS, Flores, me and BuJ (sorry if I forgot anybody)
Minister Masket wrote:Incidentally I wouldn't even bother attempting to aim for the MVP award. I got it for the Lion King game...and my reward? Nothing!
Just making sure, you know the reward is supposed to be credits and you'd need to redeem your premium membership through the store right? I remember seeing a post (I think it was by Mets) saying the credits were issued. You should file a e-ticket or pm whoever said that if you don't have them credits.
. Of course, tomorrow, we'll vote somebody else... 
.
? Caught you there, didn't I?